Getting the ball all the time means nothing if most of the time it goes to the advantage of the opposition. CJ has played some great games this year, but as I said, this was not one of them. Some people are fooled into thinking that getting a lot of disposals means a good game. He works hard to get...

Well blow me down - Clinton Jones isn't Ian Stewart - get your stakes and pitchforks everyone, we've gotta finish this now!!!! Everyone knows he isn't the greatest footballer, including the coaching staff, and CJ himself, and his teammates. Yes, they might get a hot handball from time to time, but t...

GrumpyOne wrote:Is Carlie married to Charlie?

Sister....their parents weren't that original with names....

saint66au wrote:Id rather play Adelaide at AAMI than Collingwood at the G to be honest

+1

Collingwood lift for big games - like finals at the 'G

Sunday afternoon is a poor timeslot too. I imagine that had the game been Friday or Saturday night, the crowd would have been a lot larger.

I would expect 33,800 to be above average for our Sunday afternoon home games.

The only player who looks like they would really need a week off is Kosi, and that has as much to do with form as it does with injury. He is playing sore, and i think this week would be a good chance to give McEvoy another crack, despite Big Mac's apparent lack of form at Casey.

Confirmed sightings of Big Lazar Vidovic, Kristian Bardsley and Jason Heatley.

Spot On.

Proof of this is the discussion on who we drop for Bally and X (and possible Mini).

I can't remember a time when we weren't calling for someone's head, but this week I'd struggle to pick the obvious ones out of that bottom 6 to miss out.

I've heard that Black is signed, sealed and delivered to play for Noble Park next year. Not sure if the source is on the money or not, but if they are it implies he would be moving back to Melbourne. As for this weekend, I would probably be surprised if there's any current players from other clubs t...

B: Joel MacDonald, Matthew Scarlett, Dale Morris HB: Brett Kirk, Nathan Bock, Ryan Griffen C: Adam Cooney, Brent Harvey, Matthew Richardson HF: Nick Reiwoldt, Lance Franklin, Paul Chapman F: Jarryd Roughead, Brendan Fevola, Steve Johnson R: Dean Cox, Jimmy Bartel, Gary Ablett Jnr Int: Sam Mitchell, ...

I don't care if it's his first game or his last, if he's wearing black with a red stripe, he's not getting any claps or cheers from me. Geez i hate those pr1cks. Give it to them Saints, make them hurt for the next 6 months till they get to play again. They've never had any mercy for us...time to get...

Pwoit wrote:

Otiman wrote:I make it 7 coaches.


Doc
Sheldon
Alves
Watson
Blight
Thomas
Lyon

I only see 5

Pretty stiff....the man has 2 premiership medalions, and three years runners up. Couldn't coach us, but that doesn't mean he couldn't coach at all.

HF: S. Johnson Franklin Chapman FF: Bradshaw/Brown? Fevola Roughead Bradshaw and Brown have lost form at the wrong time, but are still in the top 5 in the Coleman Race. Add Mooney, Pavlich and possibly Medhurst on the bench, and Roo should be happy just getting to the team, let alone captain. I thin...

Geez every part of the scale in that list, in terms or what they gave to our club, from Francis and Monkhorst, through to Burke and Loewe. Some very ordinary players on that list. Wasn't Fred Campbell the next Winmar??? Obviously one on that list very close to st kilda's heart won't be there, maybe ...

Or the very least, should be it Harvey's last game, make our way down to Level 1 towards the end of the game, so when he looks to level one he'll see more red, white & black than the Bomber supporters. Hopefully the score will lead to some bombers leaving early, and freeing up their seats for t...

I was on the ticketmaster website earlier, and the "best available" only gave me level 3 seats. I'm gonna check it out at a ticketmaster office tomorrow.

Agree.

Along with Dean Laidley and Roos, is probably the best of the modern day coaches. I can't stand him now cause he's from Port, but would love to see him in a saints shirt.

We should concentrate on the fact we've been lucky enough to have seen one of the very best ever go around in the red white and black.

Dunno about anyone else, but i'm pretty pumped about how the next 8 weeks are gonna go now. I feel a fairytale brewing down at Moorabbin!!!

M Gardiner 3 votes

The only thing that really matters is that Gwilt's best game was 2 days ago, X's best game was Feburary 2007 in a Nab Cup Cairns monsoon.

Therefore Gwilt gets the nod for this week.

Didak would be a good fit for Freo's "All D*ckheads" policy, so I wouldn't be surprised to see him in purple next year. They could keep their "recycled hacks in, promising youth out" campaign going with...

Didak for Palmer + 2nd Round Pick

I would hope Birss would be an inclusion this week, considering his good form for Casey, and the job he did on Heath Shaw earlier in the year. Geary struggled this week, but has shown at VFL level that he can play a bit. I think he'll get better when he feels more comfortable at the top level, and g...

So who of Gardiner, Rix, Geary, Allen and Shane Birss do you think will get the nod? in: gardiner, geary. out: kosi, ????. bj to play forward I suspect either Armo or Eddy will come out for a rest. It seems the to be what we've been doing with the younger players so as not to burn them out. If he w...

We should be keeping an eye on the lions, and make sure we don't play them at the Gabba first week of the finals. If we have to play interstate, i think we'd be a much better chance against the crows at aami.

Am I getting ahead of myself yet???

Enrico_Misso wrote:Re the hailstones game.

I thought they abandoned the little league at half time ?

We were taken off after about 10 minutes...but definetly got out there...