Henderson is a very very average player. Barely AFL level. About to be dropped, on form, from the bottom side. That is not a player we should look to invest in. Comparisons to Carlisle are ridiculous. Carlisle is younger, bigger, better forward and better back. Just no contest. As bunk mentioned, if...

What's Holmes' running ability like? Blicavs goes all day. Blicavs is a s*** ruckman You obviously watch a lot of footy :roll: Blicavs is a gun this year Averaging 18 disposals, 17 hitouts, 6 tackles and just under 98 fantasy points on the afl which puts him at 39th best average in comp, yep he's a...

In saying that, and to completely contradict myself, I'd swap our first pick for Bennell over Kelly if given the option. Harley could be really really special.

But a massive yes to either one.

have no idea who he is but cheers Armoooo pretty much (apart from all saints games) watched two games of football all year Josh Kelly, went pick 2 ahead of Billings in the '13 draft. A unanimous pick 2, so very highly rated. Very slight still. Will be a star. Would swap for our first pick everyday ...

What about the following week, round 13? Plugger with a lazy 15 goals 4, from 20 kicks & 18 marks..

SENsei wrote:Oh and trading away early picks on key big men. I only have one word in response.


BarryBrooks.


Get it right or leave them alone.

Had Barry Brooks played 80 games and had an 8 goal game before we traded for him?

I've got another one word for you.

FraserGehrig.

Much like everything else in his game, even his development is slow.. Yes, there is some improvement. Is it enough to keep persisting with? One more season IMO, and if it is not a breakout year then cut our losses and look elsewhere. People compare him often to Sam Mitchell. The only similarities ar...

Seaford stuff is crap. As much as I think it's a hole, it'd have no baring whatsoever on Carlisle's or anyone else's decision to come to us or not. Primarily because it'll only be for 12 months before we are back at Moorabbin, and secondly because the $$'s on offer would make any drive to any destin...

I'm staying out of this.

1966 wrote: His kicking is very good which is important and gives him an advantage over Geary, Roberton and Gilbert.

Roberton is an excellent kick.

Vintage Geary.

24 in a few months. Realistically 7-8 years of footy in him. On his exposed form to this point he is worth pick 6 every day of the week. Not taking into account the WADA stuff, and in any case my personally opinion is the players will get 6 months at an absolute maximum, 3 more likely. So in that ca...

Think it's time to look elsewhere. He's had a decent year, getting worse as the year draws to a close and our youngsters tire.
Far too cute far too often. Don't see the point in playing him for the rest of the year, especially when roo gets back and we're good for experience.

Well at least this game should put an end to the Hickey v longer debate.
It won't, and Hick will be dropped at the next opportunity, but he is miles better than longer. Has that rare ability to actually get the ball.

How bad a game is Geary playing! Absolutely abysmal. Laughable.

Better get than Treloar or Aish. Just about at the top of my wishlist. His old man still a mad Dees supporter, goes to all their games in the Red Legs, heavily involved with the MFC and their hierarchy. Dees super confident he'll be in red and blue. We should do everything we can to blindside them....

Better get than Treloar or Aish.

Just about at the top of my wishlist.

His old man still a mad Dees supporter, goes to all their games in the Red Legs, heavily involved with the MFC and their hierarchy.

Dees super confident he'll be in red and blue. We should do everything we can to blindside them.

A few posters going off the deep end only due to the author, not content. Fair question, and much better than a lot of crap that gets posted on here (and everywhere else for that matter). Personally don't think it'd be an ongoing issue for him, as the injuries seem unrelated. However I'd be slightly...

Longer needs to lift he's getting smashed. Been smashed all year bar 2 or so games. The only real baffling aspect of Richos coaching is his constant Longer selection. Just don't get it. Unless it poised toward a trade. I'd be happy to get back what we paid for him. maybe he sees potential as I do. ...

Longer needs to lift he's getting smashed. Been smashed all year bar 2 or so games. The only real baffling aspect of Richos coaching is his constant Longer selection. Just don't get it. Unless it poised toward a trade. I'd be happy to get back what we paid for him. maybe he sees potential as I do. ...

Been a Schneider fan, but every possession today has been cute and caught out pretty much every time.

Goose is king wrote:Longer needs to lift he's getting smashed.

Been smashed all year bar 2 or so games.
The only real baffling aspect of Richos coaching is his constant Longer selection.
Just don't get it.

Unless it poised toward a trade. I'd be happy to get back what we paid for him.

Ross was crap last week. Deserved to be dropped.

Good/exciting changes.

Reduce the interchange rotations to 16, 4 per quarter, and there would potentially be a spot of White. Players would run far less, and choose more wisely when they'd exert their energy. As such, he'd be anchored closer to goal, in a more one on one likely contest. The interchange will not be reduced...

The game is unrecognisable from past era's. Probably for the worse. Yesterdays game was downright ugly, not taking into account the scoreboard. However I think many of us forget how many s*** games there used to be in what a considered great era's, as we only really remember the best matches. But it...