Eagles are crap, reckon they've lost the plot. Sure they're missing a few, but they are mentally shot.

Pity I can't spell, I thought the subject was 'decent umpire', and I was going to argue. Isn't it ironic that the dissent is typically as a result of a very bad or incorrect umpire decision. So not only is the team penalized by the original dubious decision, they are further penalized by the extra 5...

Reckon there were a few who were keen to trade him in the off-season.

He win's the Anzac award for tonights game

a bit soft, goal to Marshall

Bruce G McAbee wrote: ↑Fri 22 Apr 2022 8:23pm This game worries me, hopefully it's simply because I'm a St.Kilda supporter.

Worries me too Bruce....

Pity the trading rules don't allow us to sell a spare ruckman to Hawthorn. They're probably so desperate they'd almost certainly pay 'overs'.

I'd be OK to give up Campbell for their 1st round draft pick next year.

and if Toby Greene gets 12 months, Steven Baker probably gets a life ban.

As a group, our defense has been outstanding this year. They are very well organized and are supporting each other particularity well.

Thought Marshall may be carrying a bit an injury yesterday, but a very brave game nevertheless. Marshall is great value around the ground, a solid addition to our midfield. Ryder is an outstanding tap ruckman, to be honest I never realised just exactly how good till he came to St Kilda. (expect that...

5. Battle
4. King
3. Higgins
2. Couch
1. Sinclair

Hill, McKenzie & Jack Steel good

Liked Hayes & N.W. Milera's games

Just put Hayes in the middle and let him go where ever he sees fit. Small’s can feed off him and the opposition can worry about tagging him. He is big, clever, flexible, fit, strong and mobile. Thank goodness he appears to be able to handle the step up. Paton Howard Wilkie Webster Highmore Hill McK...

I'd play Battle in the midfield. We need the grunt. Desperately.

Hey 1965 Saint, you can't burn your membership any more, and you can't even microwave it. So how do we symbolically 'protest' our membership?

Reckon Luke Dunstan would've contributed a bit more than Owens last night....but Brett Rattan's not a fan....hope the club holds him accountable... 3 x small forwards didn't work last night, and didn't work last year, suggest we stop doing that. Our midfield is diabolical. We've got Jack Steel and n...

Higgins, Butler & Kent.

It's difficult to justify having them all in the same team.

Hey Curly, thanks for the dedicated thread, I appreciate it.

The AFL has lost $squillions over the past couple of years. Would it be cynical of me to think the umpires may be encouraged to support the big drawing clubs?

Saints looking pretty average so far

I am a "person of a certain age", which does not mean I am a dumb bastard. But, for the life of me, I cannot see how having to own a functioning smart phone and having to waste time loading up a "ticket" each match I attend is an improvement on a system that has seved us well fo...

my guess line up : B: Wilkie, Howard, Webster HB: Sinclair, Battle. Hill C: Wood, Crouch, Brynes HF: Gresham, Membrey, Kent F: Hayes, King, Butler Foll: Marshall, Steele, Ross INt: Paton, McKenzie, Sharman, Long Emerg: Campbell, Milera Wanganeen, Highmore, Connolly On paper, still a strong line up....

I'm pretty happy with our 'top up' recruits (except Hannaberry). Reckon depth will be crucial this season.

Such a pity that our 'home grown' early draft picks, Billings, Hunter Clark and Coffield are injured at a time they are due to blossom.

The_Dud wrote: ↑Sat 05 Mar 2022 7:39pm

Toy Saint wrote: ↑Sat 05 Mar 2022 7:24pm My Foxtel isn't working, may I ask for updates?

Yeah mine is the same. Have the same AFLW game on 2 channels and a holding screen on the channel we’re meant to be on

Same here, this sucks. I'm not interested in AFLW.

Is the game on the radio?

My Foxtel isn't working, may I ask for updates?

People become narrow minded when looking at midfields. I believe our midfield is a lot deeper than the common Steele Jones Ross Crouch That gets rolled out by the negative types. Sinclair Hill Clarke Webster Patton For starters are all part of the group. Our forwards can all play mid minutes Higgin...

Luke Dunstan was useful last year, recon he's a big loss.

Hanna Green just won a mixed gender golf competition by 4 strokes. The only compensation for the lady players was the t-box, which is considered appropriate given women lack the strength of men. It's a bit like Weight-For-Age horse racing, where fillies and mares typically have a 2kg advantage. My p...