plugger66 wrote:

remboy wrote:

plugger66 wrote: Firstly when was the last gun taken in the PSD

David Strooper.

Apart from him.

Tom Rockliff from Brissy

Look at how bj was in tears again the other night when the team that bought him played us. It means a great deal to these St.Kilda stalwarts to be a one club player. Joey is a Saints man through and through and should never be traded, especially to Essendon, the team that citywest as nexus-nick sai...

citywest wrote:

SaintPav wrote:Highly doubt it.

Why do you doubt it? From all reports he is one of the best tall forwards in this years draft.

Exactly.

And Riewoldt is probably the best CHF of his generation. Not a draft. Run along, Helen

P.S. GO BOMBERS!

Bump

A few nostalgic memories

1) Spur, Nanna and the coleslaw... Hahaha classic
2) The wit of Bungi, Zippy & Dan Warna (his posts were just brilliant)
3) The inside info of Stone Cold

HFF Tredrea 4 time AA CHF would probably edge him.... He is a better forward than Brown, Pavlich, Hall Hall doesn't even deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as Brown, Pavlich, Tredrea & Roo. I think Tredrea was a cross between Loewe and Riewoldt - in that he was equally comfortable takin...

Harsh on White - as he was drafted as a long-term prospect. Also harsh on Markworth who suffered a serious injury last year - when he was expected to break out and be given a chance to cement his spot in the team. I think Lee can offer more than Maister - definitely a better kick on goal. Agree on S...

From memory, the two main knocks on Eli were on his pace (was never considered slow, but was not considered to have that "burst" of speed) and also his disposal. I really liked his goal on Saturday - the initial handball wasn't the best, but he ran hard to receive the follow up and it was ...

kosifantutti wrote:

dragit wrote:Watts better than either Jones.

Both Jones?

There were 3 out there last Saturday, right?!

Lenny Hayes played almost an entire game with a torn ACL against North in 2006 This one for sure. Also, as another poster mentioned - that game against North where we ended up with about 14 fit players in the 30s and a medal was commemorated for all the players in their honour. I'm fairly sure Alan...

I've never seen this one before - but it's an absolute beauty!

kosifantutti wrote:Yes, it used to be Frutti but I changed it.

TBS likes this.

markp wrote:Culture

This. Beat me to it.

A lot of the high draft picks this year have had injury concerns.

Boyd and Scharenberg have had their issues. Was Aish struggling with injury too?

St Chris wrote:

Devilhead wrote:Billings
Dumont
Jones
Curren

I reckon this might be around the mark.

Would be very happy to get Jones, a genuine mid with grunt.

Yep.

Said this in the other post as well.

I think Dumont is going to be one of the best players from this draft. Just a hunch. Love the way he goes about it.

dragit wrote:If we want Weller for the main list we won't need to use the PSD... We can just sign him up as a de-listed free agent.

The PSD is largely redundant.

True.

We will, however, need to delist someone to make room for him on the list. TDL & Dunell the prime candidates I would imagine.

Very pleased with his appointment.

Had some personal dealings with him when I was doing some work commentating on the VFL.

Fantastic footy brain, great with developing youth, and a top bloke to boot.

Well done Saints.

I don't want Hartung.

Big knocks on his disposal/decision-making at times, and from some reports appears to be a bit full of himself. I think he will get found out at AFL level.

What I think:

3 - Billings
18 - Dumont
19- Z Jones

Although I would be equally happy with Matt Crouch, Blake Acres or Luke Dunstan with either of 18/19 too.

He hasn't even won a game yet FFS. Useless.

Agree with you 100% on this. If it could go: Pick 3- Billings Pick 18 and 19- Two of Crouch, Dumont, Sheed and Dunstan then I will be very happy. I would love Lennon to slide but that probably wont happen. This midfield heavy draft has come at the perfect time for us and we have the opporunity to b...

2014 - No Longer a Rabble

Pick 3 - Classiest midfielder available. From my limited knowledge, I can't split Billings, Kelly & Aish. Scharenberg might be a chance too. Billings might have that X factor about him, that Steve Johnson type who starts as a high HFF and moves into the midfield. Picks 18 & 19 - Best 2 insid...

2014 - The Savage Rebuild is on

Those ratings are hilarious! Heard Terry Wallace rate in 3 'tiers'... only the filth and the Saints were in the top tier. Were Brisbane in a tier of their own? Kinda feel sorry for them, a few years in development into 3 first round picks and a couple of other promising kids and they all want to go...

Bowey Boy wrote:Our rating - C+ according to The Hun...

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/a ... 6746839549

Not sure if they're being serious....