I hope it's correct that he has been offered a one year deal to stay with us. By all means, if another club is offering multiple years on better money then I wouldn't begrudge him for leaving. Tim has probably been told that a forward line of King, Sharman, Caminiti and Owens is the plan and he'd ju...

Keep it simple. Draft the two best available mids with 7 and 8

There's a big difference between resigning and re-signing

I just hope that the Higgins goal isn't recognised in furture as the moment we lost access to the new Chris Judd. Then again, it ws the most hilarious and enjoyable moment of the year and a fitting end to the season. It does remind me of when Daniel Wulf hit the post against Sydney to draw the fina...

Did we win more because King didn’t play? We won more with King out, not becaue he didn't play. Sharman still has an issue with consistency, puts in a good game about every 15 and we all get sucked in and think he's the answer to our forward line. Dropped away after the Essendon game, had a shocker...

At least we gave Carlton fans two hours of agony

D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Tue 27 Aug 2024 9:22pm No surprise with the first 4.

Agree it is perplexing to play Bonner so regularly then delist him. Similar to another PA backman Leinert.

Logan Austin too. Which Port half back who can't defend will we take and play for a season before delisting this year?

There is no justification for selecting Cameron over Marshall. Not the brightest group of selectors

Kicking 14.3 in the final 6 games should get him a new contract

It's not going to happen but it's an interesting thought experiment. If we completely abandon any hope of success for the next few years and switch to rebuild mode...as it sits, we'll likely have picks 6, 7 and 25 already. What would we yield from trading away high value senior guns? Approximate gue...

Not a bad call. He's taller and more agile than Hamill but it certainly seems that he's playing as the super physical third forward who provides fierce defensive pressure, which was Hamill's trademark. Similar wonky set shot too

Bonner for Tsatas, make it happen

5 Wilkie
4 Steele
3 Marshall
2 Sinclair
1 Wilson

Honourable mentions to Jones, Higgins and Clark

If there's a very talented young player wanting to move for opportunity or to return home (ie Steele, Membrey, Henry, Roberton) then we should pursue them but overall I think our focus needs to be on the draft. We can't take FA's because it would diminish our Battle compo. If anything I'd say we sho...

I think it's fair to say that we were a worse team with Max King in it than without him this year. But there are some huge caveats. 1 - King was nowhere near 100% at any point 2 - We played a dumb game plan involving bombing it on his head every time we go inside 50 3 - His support squad of Membrey,...

Neither were bad but I think it might be Gus and Jones out for Pou and Garcia. Dow sub.

mad saint guy wrote: ↑Mon 05 Aug 2024 5:48am Would like to see us blood Heath or Keeler but it seems like that's not happening this year.

Out: Bonner, Dow
In: Byrnes, Clark

Jones sub

This guy knows what's up

I'm ambivalent on this matter. On one hand, he'll likely continue down the path he's been on and fail...on the other, he has the talent to win a Brownlow and he's still young. We turned Gardi around...there's a lot more potential upside to having him on the list than Bonner/Ross/Allison next year

Killa wrote: ↑Wed 07 Aug 2024 6:00pm Bonner has played every game apart from 1 due to injury

Let's hope he gets the Rob Eddy treatment. In one day, then they come to their senses and boot him the next.

I think Membrey, Jones and Byrnes have showed enough recently to earn another year. We should probably cut Crouch loose unfortunately since degenerative knees at his age are not something that is often turned around. Heath is showing enough that I think we can let Campbell go. Van Es gets another ch...

Would like to see us blood Heath or Keeler but it seems like that's not happening this year.

Out: Bonner, Dow
In: Byrnes, Clark

Jones sub

I can 100% assure you we will not pay overs. Josh will do what’s best for his family-as he should ; yet the St Kilda footy club decade after decade cut loose great players often for little return Like who? only ones I can think of the last 30 years is Hall and maybe acres. and Considering Hall want...

If we take any FAs then our Battle compo would be reduced. Don't think that's on the cards this year

Mentioned this in the WCE match thread, but who teaches these blokes how to kick for goal? Or perhaps it's who's not helping them break bad habits? His ball drop is so bizarre, when I saw this it is pretty obvious why he is one of our worst shots on goal.   https://streamable.com/vk0o3v I shake my ...

5 Sharman
4 Nas
3 Marshall
2 Wilkie
1 Jones