No comparison to Roo at the same stage of his career. None at all. Definitely not.... 2001Nick waltzes into Harvard - Gehrig, Everitt, Loewe, Hall...with Hamill, Hayes, Harvey, Milne in the mid and small forwards....SUPPORT. ALL DAY EVERY GAME...for years. King crawls into Frankston TAFE and he's g...

This bloke in the crowd can whip up some fanboy jackets for them if they're interested

Do you reckon it was Teflon

Abuse now - just a sign of desperation- I really should report you! Bookmark it all you want I never once said he cannot ever be good - my assessment was of his game just gone! He could end up being the second coming of Jesus Doesn’t change the fact he was flogged by Aidan Corr and in a game with a...

Doesn’t mean he enjoys the weights session, but he does it. What does he enjoy…playing Xbox and Play Station? Jfc, he gets paid to do weights! I don’t want a reply from tony…just wanting to highlight how these guys don’t realise how lucky they are to be earning a decent living playing sport Strengt...

Lincoln McCarthy spent 6 full years on Geelong’s list and could only manage 29 senior appearances due to various injuries. Hunter Clark will recover from this. McCarthy had a really good run in the last 5 years at Brisbane but unfortunately the team is cursed atm, and he’s one of 4 players to have d...

Buckley was referring to the amount of inside 50's St Kilda was getting against North Melbourne, when he said King is a liability He said that King doesn't work hard enough. Maximum effort isn't there. Buckley said King needs to understand his strengths and use them, which he's not doing The guys in...

say something Unintelligent again?

Teflon can't win the footy arguments so he foes me instead... Tosser!

It's so funny when you try and be a smartarse and it backfires on you

Does unintelligent have a capital letter does it?

Teflon would have been a star under the roof at Marvel. I've heard he hated it when it was windy or it rained. He preferred to sit on the bench and wait for ideal conditions

That's how he gained most of his footy iq. Observing his team mates winning the footy and getting cold and wet

To be able to adapt to Tassie weather, I suggest 1. Boys go for swims daily at Melbourne beaches 2. Walk to training from the carpark without a jumper or a hoodie 3. Wear shorts at home all week and don't put the heater on The other hazard when they go on interstate trips is the all you can eat buff...

Funnily enough People who start comments with IIRC generally don’t Funnily enough you backed up my post that said he played as a small forward and mid by confirming he played as a small forward and mid :mrgreen: In 2017 Sincs averaged 21 disposals per game. 8.5 contested 12.5 uncontested 2018/19 he...

We'll see how 2025 unfolds and then I'll let you know if I think we're serious contenders in 2026

Jack Sinclair has bounced back to form with 10 coaches' votes to his name off the back of Saturday's win over the Roos. https://www.saints.com.au/news/1548030/coaches-votes-seamless-sinclair-snatches-perfect-10-six-saints-poll StPeter will be happy..😃 Haha yes. Just have seen him underrated by most...

Jack Sinclair has bounced back to form with 10 coaches' votes to his name off the back of Saturday's win over the Roos.

https://www.saints.com.au/news/1548030/ ... aints-poll

StPeter will be happy..

Jack Sinclair was no good in his first few years. You're right... I've done a comparison of Sinclair in 2016 with Pou for this year. He was very skinny and lacked strength in his first 2 years, but he attacked every contest. I think he suffered severe concussion and it set him back for a short peri...

Comparison with last year This vs last Better Higgins 56.5% vs 43.4% Membrey 56.5% vs 37.5% Worse King 43.8% vs 54.9% Sharman 40.0% vs 65.2% Owens 41.2% vs 51.0% Not a fair comparison imo Sharman was playing as a wingman and a defender this year. Pretty difficult having to be a fill in utility and ...

We also need to be seen as an attractive option for free agents on the move. Draft picks are not the only option. Are we aiming for top 4 in 2025? Are we flag contenders in 2026? I don't think we're either...so let the development occur organically with a core group of youth aided by the experience...

I'm not suggesting the club and coaches deliberately tank. I just think the long term is more important than banking wins in the short term

Get as many games as possible into our youth and continue to provide decent opportunities to them.

Nice cliche heading. Congratulations I know it helps our sanity having more wins and it makes for happier fans in the short term...but I'd rather we bank a pick 5 in the National Draft rather than a pick 8 or 9 or 10. Here's some of the quality that has gone at pick 5 in the last 20 years. Connor Ro...

TBC is To Be Confirmed. he has had to have another operation on his ankle, may be gone for the year, may be gone, that depends on how he recovers, on how he is rated by the clubs footy dept. I don't know the kid but if he is a determined young man and he is willing to put in the hard yards, we need...

Yes I’d like to see him lead up like Larky did/does ….but we have a midfielder as our forwards coach … Who runs the show? Banger or RTB? Does Max King do as he pleases and the team and the head coach devise all strategies around Max? 3 years ago it was Ratten's fault that King wasn't leading accord...

Dougal in the votes

Not sure where you are getting your information from but the stats clearly demonstrate that violent crime has been falling over time in Australia. https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/crime-and-justice/crime-victimisation/2021-22#personal-crime-summary I’ve even summarised the key parts nicely ...

Yes I’d like to see him lead up like Larky did/does ….but we have a midfielder as our forwards coach … Who runs the show? Banger or RTB? Does Max King do as he pleases and the team and the head coach devise all strategies around Max? 3 years ago it was Ratten's fault that King wasn't leading accord...

All our tackles are too weak. 95% of the time the player just gets hands away, or breaks the tackle. Would be nice if our players pinned an arm and dragged a player to the ground wouldn't it...oh wait 🤔 The umpires let the opposition do pirouettes and then it's play on 2 seconds into a tackle. It's...

Beno88 wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2024 10:41pm He will be a star.

Yeah nah...

Whatever you do, please don't tell us he's a ripper

I like Pou. I think he's got the talent and the right attitude to make it as an AFL player, but I'm nervous about the way St Kilda develop some of our so called 'star' young players.