Lucky we didn't waste a No 1 draft pick on him You would have to be stark raving bonkers to use a No1 draft pick on a key position forward who can't get much of the ball and can't score many goals. Lucky that does not apply to St Kilda then. The way our forwards go, Max King likely to be made To pl...

The only thing that’s certain is that Marshall isn’t going anywhere.
22 touches
27 hitouts
Equal game high 9 clearances
14 contested
2 goals

He's ok. Have to consider injury and delivery. And he gets best defender. But we are a team full of B Graders with a B grade coach, so why pick on him. Most forwards look second rate compared to Nick who won so many games for us (and probably got AR and extension in the process). GWS are a class te...

Yorkeys wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2019 6:52pm Good kid, poor coaching.

Based on what, he got a game today and helped himself to 10(?) touches

Probably not that unpopular. Why we havnt played a Longer / Marshall combo to give some support up forward is beyond me. Two terrible games where intercept marks have dominated us. Even putting Battle up there. No changes happen and unfortunately teams have now worked out our boring style. Marshall...

Probably not that unpopular. Why we havnt played a Longer / Marshall combo to give some support up forward is beyond me. Two terrible games where intercept marks have dominated us. Even putting Battle up there. No changes happen and unfortunately teams have now worked out our boring style. Marshall...

Toy Saint wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2019 6:15pm Bruce had no right to play last week, he was injured. And he didn't look much better today.

I understand that they came out and said that he probably should’ve missed last week... this isn’t an assessment on two weeks though, this is a look at his whole career with us.

Bruce just isn't that good. Outside of a few spectacular grabs and that 50 goal season (which I will get to shortly) he is severely overrated on here. - He isn't overly quick - Far from a reliable set shot - A relatively poor contested mark (outside of the few hangers that he's taken) We've all hea...

mr six o'clock wrote: ↑Sat 04 May 2019 6:10pm That's part of our problem
We can only attract b graders from other clubs
And the kids we select rarely develope into a graders

Steele/Membrey been the best pick ups

We were in it until the third quarter. It wasn't Parkers miss that cost us it was the 20 other inside 50's that we didn't capitalise on. Also Brown was #2 in intercept marks coming into 50 this year. Why the F was he omitted for? Gresham had a shocker today, he really did and if he gets dropped I w...

Is a shocking kick for goal... but constantly finds himself in scoring positions. If he was kicking straight this year, we would be hyping up that trade on here to no end.

Bruce just isn't that good. Outside of a few spectacular grabs and that 50 goal season (which I will get to shortly) he is severely overrated on here. - He isn't overly quick - Far from a reliable set shot - A relatively poor contested mark (outside of the few hangers that he's taken) We've all hear...

Hunter Clark is reaaaaaally slow. Does anyone know what his outstanding traits were in the TAC Cup? Probably comes from a good family... He’s a very good player with ... horribly poor senior players to lead and guide him. And a Dribbler of a coach with zero idea of how to lead and motivate himself....

Currently have eight players with less than 10 touches including:
Acres
Sinclair
Webster
Clark
Bruce
Long

Jesus.

Hunter Clark is reaaaaaally slow.

Does anyone know what his outstanding traits were in the TAC Cup?

That 50 goal season from Bruce is the biggest outlier in recent memory

Bruce just isn’t good.

Where is Leppitsch coaching atm?

Young named as an emergency

Which five players at St Kilda should get $800K a year? On potential you'd include Carlisle but on output and risks going forward, I wouldn't I'd go Stuv, Bruce , Steele, Gresh, and Billings What has Bruce done in the past 4 years that would put him remotely close to the top 5 players at the club? ...

Good article by Tom Morris https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2019-jack-billings-refusing-to-chat-with-rival-clubs-in-best-sign-yet-he-wants-to-stay-at-st-kilda/news-story/48dfff35c0f2d81dfefed59bc27ce30b "Not only has the left-footer expressed no desire to leave, but he’s privately reiterate...

Not sure why people think we need to change anything.

RoMa’s played in 4 games, we’ve won the hitouts in one game and we actually lost that game.

Right now we’re quicker, fitter and more mobile compared to our rivals. Why bring in someone like Longer who will only slow us down?

Damo one of the best in the business. Plain and simple

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Thu 18 Apr 2019 1:54pm Stonecold was taking the piss with that stupid FB story!!!!

Are you stonecold?

Interesting to see one of our own, Joey M tip Melbourne this week, reason: Max Gawn will dominant the ruck against the inexperienced and under developed Marshall!!!!! So, which of you armchairs is going to argue with that????? I'm sure you'll find your usual under educated excuses, however, I'm tal...