I've seen Parker a number of times this year and while he has talent it is still a big risk. He had troubled teen years and has only in the last 2 years had any impact at WAFL level. He has potential but not much would have to go wrong off the field for it to all blow up

Armo,Savage,Newes,Dunstan,Rice,may be others,i realise we need depth but am struggling to fit in my best 22,and really believe we should be playing the Cottfields,Clarkes,Longs who are our future.Happy to be proved wrong and some of these guys have great 2019 just cant see it and really don't want ...

I've warmed to the idea as I don't think that Bruce is elite nor ever will be. McCartin still has time on his side and if we get any luck, he'll become a genuine gun full forward. If King lives up to the hype then a forward line consisting of Paddy, King, Battle, and Membrey could be a tasty forwar...

ListManager wrote: ↑Tue 20 Nov 2018 8:32am Max King. Didn't our stupid club learn anything from the McCartin experience.? FFS, we need elite MIDFIELDERS . James Gallagher and Libba should be removed from their positions if they do this.

"Nah all good, we have Hanneberry- well he was elite 3 years ago- does that count ?

(Lots of good stuff left out for brievity reasons.) ... I should also add my impression of him is strongly influenced by what I’ve been told by a friend who worked with the playing group and Richardson from 2014 - 2016. The reports he gave me about Richardson’s M.O are borne out in our dismal perfo...

First up, cards on the table. Richardson has completely lost me. How he is still in the role is just astounding really. Pathetic, matey performance management. Fish rots at the head. Runs are just not on the board. We would have to win 18+ games next year to have me thinking otherwise. I hate sacki...

Our key weaknesses from last season haven't been addressed (at least in the trade window) and that is pace and elite ball use by foot. Our mid field apart from Steven is slow and one paced and their foot skills are horrid. Adding Hannebery does absolutely nothing to address that as he is slow (and ...

First up, cards on the table. Richardson has completely lost me. How he is still in the role is just astounding really. Pathetic, matey performance management. Fish rots at the head. Runs are just not on the board. We would have to win 18+ games next year to have me thinking otherwise. I hate sacki...

First up, cards on the table. Richardson has completely lost me. How he is still in the role is just astounding really. Pathetic, matey performance management. Fish rots at the head. Runs are just not on the board. We would have to win 18+ games next year to have me thinking otherwise. I hate sacki...

First up, cards on the table. Richardson has completely lost me. How he is still in the role is just astounding really. Pathetic, matey performance management. Fish rots at the head. Runs are just not on the board. We would have to win 18+ games next year to have me thinking otherwise. I hate sacki...

First up, cards on the table. Richardson has completely lost me. How he is still in the role is just astounding really. Pathetic, matey performance management. Fish rots at the head. Runs are just not on the board. We would have to win 18+ games next year to have me thinking otherwise. I hate sacki...

First up, cards on the table. Richardson has completely lost me. How he is still in the role is just astounding really. Pathetic, matey performance management. Fish rots at the head. Runs are just not on the board. We would have to win 18+ games next year to have me thinking otherwise. I hate sacki...

Our key weaknesses from last season haven't been addressed (at least in the trade window) and that is pace and elite ball use by foot. Our mid field apart from Steven is slow and one paced and their foot skills are horrid. Adding Hannebery does absolutely nothing to address that as he is slow (and w...

Our key weaknesses from last season haven't been addressed (at least in the trade window) and that is pace and elite ball use by foot. Our mid field apart from Steven is slow and one paced and their foot skills are horrid. Adding Hannebery does absolutely nothing to address that as he is slow (and w...

Don't get this "depth" thing, we have a list of players and the team finished 16th this year and so called experts want to add more players to the list who are no better than the ones we already have on the list. So what is the point? There isn't one, just like the players we have recruit...

Even a rabble like Fremantle can attract two young up and coming stars and all we get is a burnt out, slow poor by foot midfielder that no one else wanted. That's right, you can spin it any way you want, but not one other club was interested in Hannebery and Sydney hardly put up a fight to keep him-...

To be fair, Mav was alright there for a while. Poor man's Aaron Hamill with his tackling. Would rather a crocked Mav Weller than Jack Newnes...... that's how low Newnes is in my estimations. If he starts Round 1, we have a serious problem. I have news for you- it wont take Newnes starting in round ...

Our list is fine ... we will trade aggressively.... we have delivered “f all” so far .... I wouldn’t say f**k all, Hannebery is still an A-grader, was previously elite but possibly past his best now, hence why we got him relatively cheaply. Kent though, let’s be honest, is just another depth player...

Looking at the midfield- all I can see is slow, Steven excepted. Dunstan, Ross, Sinclair, Armo and even Clark. Longer has the speed of slow drying cement. All one-paced runners, and this is why we need to bring in some burst speed in the midfield. Can't see an easy fix to this in the short term. He...

If Armo is getting a game for us, we are destined for bottom 2- He looks like he's running in gum boots

Jack Steel ??

Drew21 wrote: ↑Fri 12 Oct 2018 3:20pm A) I think hunter will be a very good player has poise and does not seem rushed

B) I would trade 4 for the 6 ,10 and 11 or next years first round
See how desperate they are on draft night

I agree on Hunter Clarke- he will be very good

I concur, if that's all we are adding (Kent and Haneberry), then we will finish in the bottom 4 at best. The club cant be knocked for having a crack, we are just not that appealing atm. We just have to accept that the rebuild failed and that it is going to take time- the big challenge will be holdin...

There is absolutely no way Pick 39 gets the job done.. we’re a basket case, will be the future second. At this rate we should get a priority pick anyway next year If pick 39 is not enough we should walk away- he is simply not worth it. Its about time the saints showed some balls. Sydney don't want ...

Most of the other clubs have brought in some good players and improved their list. We have added hannerbery and lost Hicky. In effect we have taken a step backwards or at best remain the same. Spare me the pick four argument its going to be a long miserable 2019 if that's all we end up with. Aggres...