I don't see a future for him... It's not due to lack of effort, I am sure he trains as hard as anyone and applies himself.. He is said to be the strongest player at the club. Sure genetics help his cause, but in a room full of AFL athletes, to be the strongest you would have to apply yourself irres...

He must surely be the classic example of a physically gifted athlete who couldn't realize his potential because of a general lack of interest or heart or both. He may wake up one day (probably in 10 years) and think to himself. "If only I had given it a crack, how good could I have been?" ...

I saw the word "retrospect" in a comment. You didn't need hindsight to know that what a lot of what St Kilda FC was doing was madness. There is a simple reality here. The Hawks ran a business that specialised in playing football. A succesful business will make strategic business decisions...

Big Deal. Move on.

Infamous day, no hiding from the fact it was a shameful act! Greening was seriously injured by an intentional behind the play king hit..... No excuses... O'Dea has to live with the fact he ruined the career of a spectacular footballer... And really, that's what he's best remembered for.... Not sure...

He reminds me of Allan Jenes. A little bit nervous in front of the camera. A leader in battle. A man for all seasons. A leader for our club. A man for all seasons should be changed to a man for many seasons. I might be wrong (and I'll know in 2.5 seconds on this forum) but Watters, Richardson and H...

He reminds me of Allan Jenes. A little bit nervous in front of the camera. A leader in battle.
A man for all seasons. A leader for our club.

I still cant fathom exactly how we ended up getting Billy. Appears like a massive coup. Well we traded McEvoy to Hawthorn who had previously indicated to Longer that they would take him from those nasty Lions. When Hawthorn secured McEvoy, Longer and the Saints both realised that we were a match ma...

No

I wonder what sort of objective tests they used to assess him? If they used self report type psychometric tests then he might have fooled them. If he has poor insight and lacks self awareness, which appears, in hindsight, to be the case, then it's a case of rubbish in, rubbish out. If they fell for...

We need money. We need a supporter with money. We need a supporter with money and leadership skills. We need a supporter with money and leadership skills and a passion for the club. We need a supporter with money and leadership skills and a passion for the club and is wiling to devote his/her full t...

StK has hung around for over a hundred years and only told the correct time once In the last thirty years hawthorn has managed 7 times It's not all about luck $ helps So did a change in Clubs zones. How many of those fabulous Hawthorn teams of the 70's and 80's contained players/champions that came...

BigMart wrote:StK has hung around for over a hundred years and only told the correct time once

In the last thirty years hawthorn has managed 7 times

It's not all about luck

$ helps

Dr Spaceman wrote:

satchmo wrote: Funny how a guess turns into fact.
I would have thought that Grant happily put his name to any opinions that he had. Still it's a good excuse to hammer home any prejudices that we have. And in that case I blame Laidley!

Yeah, me too!


Well either him or a dingo

Or a Schoolgirl

McEvoy on 3aw... Spoke well, disappointed and surprised that he is no longer a Saint. He mentioned other Saints players feeling the same (did not name names). Visited VFL Park (Hawks headquarters) for the first time yesterday. http://media.mytalk.com.au/3AW/AUDIO/151013SportsToday.mp3 his mention o...

What happened to all those people on here who said SW had to have his contract extended. There seemed to be many more in that camp and now i cant hardly see a post on it. Stand your ground. if you thought that then you are allowed to say you think the club is wrong. To me it was the only decision b...

Like it or not everyone is tradeable at the club for the right price. It's all a matter of weights and measures. It's a bit sad but it was sad swapping Stewart for Barrott and it was sad losing Big Carl to Melbourne and it was sad seeing Plugger go to Sydney which ironically allowed us to draft Dal...

Like it or not everyone is tradeable at the club for the right price. It's all a matter of weights and measures. It's a bit sad but it was sad swapping Stewart for Barrott and it was sad losing Big Carl to Melbourne and it was sad seeing Plugger go to Sydney which ironically allowed us to draft Dal ...

No more blaming the players. Exhausting and taxing game plan, try kicking "easy" goals after implementing that. No such thing as easy goals when you're stuffed. We are very hard on our players. Agree.. BTW is that you on twitter ? Agree. Isn't that the problem with Nick Riewoldt? Runs 2km...

Well at least Finey will be happy. 14 pages devoted to his views. I reckon everything has been said.
Let's not give him anymore attention and CHANGE THE SUBJECT.

Cut the crap everyone. He's a good coach and with all things being even we would have won 2 flags. Simple as that.

Good on him. A bit of positivity required.

If we can somehow get Crowley to tag Barlow we might win this one. If not we don't have a chance.

Is that all?

The Coach is the leader. He's doing a good job and he's got the strength to shoulder our losses.
And he's selling the message: "We want to go out on the field and win every game we play"
It's all about winning ultimately even if sometimes you don't get the 4 points from a game.