I am one of the few to put him out there but I like Noughton. I am not buying our new back row depth because Goddard is training again and Logan joined us for a handshake and a pack of chips. He is a Key defensive player, which we need especially if Carlisle or Brown cant play long term. I will be s...

I doubt we will get Cerra but you are right he looks good. Bonar has a few injuries already. I would prefer to get someone else who is uninjured Both have had injuries. Champion data on Cerra 7. ADAM CERRA (Eastern Ranges) 186cm midfielder Injuries in past two years the question mark. A ball winner...

I doubt we will get Cerra but you are right he looks good. Bonar has a few injuries already. I would prefer to get someone else who is uninjured

Not a fan of Stephenson so I am hoping he is off the table before he gets to us. We have been burnt before with a draft pick having a preexisting condition i.e. Paddy. PLus he's filed kicking from what i have read isn't good. I prefer others

And who do we lose to fit one of these guys in. Only so many spots on the list. I don't know enough about these players but: - we got Logan as a defender so why get Collins as well. In saying that I would still draft Noughton if available but thats for another post. We have enough small forwards so...

More melts if its NOUGHTON. NOUGHTON???? The worst kick in the draft and since jason daniels he is an absolute spud. ZDawson yet dawson had a better kick If we get fing naughton I WILL NOT GET A MEMBERSHIP. DISGRACE!!!! Noughton has a loopy kicking style for sure that is easy to intercept but that ...

And who do we lose to fit one of these guys in. Only so many spots on the list. I don't know enough about these players but: - we got Logan as a defender so why get Collins as well. In saying that I would still draft Noughton if available but thats for another post. We have enough small forwards so ...

We are about to get our number 1 pick It may not be this year but 2019 with paddy, logan, goddard, long, battle, freeman and progression of the other youngsters we wont know ourselves. 50-100 games in all these young guns and they are guns. Much maligned and I dont know why?? Ffs people riding off ...

Ooo wouldnt say that. Logan has got it youll see the kid had a broken leg ffs. Before that he was first picked out of quite a few options. Hes had his year of rehab hopefully 2018 hes back. Same as goddard. WCE game goddard was good go and watch it. In a game where we suked badly he even kicked a n...

I may be on my own here but I hope we don't get Stephenson. From what I have seen and read he's kicking around the ground is bad. Spraying the ball a lot and not hitting targets. He is great in other areas for sure but I think there are better out there. Bonar sounds like a great inside midfielder b...

I was happy with Brown last year. Did exactly what he was hired to do so not sure why the negativity. As for Logan and Goddard taking his place I have not seen enough from them to think it will happen soon. Goddard really hasn't been brilliant before he was injured and he is slow. Logan was cheap as...

SaintPav wrote:I’m sure there is probably a good reason for it but why did they wait until October to do Jakes’s surgery?

My thoughts exactly. Why didn't we get it done earlier, even rest him for the last game when finals were off the table and have surgery then ?

Bonar looks good but 2 acl injuries already is a bit of a concern. Can we take the gamble?

I would definitely get Aaron Naugton if he is still available. We still need another key defender. Geary is pushing 30 and brown has one maybe two years left in him. When they leave we are back in the same spot we are now. Logan is not great, he isn't and what has Goddard really shown. Not enough f...

I would definitely get Aaron Naugton if he is still available. We still need another key defender. Geary is pushing 30 and brown has one maybe two years left in him. When they leave we are back in the same spot we are now. Logan is not great, he isn't and what has Goddard really shown. Not enough fo...

https://www.afldraftcentral.com.au/2017 ... tom-draft/

another good summary of each player

Don't forget Marshall Battle,White & Long. Some big upside there as well

Once was bad enough but to repeat the same post 5 times....really?[/quote]

something odd happened there. Do you know how to delete posts?

http://www.espn.com.au/afl/story/_/id/20952212/knightmare-afl-draft-power-rankings-october-rayner-maintains-ranking-dominance great summary on the players. I am working on the assumption we are after 2 midfielders and not a defender. Ignore top 4 on the list as they wont slide to 7. there are some s...

erase multiple post

Erase multiple post

Erase multiple post

Erase multiple post

http://www.aflplayerratings.com.au/Ratings/Player/122454/Logan-AUSTIN says it all. Doesn't stand out at SAFL and not good enough for powers top 22. Only get him if it really cheap and as a back up player for injured players. I would rather not get another list clogger You must be a glass half empty...

http://www.aflplayerratings.com.au/Rati ... gan-AUSTIN

says it all. Doesn't stand out at SAFL and not good enough for powers top 22. Only get him if it really cheap and as a back up player for injured players. I would rather not get another list clogger