I think it’s obvious to anyone who knows just a little bit about the caper that Sharman will be an integral part of our side Integral in what position? Certainly not as a forward. He has played 7 AFL games this season for 4 goals. He can't even hold his place in the forward line, being moved down b...

Tim Membrey also gets most shots that are expected to be kicked. It would be good to compare his stats. He has endured some wayward periods in his career, but also some "sharpshooter" periods. One of Membrey's wayward periods was when Ben Dixon was hired as goal missing coach, i don't kno...

Meanwhile convicted criminal burglar Marlion Pickett got to play with Richmond in a grand final after being released from jail. He is now back before the courts again for burglary. https://www.watoday.com.au/national/western-australia/disclosure-issues-magistrate-unhappy-as-marlion-pickett-s-court-...

Lucky escape IMHO.

Good first quarter for the Zebras 45-20. And all three Kangas goals were from dubious umpiring decisions: the first coming after a dubious free kick in the ruck contest, the second after an "over the shoulder" tackle that wasn't, and the third after Greenwood of the Kangas manhandled O'Co...

murray 66 wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2024 10:21pm It was a good win mate not being negative, but it was Nth Melbourne remember....
With Dow, Henry & Clarke to come back in, it will sort itself out!

C L A R K.

5. Sinclair
4. Wilson
3. Hayes
2. NWM
1. Windy

Scollop wrote: ↑Fri 03 May 2024 7:44pm

SaintPav wrote: ↑Fri 03 May 2024 6:34pm Collard has been an emergency so he can't be that far off.

Norf were really into him and he was keen too from what I have been told.

Carlton fans were saying that SOS picked him because he knew Carlton wanted him. They had next pick after us

So? Probably bulls*** anyway.

The trouble with NGA kids is that we cannot match a bid until pick 40 so if these guys are guns they will go before then. Northern states have no such restrictions. We were lucky with Owens & Windy as they went after pick 20 which was the bar that year. McKenzie our NGA that the dorks grabbed l...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Thu 02 May 2024 10:23am A lot of it seemed pretty balanced to me.

My are so many on here obsessed with playing the victim?

Your avatar which I have only now just noticed really suits you dudley

I can assure you no one is more vocal and proactive to the AFL than Basset. He is a true Sainter so when the supporters feel an injustice has been done, I promise you he is just another disgruntled supporter who actually has a voice to the AFL. And he uses it. But as we all know it’s a fine line. U...

Much like Brayshaw changing direction into Maynard's flying bump/attempt to smother ... if he doesn't change direction Maynard may only just clip him Great argument, except that you're wrong about there ever being any possibility of Maynard missing Brayshaw. Watchthe front on replay (1 min 14 into ...

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Mon 29 Apr 2024 11:09am

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Mon 29 Apr 2024 9:21am Lets call it what it is - not cheating - but incompetence by overpaid non-professional un-professionals

If that were the case wouldn't the poor decisions be the same but be equally split between teams so free kick counts would not be so ridiculously one sided?

Yep. 100%

What do we know about the current senior umpiring group? Most seem athletic enough, not many spew at 3/4 time or cramp up. We know they are largely respectful of each other's decisions, not demurring even when they know a mistake has been made. Nice tight and supportive. We know they have collectiv...

B.M wrote: ↑Sun 28 Apr 2024 6:21pm Gary ‘the glove’ Payton?

typo mate, just a typo.

That's a very interesting analysis cwrcyn, well done! With a 2-5 record after 7 games St Kilda have certainly not followed up on their good form last year when they also started the season with a long injury list. The big difference this year is that unlike in 2023 in most games St Kilda have not p...

In a few weeks we get a lot of players back! Hopefully not too many more get injured in the meantime?! Clark - 1 week King - 1 week Henry - 2 weeks Webster - 1 week Wood - 1 week Paton - 2 weeks Crouch - 2 weeks Hayes - playing VFL Dow - playing VFL That’s 9 players in the next 1-3 weeks returning ...

Killa wrote: ↑Sat 27 Apr 2024 9:06pm Extended for 2 years

So there you go

He was always going to re-sign.

This thread makes you wanna cry..very sad reading

Arie not far away./

3 weeks for Higgins is an AFL effing sick joke, but who is really surprised

Campbell deserves a game if Marshall is out.

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Sat 27 Apr 2024 4:17pm I'm unhappy with the errors that could be avoided.

One kick-in took too long, Port had covered all exits,
Nas kicked to Hill, Hill kicked short to Nas, it was turned over, and S*x Pest-Pepper snapped a goal.
Stuff like that which has us shaking our heads

Yep.

5. Wilson
4. Marshall
3. Sinclair
2.Hill
1.Wilkie

bobmurray wrote: ↑Sat 27 Apr 2024 1:35am The real get a grip view is currently, we are shite, that's a St Kilda thing, we have perfected it.

Yeah maybe but Port don't look like world beaters either