Mark, I agree 100%. We had this discussion a couple of months back and I posted the exact same suggestion. As far as I'm concerned the tri-colour front is our "brand". You show the front of our jumper to anyone in Australia who follows AFL and its instantly recognised.

if anyone does not know what number Harves wears they really should not be allowed to post !

It was a nothing to lose strategy for Saints If Cats Blake had agreed to go to Saints we would have had a 10 year ruckman. If not then we get ready mady King for the next 3 years and Cats have to up the price for Blake. Put the squeeze on the Cats with little risk to the Saints - nice to see the Sai...

no doubt in my mind that we could have won it in 2004 - 2006 if the injury gods had smiled on us. I remember walking out of TD last year after we played the Kangaroos thinking that the window had shut. However a few things have changed in the offseason for me: - for the first time in a while, I thin...

I am not a fan of Gwilt .. however I dont think he has been given his best opportunity to shine. Very similar to Ferguson IMHO ie not tall enough to play KP defender - and to be honest not sure why they persist with that for him. Will not be kept on next years list if he is not tried in other positi...

top 8 looks right to me ..bottom 8 wont finish like that - he's obviously an essendon supporter though - cant see them that high up the ladder

I called Joey after the very first intra-club game he played - I had to wait a while but he finally came through. Called Sam Gilbert after his first couple of senior games - looks like this will be his year. Although he's established, I'm still waiting for Leigh Fisher to step up another notch. Raph...

lots of "ifs and buts" .. here's hoping you are right !!!

Harvey - how much longer can this guy stay on our list .. bout time he showed something

... just kidding .. I'm one of his biggest fans. He can stay on the list as long as he likes !

No doubt the quality of the midfield since 04 & 05 seasons has gone down. Montagna the only one that has markedly improved since then. We need a few others to step up to join Ball, Hayes, Dal Santo & Montagna as 'A' grade midfielders (note - I am assuming that Ball has overcome his injuries)...

R Harvey still pretty handy - but at his peak was the best in the league

N Winmar was another who sticks in my mind as being a cut above

How are X and Raph shaping up this pre-season ?

Are they carrying injuries ?

Will they be ready round 1 ?

Any chance we might get a full season out of them ?

I am still waiting for these guys to play consistently good football. Hope it comes this year.

Its an interesting question.. I was a football club member in 97 (not a social club member) and the ticket window for grand final tickets shut with 6 people left in the queue in front of me. I never got a ticket for the 97 GF - which in hindsight I'm thankful for (I'm still devasted we lost). Anyway...

ok.. I know this may not be popular .. but I think 2007 was the first season where G had more bad (or ineffective) games than good ones .. so I was in the minority that actually was happy to see G retire - i thought it was the right time for him to go. Kosi for mine is a much better competitor in th...

I can't believe so many people put Fisher at CHB. He's a good player, but no where near good enough defensively to hold a Pavlich or Brown to less than about 10 goals. It might be time to check some facts. Maguire, and to a lesser extent Hudghton missed chunks of 2007 leaving Sam Fisher to hold the...

Fitzroy all over agin ..

Armoooo wrote:That is how it has always been on paper for some reason...

put a white back on it .. wear it with white shorts . .and hey presto thats a good looking "clash" jumper

I'd be amazed if North's board hadn't well and truly expected this move by the AFL actually. If the board didnt plan for this eventuality before they announced their decision to stay in Melbourne, then not only are they fools, they are doomed. Interesting 24 months ahead for them. I wish them all t...

can someone bottom line it for simpletons like me

Is the amount coming in from JW sponsorship greater than the sponsor $ that have left the club this year ... and significantly so or what ?

clubs had nothing to lose from rookie listing them...they were going to have to pay them their 2008 cotracted fee anyway...... I didnt realise that was the case .. well I guess I understand why they rookie listed him then..if they have to pay him, might as well keep him on the list in the off chanc...

terrific news on Mini the kid has talent, he needs a bit of confidence and some positive coaching. IMO talent doesn't go, discipline, confidence, health, fitness and dedication may go, but talent is talent. Well done mini, I hope you grab this opportunity with both hands and make it work for you. p...

Saint Bev wrote: But even if they shift to Mongolia, I would never give them up and I would stay a paid up member as I am now and always have been.

exactly Bev .. if you truely are passionate about the Saints you just cant give them up

Signed Sealed Sainter - a question for you. what if due to unforeseen circumstances you had to move to WA or QLD or NZ ? Would you stop supporting the Saints and start following the Eagles, Lions or a different code ? .. and dont take the option of saying you will never move .. because you just dont...

I wonder....since they did the faded number this year....why not just take a normal home jumper and do a fade effect on it....white light grey and light red with light grey shorts....then it will be the same but different.....could someone whip one up so we can see what it would look like why fade ...

Every AFL supporter recognises the traditional tri-color design as St Kilda - so why are we messing with that ?. It is what differentiates us from every other club. IMHO the clash design jumper should feature the traditional tri-colour front - but with an all white back worn with white shorts. That ...