Doesn't matter how many changes we make this week, it's just shuffling the deckchairs around on the Titanic - just don't have the depth

WTF is up with Phillipou - how can you drop a sitter like that!

3 of our 6 INs this week been horrible, Sharman, Phillipou and Collard - Sharman not good enough at this level, I'm convinced now

Clark , Dow , Hammer and Sharman. All good in the 2nd half. That’s all that matters Enough for senior call up???? No, the only one putting his hand up for a call up was Camminiti from that lot - was hoping that Collard would shine today given the absence of Higgins and Butler but he was horrible

I thought watching Sharman today he was ok. But not great. Hes consistent...meaning he gets a bit of the ball, gets a shot or two on goal...but nothing you cant live without. At times he's been in marking contests similar to Caminiti...can mark & bring ball to ground. Wouldnt think either playe...

Good point

According to this article on the AFL website, our pressure over the last 2 weeks is the 8th worst recorded since this started being measured in 2010 https://www.afl.com.au/news/1119457/the-heat-is-off-st-kilda-saints-pressure-plummets-as-worrying-trend-emerges I can accept losing when the players le...

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 26 Apr 2024 11:18pm The youth today

Phillipou 2 kicks
Garcia 7 possessions- as a mid
Caminiti 6 possessions
Sharman 6 possessions

Hastie impacted 8 in a quarter

VERY good Angus Hastie!

Angus Hastie needs to be in the starting lineup next week, the kid shows plenty - 8 disposals in a quarter of footy and looked very good.

B.M wrote: ↑Fri 26 Apr 2024 9:55pm Cooper Sharman’s body language is fkn terrible

Gives up and stops trying

Needs a fkn rocket!!!

Not happy with Sharman at all! He has been terrible for a few weeks now and definitely needs a spell - I'd sub him out for Hastie

I definitely would have had Collard in to cover for Butler

In: Howard, Hastie
Out: Butler, Jones

Can't believe we only make 2 changes after last week's s*** show

I wouldn't be breaking the budget if we do decide to sign him on - hasn't lived up to the early hype by a long shot, disappointing.

Not sure if it's been mentioned at all here but Perkins definitely pushes Windy into Durham - Saints should appeal and base their defence on that.

This might be a bit left field but I would love to see them blood Isaac Keeler - this guy's ceiling is unlimited, reminds me a lot Paddy Ryder and think the earlier we get him in the better.

Arie also needs to come in for Cordy

1966 wrote: ↑Sat 30 Mar 2024 7:10pm Tom Campbell has to play. Just ridiculous having Owens as 2nd ruck.

I'd almost be tempted to bring Max Heath in to help out Marshall - served a fair apprenticeship and he's a goal kicker as well. Let's see how he goes tomorrow for Sandy, also seeing if Arie can back up his performance last week.

Forward line was a shambles today and we weren't able to cover for the guys that went out. We just had nothing down forward and I question the decision to sub Sharman out - he was having a stinker but could have been handy in the last quarter, just nobody able to take a mark in the forward 50. Reall...

Helped the club through a really tough period, RIP Prez!

Arie for Cordy

Arie Schoenmaker demanding selection now.......26 disposals and 10 marks, not even 3 quarter time yet.....bring on the Superboot!

Damn, he was looking so good too!

At least with Butts possibly back next week, we've got a like for like replacement

Big Max wrote: ↑Fri 15 Dec 2023 1:32pm I'm hoping it's Keeler, because we desperately need a backup ruck/forward.

I agree that it will be the mercurial Isaac Keeler - can't wait to see this kid play

This draft is all about run, run and more run for the Saints

George27 wrote: ↑Tue 21 Nov 2023 7:36pm So is he the Coffield replacement? 190 cm , off half back.

Yep, that was my first thought - running defender that takes the game on - I like it

Got to be Ollie Murphy now......bargain selection and something we need is a key defender!