What did we really trade for hill. From all accounts this year's draft is nothing special and next year's is going to be the most effected by father son academy gold coast compensation picks. Basically we lost Bruce who will hurt, Steven who won't because if he stayed he wouldn't have played for us...

question, what didn't we draft Jack Riewoldt?

CURLY wrote: ↑Thu 24 Oct 2019 2:51pm

skeptic wrote: ↑Thu 24 Oct 2019 2:49pm Personally all I want from Kingy is 27 weeks without any injury...
Would be happy if he had a solid season in the VFL if he got through unscathed

He's not playing 27 VFL games not a chance. If he is fit he plays round 1.

hundred percent

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Sat 19 Oct 2019 10:15pm Hind in for Long. Long to never play unless we have injuries and are desperate

ya joking. go see a doctor

Lonie will have to play well to hold his spot, but on current form is ahead of all other small forwards (Gresham aside, who is a mid/fwd) My order on last years output would be Lonie, Kent, Hind, Parker, Long, Butler, Young With Gresham rotating That order could easily change with form Billings and...

I view it as jack bytel is essentialy our 2019 first round pick, just been on ice a year. trading our actual first round this year we have turned pick 6 into an experienced spine and an elite wing. Bytel coukd have gone as low as pick 6. King and Bytel will be a beautiful icing on this cake Get wha...

Lethlean seems to have impressed Ratts with the way he worked together with Gallagher and Gubby. I haven't really trusted Lethlean since he came to the club, assuming he's using us as a stepping stone onto the next job. Somebody reckons he applied for the Demons CEO job only a few months after AFL ...

I view it as jack bytel is essentialy our 2019 first round pick, just been on ice a year. trading our actual first round this year we have turned pick 6 into an experienced spine and an elite wing. Bytel coukd have gone as low as pick 6. King and Bytel will be a beautiful icing on this cake

Lethlean seems to have impressed Ratts with the way he worked together with Gallagher and Gubby. I haven't really trusted Lethlean since he came to the club, assuming he's using us as a stepping stone onto the next job. Somebody reckons he applied for the Demons CEO job only a few months after AFL ...

six weeks it's fixed. plenty of time

I was just reading the thread on Jack Steven's trade to Geelong and am absolutely disgusted at some of the comments you all have made in relation to Jack's worth to the club. Nobody appears to have grasped the real issue here which is Jack's mental health. I'd give him to Geelong for nothing if it ...

Now Brian Cook is in the media today claiming that Geelong don't want to part with one of their picks in the 20's or 30's. So if I was St Kilda, I'd stand firm and tell Geelong to shove it. If Jack wants to play footy with them in 2020 then they need to stump up or Jack can either sit out a year or...

Jack can suck it up! His wife left him he went on a bender gave up on footy came back and now he wants to move up the road to Geelong. Keep him

thats a v good trade. Essentially turned 6 into hill Ryder and Howard. As hill will be traded on 10.

Jack Steven broke up with his wife. She left him so of course he had a s*** year mentally. hell probably be fine next year don't give him away!!!!

Jacks Back wrote: ↑Mon 14 Oct 2019 10:20pm

saintbob wrote: ↑Mon 14 Oct 2019 10:10pm Lonie and McKenzie have to be on that list, no one has then in our best 22.
I’d rather have Acres and Brown everyday of the week.

If we get Butler then one of Lonie, Parker, Long or Kent goes (I assume Young is a rookie and should go anyway).

why would long go?

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 03 Oct 2019 12:57pm Why would you give up a quality player to add a quality player?

What have you gained?

You really want to add quality to the quality you have.

Richmond didn’t give up quality players for Prestia and Lynch.

because they are twins. But no you would just offer him ca$$$hh

Bruce was told during his review to go look? he looks and finds, now we match the offer? sounds like his agent is repping him well

HUGE!!!

mental health. very sad

[/quote]
AND

Please can anyone explain to me how Matt Finnis and Simon Lethlean are somehow qualified to select an AFL coach ?

ANYONE ?

[/quote]

I know one thing you are not qualified to select an AFL coach, so I think I'll go with the committee thank you.

I can’t understand the negativity about Ratten being appointed. He was clearly the best choice for the role. Please explain why you think this..... Coached previously......with only a 50% win record...... If you want to quote previous stats. Quote them all from his time at Hawthorn. Carlton moved h...

Huge news. Roo, Roughead & Ratten.

mr six o'clock wrote: ↑Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:14pm There are probably a few clubs who would want him
Why do we think he'll be coming to us ? ( apart from the obvious 2 )

it's the obvious.

it's not depression, it's a breakup. And breakups take their toll and take their course