CQ SAINT wrote:Siposs, Lee, Markworth, Billings. All continued risks calculated as huge potential but they have resulted in very little. Do we need more?

Yep if its Freeman.

We need carlisile. He is A GUN! Watch his highlights!! Great hands He had a down year. He hated being at essendon lost spirit. We will nevwr get a KPP so cheap lets POUNCE PLEASE!!! Give them pick 7 or whatever we end up with. This draft is pathetic!! Parish is Fiora Mathesion is just another bgrad...

There is no way dunstan will be traded. If it is a player and it is the bombers my guess is Ross or hickey But like I said earlier Carlisle is out of contract, has requested a trade and has wada hanging over his head. We owe Essendon f-all so if they don't deal he can go to Carlton in the psd for n...

Armo was robbed.. Dubious voting round 7-11 in particular! !! Maybe they got it right and you got it wrong. It seemed to me and a few others on here that Steven would win. Anyway second is clearly his best result. Hopefully he improves further but considering Jack had the taggers in most games he h...

There is no way dunstan will be traded. If it is a player and it is the bombers my guess is Ross or hickey But like I said earlier Carlisle is out of contract, has requested a trade and has wada hanging over his head. We owe Essendon f-all so if they don't deal he can go to Carlton in the psd for n...

I read a post on here last week that if we trade Billings for Carlisle St Kilda should fold....I agree that if we did this trade then we should fold. Now I'm hearing Newnes for Carlisle. I'll say it right now. If St Kilda trade Newnes for Carlisle then St Kilda may as well fold. But you are happy t...

There is no way dunstan will be traded. If it is a player and it is the bombers my guess is Ross or hickey But like I said earlier Carlisle is out of contract, has requested a trade and has wada hanging over his head. We owe Essendon f-all so if they don't deal he can go to Carlton in the psd for n...

Devilhead wrote:Apparently Sipposs gone according to the Trade Rumours thread & the Trade Rumours Extra thread

What about the delisted thread?

I read a post on here last week that if we trade Billings for Carlisle St Kilda should fold....I agree that if we did this trade then we should fold. Now I'm hearing Newnes for Carlisle. I'll say it right now. If St Kilda trade Newnes for Carlisle then St Kilda may as well fold. But you are happy t...

We'd be crazy to offer Newnes and a 2nd rounder for Carlisle. Picture WADA winning their appeal, by the time that happens and he gets a 2 years suspension, wouldn't that place it in our projected premiership window? What good would he be then? If we got him cheap, no probs, The club needs him to no...

If we did trade Seb to Essendon with our second for Carlisle, I would be asking them for their 3rd in return, which would be handy in other negotiations. Barry the will laugh at us trying to give them about pick 25 plus Ross for Carlisle. He will cost us our first rounder unless we can somehow get ...

Are we certain to play in NZ next season?

Hickey is 25 Longer is 21 Much more upside with longer. Hickey is ok but OK doesnt win you flags If we can off load Hickey, Saunders, our Picks and Ross (who we have heaps of) and get Carlisle Freeman Talia Kelly and Aish? We could win the flag in 2018. And reiwoldt still here. Is there any chance ...

In one way the top 5 is all a bit sad. Pretty much expected if you watched the games without looking for mistakes as the first thing you look at. Sad but expected? How so? Sad because the top 5 are already aging. Even the top 10 only has about 3 players under 25. 2 years ago Armo was a trade option...

Except Grundy had a better year No he didn't he was on the borderline for a while of getting dropped. I'm not sure he didn't this year actually. Don't care if he was dropped or not. Is a better all round player than Longer and was better this year. I still rate Hickey as a much better ruckman than ...

We certainly can afford to lose Seb because of how he plays. We have enough of them. The question is what would we get for him. Around a mid 20's pick in a weak draft and hasn't set the world alight. Only going to get a high second rounder or a third rounder. Maybe just keep unless someone shocks us.

Except Grundy had a better year

Amzing spin I would have thought. You say not to dissimilar but they have 2 under 23 in the top 5. 3 in the top 6. We have none in the top 6. None in the top 8. We have one in the top 10. They have 4. I'm not at all concerned about the ages of our older guys but more concerned with the finishing po...

Geez, I reckon some on here are looking at this with a glass half empty attitude. Of the top 15, we have: A winner at 25 6th at 24 8th at 23 9th at 22 11th at 22 and 23 13th at 24 and 14th at 22 That's more than half of the top 15 closer to the start of their careers than to the end. Not bad for a ...

Geez, I reckon some on here are looking at this with a glass half empty attitude. Of the top 15, we have: A winner at 25 6th at 24 8th at 23 9th at 22 11th at 22 and 23 13th at 24 and 14th at 22 That's more than half of the top 15 closer to the start of their careers than to the end. Not bad for a ...

Geez, I reckon some on here are looking at this with a glass half empty attitude. Of the top 15, we have: A winner at 25 6th at 24 8th at 23 9th at 22 11th at 22 and 23 13th at 24 and 14th at 22 That's more than half of the top 15 closer to the start of their careers than to the end. Not bad for a ...

magnifisaint wrote:He went to the best and fairest

He has a contract and is still playing so I would hope so. Anyway spoke to a Saints person on Saturday and he tole me they are waiting till Sandy finish before telling anyone. He is either wrong or they changed their mind.

Not interested? We are such a loser club. Shouldve got bennell carlisle freeman and melksham All great deals but We wont get any why? Cause we suk no one wants to work in seaford. The management of stkilda has been s*** for decades. We will never win an afl flag. Any otherclub with reiwoldt, kosi, ...

In one way the top 5 is all a bit sad. Pretty much expected if you watched the games without looking for mistakes as the first thing you look at. Sad but expected? How so? Sad because the top 5 are already aging. Even the top 10 only has about 3 players under 25. 2 years ago Armo was a trade option...

Poor saynta. No ability to do anything without and even then he struggles