Marshall Like all of our best players, is not the problem It’s the ones who are poor that is hurting us Your best players can’t do more than play well, it’s the players who aren’t playing well that is the problem Paddy Ryder actually caused Marshall to be more ineffective Marshall is a C Grade Forw...

Marshall needs a Paddy Ryder style ruckman to come in and help, so its not all on his shoulders. Good luck finding one of those! I'd settle for any help that he can get...And that is not Caminiti or Owens. Exactly. Bring in Campbell, bring in Heath, just do something different, what's the worst tha...

Collingwood has an injury list nearly as long as Richmond and should have beat Freo at home with 6 players having less than 10 games experience! The excuse-makers and mediocrity-accepters on here and around the club have been using injuries and young players as "the reason" for a pitiful ...

Collingwood has an injury list nearly as long as Richmond and should have beat Freo at home with 6 players having less than 10 games experience! The excuse-makers and mediocrity-accepters on here and around the club have been using injuries and young players as "the reason" for a pitiful ...

Collingwood has an injury list nearly as long as Richmond and should have beat Freo at home with 6 players having less than 10 games experience! The excuse-makers and mediocrity-accepters on here and around the club have been using injuries and young players as "the reason" for a pitiful ...

One of the issues with our leadership group is their individual form. Steele - tries hard but is a shadow of his AA self Wilkie - tries hard but down on last year Sinclair - down on last year Ross - almost gone Marshall - great player but has major holes in his game that can be exposed Maybe they'r...

Collingwood has an injury list nearly as long as Richmond and should have beat Freo at home with 6 players having less than 10 games experience! The excuse-makers and mediocrity-accepters on here and around the club have been using injuries and young players as "the reason" for a pitiful p...

Otiman wrote: ↑Tue 28 May 2024 10:16am

The_Dud wrote: ↑Tue 28 May 2024 9:44am Games like this (and others this year) are perfect examples of why B&Fs aren’t necessarily the best way to rate players

I can't speak for other clubs, but the Trevor Barker Award rules help here.

What is the current system we run? I think last I saw every player gets votes?

One of the issues with our leadership group is their individual form. Steele - tries hard but is a shadow of his AA self Wilkie - tries hard but down on last year Sinclair - down on last year Ross - almost gone Marshall - great player but has major holes in his game that can be exposed Maybe they're...

Games like this (and others this year) are perfect examples of why B&Fs aren’t necessarily the best way to rate players

Stop bitching guys and concentrate on the game Yeah, you’re right But it absolutely pisses me off that he chooses an indigenous player as an avatar for his forum name of The Dud Forget the Indigenous - He has chosen a player who donned the RW&B - more than he has done - and has the audacity to ...

“Didn’t see that coming…” what’s he been watching the last 10 weeks?!

Devilhead wrote: ↑Sun 26 May 2024 11:18pm Nee Nor Née Nor Née Nor Née Nor

Careful Teffers ........ here comes The Dud Police

Yep we’re third last on the ladder and lost by 40 points because of the umpires… definitely don’t look at the coaches or players, nothing to see here!

The temp name change didn’t seem to bother the Dees…

111 to 98?? That doesn’t look like ‘Saints footy’ to me!

We are a basket case.

Again, lack of selection integrity, Cordy was dropped after doing nothing wrong, just because Howard is a ‘bigger’ name.

whiskers3614 wrote: ↑Sun 26 May 2024 6:19pm Where would we have been without Marshall's 15 metres gained?

Marshall’s deficiencies (which some refuse to acknowledge) were thoroughly exposed against a top quality ruckman in Gawn.

Ye of little faith! The excuse makers will always find something to blame and continue the mediocrity!

The umpire whinging is starting up again for one!

This is going to be controversial but Steele needs to be relieved of the Captaincy, he's part of our midfield problem, he's Seb Ross 2.0. He also just doesn't do anything to get his team going, even King shows more emotion after kicking a goal and that's saying something. See that brew ha ha at hal...

Through the middle again…

Instead of having a long drawn out post. I have watched the same thing from St.Kilda for 10 years. We win the ball on half-back but have no one forward of the ball to kick it to. What happens, we kick it directly to a defender, or put ourselves under pressure and make terrible skill errors, it's be...

Pickett caught drops it Fritsch goals You can’t make this up 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 Seriously FK OFF Dud C’mon, don’t join the crying crew, the umps have got zero to do with our problems or current situation. Change your avatar Change yours. I’ve offered to do that before arsehole Wowee that’s not very nice

Saintmatt wrote: ↑Sun 26 May 2024 5:28pm Never watched a team live so utterly dominated for 85% of a half and be two goals down.

I think it’s the current Ross gameplan, clog up the game as much as possible and make scoring hard then hope to snatch a victory at the end.

CURLY wrote: ↑Sun 26 May 2024 5:26pm Salem throw goal

Picket dropping the ball Frisch goal

There’s the lead right there