So a list of hiring and firing over a 12 month period proves we’re well managed? I thought so, your accusations have no substance. Enjoy your white whale hunt. A clutching straws argument if I ever heard one. A list of the so called “actions” as you may call it means nothing without results. Hiring...

The administration/board has done a few things in the last year. Which do you disagree with? If i've forgotten any, please add. - Appoint Lethlean CEO - Doing a full in depth footy review - Hiring Geoff Walsh - Sacking Ratten - Hiring Ross Lyon - Moving on Lade - Moving on McGlynn - Moving on Rath ...

Looks like another case of "The sky is falling, the sky is falling!" Seriously, taking pot shots at the club all the time is ridiculous. Emotional outbursts due to frustration don't achieve anything. Look at the facts. We all know we're a middle of the ladder team with insufficient talent...

And we’re still waiting for our first finals appearance since 2011. You spent 2020 in a coma? You’re right. The only finals appearance we’ve made since 2011 is the COVID hub year. How very St Kilda, to hang our hat on that. No wonder we’re such a sh*tty football club. So, in your world, 2020 didn't...

St Kilda is just a sh*tty football club at present and until you start fostering a culture which is desperate for success, we will only ever be just another sh*tty football club.

Wet Toast are due for a win. The only positive is that we’ve got our backs to the wall.

We are at risk to losing to WCE, as we have done before.

1971 wrote: ↑Sat 24 Jun 2023 11:39pm And still blaming some fish for selecting McCartin over a Tractor?

Who else should we blame? It was his call that relegated us to a wilderness for the last ten years.

Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Sat 24 Jun 2023 11:46pm

SydneySainter wrote: ↑Fri 23 Jun 2023 11:14pm And we’re still waiting for our first finals appearance since 2011.

You spent 2020 in a coma?

You’re right. The only finals appearance we’ve made since 2011 is the COVID hub year. How very St Kilda, to hang our hat on that.

No wonder we’re such a sh*tty football club.

More than you think.

Owens, Marshall, Sincs, Steele, Butler, Wilkie, Hill, King, Crouch, Battle and Gresh.

If R Clarke, Dawson, Eddy, Clint and Mini got games, why not the above.

Yep, we are definitely not playing finals this year. At this stage, I reckon West Coast will beat us.

Tonight hurt to watch. We are not good enough. But we knew that at the start of the year. That said- again at times threatened to win the game with a bit of luck. The kids will learn from the game. Other things we learned. Midfield exposed as not good enough and Sinclair is significantly better and...

And we’re still waiting for our first finals appearance since 2011.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again - Howard is an absolute liability.

MC Gusto wrote: ↑Fri 23 Jun 2023 10:48pmToo good

If you mean the Lions, they are not too good. Ask the Hawks.

Can’t we cop a break in this stupid game. Where is the midfield? You had 37 seconds to defend that quarter and we still let them take a breazy clearance to a goal.

FFS, this is just a carbon copy of last season.

Yeah but if McCartin had become a gun for us it wouldn't hurt as much. The following scenario below was as likely as the one you describe in your post above If Scott Watters was a premiership coach for St Kilda we wouldn't have had to put up with 6 years of mediocrity under Alan Richardson Nah, I d...

Yeah but if McCartin had become a gun for us it wouldn't hurt as much. The following scenario below was as likely as the one you describe in your post above If Scott Watters was a premiership coach for St Kilda we wouldn't have had to put up with 6 years of mediocrity under Alan Richardson Precisel...

Criticizing not picking Petracca is fine in hindsight. But not in context. We had 1 KPF player under 30 (Josh Bruce, 4 goals the previous year) when we went to the McCartin/Petracca draft. I don't buy the 'character' issues with Petracca, but if you throw that in as a layer of doubt, the decision m...

Good on the Tiges. Made all the right decisions and cleaned up with three flags. Meanwhile we dicked around at Seaford with half-arsed draft picks and clueless nice guy coaches. Those were not half arse draft picks. Petracca & Bontempelli together would have won this game. When you have low dra...

The club has failed him.

Should have played in more finals than the COVID hub year.

For a period, he was our only lead-up forward, despite being mid-sized.

lewdogs wrote: ↑Thu 15 Jun 2023 2:53pm A win this week and we can really start to dream...

Just shows what the last 12 years has done to us.

We previously used to dream about winning a premiership. Now we simply dream about winning finals.

How did we get this state?

Watched replay of DeGoey's On The Couch interview. Mentioned despite the large salary offer he did not think St Kilda could deliver the results available to him by staying at Collingwood (even with him playing for StKFC). He also mentioned he believed he knew a lot about football and that its enjoy...

bakes wrote: ↑Sun 18 Jun 2023 11:26am Beat them by 35 odd points and we’ll be in the top 4

Assuming the Bombers don’t also have a big win.

SaintPav wrote: ↑Mon 19 Jun 2023 9:53pm and you’ll start a thread on it right after like you usually do.

Depends on how badly we lose.