Probably the worst quarter of football I have seen in my 34 years as a st kilda supporter.. I honestly can't remember such garbage it looked like men against boys. Richo has to go, seems like a nice guy but we can't stand for that pathetic crap

Whatever Richo said at half time is working

McKenzie is being torn a new one.. Cameron on his way to 10 goals on him

Ross would have to be one of the poorest kicks in the comp.. I can't remember last time he hit a target. Hunter Clarke had an absolute horrible first half also.

wtf is Richo smiling for at the end... we would have lost to every other team with that performance. Brandon White.. love his effort but can't play a guy forward who misses 2 shots from the same spot 20 meters out...

Surely this bloke is worth a go? Lacks a bit of forward pressure but has averaged 2 goals a game in the last few seasons. Really surprised Geelong delisted him. We seemed interested prior to trade week and have apparently our interest has cooled? Thoughts?

I reckon we have 5-6 winnable games left. We’ll finish with no more than 7 wins and I reckon only Carlton and Brisbane will be worse off, Gold Coast maybe too. We are in massive, massive trouble and getting a high draft pick doesn’t make me feel any better. Agreed, put simply the rebuild just hasn'...

Hickey showed today why Longer should never play for the club again.. in this day and age you can't have a player who is a liability around the ground

'Dicko' has been a revelation so far this year... stats speak for themselves

Long was huge in that last quarter... Positive that all our good players were youngsters, something we haven't had in a long long time. Big hats off to McCartin also came up big with 3 mins left. Shame Jake the snake couldn't glove that last one.. I still think 10 goals kicked in perfect conditions ...

SaintPav wrote:Get rid of Geary and Gilbo.

Fkn useless

Agreed, however cannot drop a captain, imagine the PR after that. Problem is who is next in line for captaincy?? I cannot think of one worthy player

Our goal kicking is an absolute disgrace, to kick like that with no breeze or conditions to deal with... the players should be ashamed of themselves. Hickey has been really good, surely Longer cannot come back in again being such a liability out on the ground. If we kick straight in this last quarte...

For all that effort we are only 5 points ahead and GWS haven't moved out of 3rd gear yet. Honestly Billings and Gilbert are a liability. Send Billings back to the VFL until he can gain some confidence with his goal kicking and Gilbert should be given his 200th then no more

Coffield looks a player.. Billings... not much more needs to be said to be honest. Good to see Dicko is making a difference down there

We have problems everywhere. Our recruiting has been diabolical, the development is not there with so many players stagnating and to top it off we have a coach who simply cannot coach and has lost the playing group. I would be happy if we sent moved him on this year and bring someone back that has h...

1966 wrote:Why not just go man on man?
Play a 6 man forward line.
This is rubbish letting them have a couple of spares down back.

The tactics by Richo beggar belief tonight. Cannot remember the last time an AFL coach had been outcoached so horrendously

Players don't look interested, how many more chances will Lonie get to come in and do stuff all. He may be good at VFL level but he isn't up to AFL standard so stop persisting with him.. haven't noticed him.

Yawn... nothing new to see here.
- Richo getting outcoached- tick
- Inaccurate goal kicking -tick (Dicko has been a revelation)
- Turnovers galore and horrendous skil -tick
- One goal a quarter -tick
- 10 goal thumping- gonna happen

Won't win even if we start playing now... will seriously be happy with anything under a 100 point loss and to score more than what brisbane did today

We are in a worse position than we were back in the 2000-2002 era where we got belted every week, at least back then we could bottom out after some success in the late 90s and rebuild with good draft picks. Fast forward to 2018 and we are getting lower crowd numbers than ever before, have recruited ...

I have long been a fan of Richo but this year has been a debacle. Unfortunately our recruitment in recent years has been deplorable and the single minded game plan of pressure just isn't getting it done. The forward line is non-existent and it appears as if he is losing the players. We cannot have n...

[quote="stevie"]So, not counting any % logistics, we now have to beat the Tiges and hope that the Cheats lose to Freo. Thats also assuming the Crows beat Wet Coke. If Pies beat the Dreamons it would need to be by shiteloads and our margin of victory would have to be huge too. I think I've ...

Watch us let north kick multiple goals this quarter.. we are unable to destroy teams, even though percentage is so important this will peter out to a 30 point win

So now that we know we have officially wasted yet another season, decisions have to be made about who stays and who goes. After 21 rounds i think that's a fair enough sample size to make a call on some players. Here is my opinion of players who may be in trouble - T. Hickey (trade) - J. Lonie (delis...

Has been fantastic since coming back in, definitely in our best 22, his lobg kicking is a point if difference