Slowest team ever picked by StK.....ten players who couldn't beat me over 100....and a further 5 who would just....to borrow a term...FFS

Could argue that Ferg was one of the reasons they won by 20 goals... Brooks chipped in with a couple of goals a week at FF for Casey (40 for the year) with a best bag against Tassie of 7....in 2005....his best footy was played in the ruck in 2007....he never took 12 marks in the F50 and never had 13...

well, will we whinge about the same old names after friday?....IMO we have a slow, boring team.... Macca, Steven - not ready for AFL footy.... Howard is terrible....at VFL level..lucky to play seniors IMO.... All McQualter and Ferg can do is play well at the second best level in the country (was the...

Why not????? Ball - simple fact is he is not in the same league as Judd (injuries or not) agreed......Judd was well known before the draft - he was not a smokey......he was a risk, but it was a risk NOT to take him Clarke - skilfull player predicted to go fom 10-15 in the 01 draft.....surprisingly p...

How in Gardners form? Gehrig's Form? Gram's Form? Maguire form (when he was picked) Dempsters Form? Raph's form? etc, etc......he just picks names Fiora brings one thing to the team we lack.......penetration by run and by foot.....but why would we want to move the ball quickly, when it goes against ...

For every good decision he has made, he made a poor one..... some of his recruiting of midsize tweeners from 98-2006 was mind boggling.... some of his selections were no-brainers.....and a couple of them were questionable.... Ball & Clarke taken at 2 & 5 in the hottest draft ever.... JB is a...

Blake, Fisher - been there before..........more stoppers....snore Hudghton - picked yet another underdone player..... King/Gardner/Kosi/Gehrig/Blake/Goddard/L.Fisher - plenty of speed there... Ball/Hayes/Armo/Dal in a lightning quick midfield..... Seriously - how bout picking some exciting players.....

Our most valuable player - when he plays well we win.........Lenny Hayes always plays well, we do not always win...

Lenny is our BEST player....

Most valuable player.........Nicks (either one)

should be Kosi - but his best games are rare....

1) Back line pace and skill.....who breaks lines and hits targets...ala Mcleod, Shaw, P.Burgoyne, Wojinski, Gilbee etc.... Gram - Not playing well Raph not playing well Sam playing KP 2) Mids that carry the ball....and hit targets....Foley, Ablett, Lewis, Boomer, S.Burgoyne, Judd, Stevens, Pendlebur...

Needs a couple of edits...not sure how to do that...

He is a talented TALL utility

He is too SMALL to play in the ruck.

The million dollar question......I am not sure anyone (including himself and the coaching staff know) He is an extremely talented all utility, an awesome mark, is mobile for his size....he should be a game buster......but for all that, at every position he lacks something...... Ruck - Not strong eno...

I acknowledge he has played very good games in the past......(although I dismiss that he has ever been consistently good defender, and I think he is seriously overrated on this Forum....) I also acknowledge he has come back from Leg injuries......and that takes time heal properly.... but... ATM he i...

Very average player with the footy, his disposal and awareness limits him as a player but he is very courageous..... a good clubman and very important to the list......he is adaptable and durable.....not in a top teams best 25, but a very handy back up.... Should be in the side ahead of Goose ATM......

proof is in the pudding...... I don't listen to jack that comes out of moorabbin, I don't have to, because I am not blind and can come to a very simple conclusion.... We defend first......the game plan is about limiting opponents.....accountability is Ross Lyon's favourite term... They shouldn't tre...

Gwilt has been VG at Casey.......Raph was BOG last week...

Maguire has shown ZERO!

C.Gardner would be unlucky....but is NOT damaging enough...

Not by keeping them in the game for three quarters.....and growing their confidence by giving them free possesions..... but by....attacking, the ball, the man and the scoreboard....they will start doubting themselves in the NO TIME! They match up alright with us, but are mentally scarred.....breathe...

What a load of RUBBISH..

Ross and Roo can spruke as much as they like.....about the Game Plan/style of play....but the PROOF is in the pudding.... We have gone fron the most attractive team in the AFL, which was billed big friday night games, season openers and huge crowds.....to the most hideous team to watch in recent his...

Worst thread for a while......try and get a memory longer than 4 weeks..... He is an absolute champion.. When Franklin/Mooney etc...have won 4 B&F's and multiple AA's and been voted by their peers as the best player in the land...then they can be compared to him....as an equal...not before... an...

Macca is NOT strong enough to compete with 30yo Brogan and Lade..... Luenberger hardly played time in Year 1 and was considered a freak (should have gone #1) Wood was excess, they did not chop him.....but got something they needed for him...he is a third year player... Kruezer is a freak and is play...

IMO disposal efficiency is very poor

Hayes, Montagna, Gram, Hudghton, Maguire, Jones, Blake are all hit and miss by foot....

Needs to stop trying to kick the ball too hard, and take a steadying step before kicking when at pace...

his move to a wing will see him win less footy......it is much easier at HB to get a kick from behind the ball...ATM his oponent is taking him deep, so Ross is pushing him further up the ground..

Goose will be lucky to get a game this week.....3 poss. vs Ess playing on the resting ruckman in a BP.... no influence the week before....struggled at Casey... Rix performed much better as a BP on the gorillas in the NAB his form for Casey has been strong (as usual) and exerts physical presence as a...

Am I a scool teacher??? maybe I am, but what do I teach???? Actually I have a few degrees, but I dont worry to much about grammer on an internet forum....I have enough trouble typing.... Are you one of these guys who police spelling and grammer in threads because you have to find some edge...because...

He is NOwhere near ready.....and won't be until late 2009