Instead of looking to improve our player development and instead of looking towards our coaches to get the best out of the existing talent we have, we are once again (under current regime) looking to blame the players If the footy journos (including Montagna) want to continuously blame our woes on ...

I think takeaway, nostalgicsaint and Yorkeys would be perfect as assistants to Lyon. The perfect Yes men Watch the football on Sunday smartarses and then we'll chat But what if Saints actually win? What are you then going to chat about? You'd have to reverse your dreary negative monologues and post...

I think takeaway, nostalgicsaint and Yorkeys would be perfect as assistants to Lyon. The perfect Yes men Watch the football on Sunday smartarses and then we'll chat But what if Saints actually win? What are you then going to chat about? You'd have to reverse your dreary negative monologues and post...

I just watched channel 9 news sports report and they showed footage of Saints training session Looked look the local suburban footy club warm up. Zero intensity. Zero commitment to excellence So you watched, what, a 15 sec video of Saints training on the news and have come up with the conclusion of...

It's just list management. Higgins had to come in, the other 3 are out of contract at the end of this year.
Give 'em a chance to earn a new contract.

takeaway, Staying conservative in your thinking is not the answer to St Kilda improving. Considering Brad Crouch as our 'best inside mid' is flawed. Windy was only in his second year, Sincs was only starting to be used in the middle and Steele was injured. Crouch is fading just as Seb Ross is. He a...

takeaway, Staying conservative in your thinking is not the answer to St Kilda improving. Considering Brad Crouch as our 'best inside mid' is flawed. Windy was only in his second year, Sincs was only starting to be used in the middle and Steele was injured. Crouch is fading just as Seb Ross is. He a...

The worst thing St Kilda could do right now is go backwards. I don't want to see a midfield with Seb, Steele and Crouch. I think there is a growing chorus of Saints supporters crying out for Owens to be used as an inside mid. I don't want him to be the second ruck. It's like the Blake Acres debate ...

Doesn't matter how many changes we make this week, it's just shuffling the deckchairs around on the Titanic - just don't have the depth Yep I think only Marshall holds his head up Insipid and should’ve lost by 10 goals Oddly to half time felt like we had more of the play …just can’t score We turn i...

Not all football pundits seem to see worrying signs as early as you Scolops. Coaches included. Even after the event. "Also... let's see Dow get a fair run at this level, without being replaced by Crouch in 2 weeks." That's up to Dow. Once Crouch is match fit, he's an automatic inclusion, ...

Read the tea leaves Ross. somewhere , i heard Ross say that he watched the 2nds run round besides , that being an example of the new ross in action ... one would presume , reading tea leaves was exactly what he was at the game for ... and there's the new onfield team as written in the empty cup Lov...

Scallop With their injury list, who constituted the Hawthorn attack? Noting Hawthorn won the game by only 5 points So that is one game against a lower ranking Club And what happened when we played the Western Bulldogs, a team with variable form The challenging sides do not rely on one KPP sized pla...

Didn’t he have 2 All Australian players and an AA squad ruckman in the midfield yesterday?! 😂 is that best u got?? He had an AA HBF he’s desperately had to put in the middle cause he has no one ..so midfield all fixed ? Brain dead No hope I will desist from responding further as it denigrates the f...

Scallop my only issue with your analysis here is the fact jack has only played a containing role once this season (GWS) he’s generally ran free or been tagged in all other matches. Have you got access to inside info on his role in each game? Nice. I'll be sure to follow all your posts more closely ...

Typical of Tom Morris. I think he's losing creditability. Just loves spreading gossip. He should be working for the Woman's Weekly. How on earth is this in any way Tom Morris’s fault? He’s just doing his job. This isn’t gossip. This is a real tweet from a football manager about football. Not about ...

You're a Webster fan Scollop, good on you. I'm not. I was not referring to his handball fail but thanks for highlighting it. He is too loose. Whilst he's a hard player, I think he's a dumb player in terms of disposal and discipline. You think differently. Paton over Webster? Can't agree there, much...

Never read the Herald Sun, my views are totally the opposite of Andrew Bolt. However, I will obviously not get the answers to Yorkey's questions on here, so I will have to go and consult Auntie Fay. It's great if you have direct access to someone like Auntie Fay, but.. ..it's not hard to educate yo...

Never read the Herald Sun, my views are totally the opposite of Andrew Bolt. However, I will obviously not get the answers to Yorkey's questions on here, so I will have to go and consult Auntie Fay. It's great if you have direct access to someone like Auntie Fay, but.. ..it's not hard to educate yo...

I don't agree with Paton being preferred over Dow. Paton was ok but I reckon Lyon wants him for a tagging or run with role Hawthorn have a pretty good midfield so not a bad strategy, but we recruitd Dow for our midfield. With Crouch out, we need to see if Dow can improve our clearances. We should b...

Geez...Some of these posts are like reading the comments section of the Melbourne remedial newspaper, the Herald-Sun...Or an Andrew Bolt editorial. In Andrew we Trust In Murdoch we Trust The Herald Sun is the greatest newspaper in the world Never read the Herald Sun, my views are totally the opposi...

Still a few locked-in fragile colonials around I see The efforts to show respect and to recognise & acknowledge Indigenous people and the terrible effects of colonialism, dispossession and accompanying racism are good things. However When was St Kilda FC ever an Indigenous institution, when was...

King va Cameron One jogs around a does fk all high speed running The other runs his fkn arse off Work out which one is which I'm not comparing them. Cameron is a gun, and will always be more mobile than King. Also different teams, different tactics, one forward line organised and efficient, the oth...

He needs to get on the fkn move instead of being a stationary target Too easy to move off the ball and body spoil His Brother has NO problem leading and kicking goals He needs a roast He also needs better delivery. Despite a quiet game, and the usual one and a half opponents, King managed to get a ...

Scollop wrote: ↑Fri 26 Apr 2024 9:00pm

takeaway wrote: ↑Fri 26 Apr 2024 7:07pm I do know you prefer the ruff tuff types, like that ex Gold Coast player, Ben Long

He's been sacked has he?

Dunno. Haven't heard anything about him. Is he still there?

Billings does look comfortable at Melbourne. Looks exactly the same as he did with us. 15-20 disposals. Neat kicking and creative ball use. It's creative of you to think that Billings has creative ball use. Mediocre player 18 touches with 17 being uncontested and disposal efficiency of 61%....yeah ...