:wink: My recollection was that McCartin was well in the frame as the Number 1 Draft Pick And Petracca was marked down because his body size was a contributor to his performance as a mid versus that age group Plus some personality issues with Petracca My recall was that Bomtapelli was also marked do...

The rot set in after we hired that corkhead, Ben Dixon. We went from bad to worse under his "tutelage". Don't forget his best "technique" was to get the players to imagine the best sex they'd ever had, as they were lining up, and visualize their partner in that union standing be...

It baffles me that anyone could think that this was a deliberate act. Of course training would be different, just like he probably wouldn’t tackle as hard at training his own teammates as he would the opposition in a preliminary final. MB. If you watched this collision in slow motion numerous times...

His main problem seemed to be he couldn’t take his opportunities when he had them to play in the senior side - couldn’t find the ball If I remember correctly he had a shocker last time he played for us at senior level Definitely seemed to have potential but couldn’t show it when it mattered As someo...

Pretty sure he was fit to play - if he was badly missed that was the point I was making when I said - that says something I think

He didn't play Howard or Billings in the last few games of the season last year - that says something I think

Let’s add some blah blah blah - mostly a whinge fest this place

As someone has already said Sharman is a smart player and has the skill to deliver the ball where he wants it on a fairly consistent basis

As a result he is involved in some great team plays and is as reliable as anyone else in the team shooting for goal

I think he is definitely best 23

Hammer

Thanks for the report

Any word on Caminiti ? Someone on BF said he was ‘massive’

At a bare minimum you would expect this will be good for Sandringham - the last few years we have carried so many injured middle tier,middle age players that it's been a joke - Sandy were needing to rely on players bringing their friends down to fill the gaps to field a team - hopefully next year we...

tony74 wrote: ↑Sun 22 Oct 2023 1:28pm When you’ve been a Sainter as long as me nothing surprises. All good Saintsational-I have a thick hide

Cheers Tony

That sounds like a backwards step. The umpires should hopefully be concentrating on their jobs whilst out there - not player gazing At the end of the match they will remember the big name players rather than the unkowns who played well - P Cripps - he tossed the coin, kicked a goal ran around a bit ...

Whatever mate

Just to let those who care , I had Rod Owen come in to the pub that I work in today he had me make him a soy lettie which blew my mind lol .He's been booze free nearly six years (welldone) I asked him about since its 150th did he have any past player stuff this season? The answer was a sharp no! No...

Apparently nominated Richmond - shame I think

I’m happy to try to trade out

Clark, Gresh, Howard & maybe Billings

Keep Coff

Otiman wrote: ↑Sat 16 Sep 2023 9:31am Name aside, do we need him? Aside from his height what attributes does he bring to our backline?

Young strong KPD

I’ve posted somewhere this same thing

Don’t know if he’s get able but I would like to get him and try him down back

The 'footy act' bulls*** was clearly called into the rooms pretty well immediately from a pies lawyer and they've stuck with it ever since. he was in the air with outstretched arms - and although not being able to control his trajectory he had full control of his arms, legs etc - unless a pies physi...

Not sure Coff can complain about not being picked - he has been injured all year + the year before that

He just ran out of time - needed a couple more weeks in the VFL season and less byes to give him a chance

I think he has a couple of tricks - can jump, has endurance, can take a catch every now and then - a very good kick Weaknesses Low productivity, strength, agility, ground level ability For his strengths I think decision making and execution are the skills that he has that are as good as pretty well...

I think he has a couple of tricks - can jump, has endurance, can take a catch every now and then - a very good kick Weaknesses Low productivity, strength, agility, ground level ability For his strengths I think decision making and execution are the skills that he has that are as good as pretty well...

We definitely shouldn’t be entertaining bringing Max king back - get him on the operating table now - if he needs it - and ready to start preseason
Guys like coffield and Hayes to be brought back only when 100% ready
Play a few more kids