You can't disguise Dick head :) <1 day ban for commenting negatively on a poster> POSTER INTERACTION RULE Vigorous debate and even some friendly banter on St. Kilda Football Club matters is encouraged on the Saintsational Fan Forum, as long as respect is shown for every poster and all opinions. No ...

I just heard that Banger has been offered the
Job but it will not be made public until
Collingwood’s season is finished.

PADDLEPOP1001 wrote: ↑Wed 28 Aug 2019 11:10pm Ryder is absolutely shot if we get him we should be shot!

Post of the century PADDLEPOP1001.

With your permission I would like to make it my signature!!!!!?????

Rubyjo wrote: ↑Sat 24 Aug 2019 8:20pm I have no idea.. Geelong.. Bribane.. Westcoast.. Collingwood.. Richmond.. Who do you think?

Essendon.

I’d do it. However the players won’t accept to rot on the Gold Coast. It is only a matter of time before Gold Coast come good. Once they start winning games which could still be 2 years away, all of a sudden they will have a whole list of top 10 players. Their next coach will have an embarrassment ...

Carlisle, Geary and pick 5 for Ben King.

First question - Would you be happy with this trade?
Second question - Would Gold Coast accept this?

Discuss.

The recruiting staff have made some stupid decisions in the last 5 years but if it is true and they want Ryder this takes the cake. Forget about about trading old players full stop. This only works for top 4 teams. We are a bottom 4 team. Why not scour the state leagues and grab a 24 year old that w...

Who takes responsility for this extended period of misery inflicted on us saints supporters? No finals in 8 seasons and mostly finishing in bottom section of the ladder. What makes it worse is that we came off one our most sucessful periods at end of 2011 (from 1991 to 2011). You would think that t...

Plays like a guy who doesnt give af about the club. Least when Goddard went to the Injectors expecting a flag and was let down, he doubled down and tried. Carlisle playing like moving to us was the mistake it was. It's a mistake that we should make the most of. Pick 5 and Carlisle to Gold Coast for...

From above : "Has there ever been an admin so out of touch with the supporters?" No - not for a long time now. Time to move on a few key things Mr new President !! What about the fiasco of $900k to Hill? Forget about bringing over 25 year olds. Let me take you back to about 20 years ago a...

I still think we should be selling, not buying. If we add Hill, we're probably still on the wrong side of mediocre. I feel like, five years down the road, we're probably going to wish we'd kept the top-10 pick. I don't see what guys like Constable, Jones and Tomlinson add to the list either. Consta...

If St Kilda keep going down this track of bringing in players older than 26 we are doomed. Forget about Hill, Tomlinson and Zak Jones ffs. If we were a top 4 team then by all means go for it. But we are nowhere near a top 4 team. We have to keep building from the bottom up. Not the other way around....

Let’s package up Carlisle, Newnes, Lonie and Savage to the Gold Coast for Ben King and Jack Martin. I don't think we need to be ruthless at all. We have a great core of youngsters all coming through at the same time. Where we have gone wrong IMHO is our recruiting philosophy. Bringing in older play...