When it comes to St.kilda FC and the tribunal i was expecting 5-6 weeks so in that regard its a good result but bloody hell, 3 weeks for that is ridiculous. "Severe Impact"! What a crock. Murphy has concussion issues, anyone bar him and Paddy McCartin and it would be low impact. The fact ...

saynta wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 9:51pm

Sainter_Dad wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 9:40pm

saynta wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 8:44pm 3 weeks is better than I hoped for. Pity the filth player wasn't cited.

It was looked at - insufficient force.

Yeah, Caminiti stayed on his feet and later didn't fake concussion.

You have completely invented a narrative there, unbelievable.

What galls me is the preciousness and self-righteousness of Collingwood, followed by the media, followed by the tribunal. It was a murky incident involving argey-bargey and no clear vision. A player left the fiedl unassisted and mouthing off. But in the perception of Collingoowd, the media and the ...

Going by some of the gymnastics of reality here, by the time of the tribunal hearing it will be that Caminiti wasn’t even on the ground when the incident occurred and it was Nick Daicos who concussed Murphy during a high five gone wrong!

Some of the language IS over the top but your boy Murphy hasn’t exactly covered himself in glory. Plays with fire then complains when he gets burned. We have become a society of soft cocks with no one wanting to take responsibility for anything. How has he complained? By getting concussed? I would ...

It was not only behind the play, it was from behind, a king hit. Reckless, high contact and huge impact cause Caminiti gonna knock your arse out. f*** the 2 weeks, well earnt. Pussies like that shouldn't be playing on Anzac Day. Repercussion concussion, sad, dangerous, but appropriate in the circum...

I think I gave and option in the OP - Owens Or even the post directly before yours… Campbell I’m not scapegoating him - he is the 23rd best player in the team You don’t rely on your worst player I’m just making a point - he is almost useless Maybe as a back up defender he can justify being on the l...

Cordy 3+ quarters as a ruck forward 1 kick 5 HB 2 HO Owens 1qtr as a ruck forward 8 possessions 3 HOs Also when Bytel came on as Sub for Cordy - 6 disposals Structure my arse - using a Gumby to fill a role will always get found out by good opposition. Bloke couldn’t run out of sight on a dark night...

You can’t change a winning team??? What if King was available Steele was available That is nonsense Even in a big win - there are non contributors Wins wallpaper over cracks - our conversations of i50s to scores is 17th in the league - better forwards come in - he’s gone imo Do you honestly believe...

Watch the same guys defending him jump off when we start losing a few and we look for scapegoats I’ll remember the posters who have lept to his defence- and remind them And yes, if he wins a B&F I will be converted to a Cordy fan, if he wins 2 I will call him a gun! But seriously do you think h...

Waivers may cover some liability in the short term if something happens, but will mean pretty much nothing in the grand scheme of things if down the track more problems develop. I spoke to a doctor friend who (pre covid cutbacks) was working with the AFL on concussion studies and tracking about Padd...

CURLY wrote: ↑Sun 09 Apr 2023 8:36am Has to be minimum two otherwise the AFL has again proven they cheat.

It’s more clearly cheating in the Saints favor if that were to get two weeks. Is one week at most, hardly any force.

Likely to be a Bulldog fan unhappy with the performance I think that all reports seem to indicate it was one of our own unfortunately. Wrong. All reports were quotes from our club, feeding the assumption that it was an oppo supporter, i.e. a Saints fan. I saw nothing to suggest it was a Sainter. Th...

Can't help but feel it was a bit of a direction last night the free kicks Ugle Hagen received. Of course, another afl conspiracy curly? Like the arc robbing Richmond of the final last year because as you claimed ‘ they don’t want dusty on the podium”? Sometimes people play well and also get a coupl...

saynta wrote: ↑Tue 21 Mar 2023 5:59pm Yep, Highmore might replace Webster with Windy to replace Bytel. Paton in with Butler the sub.

Don’t mind that either, but the dogs forward line is not going to be as tall this week with Lobb out (good for us, as he seems to only get dangerous against the saints).

Was just looking at the list with the injuries, basically i think the fit players we have that did not play last week are: Ross (fitness test, possibly unlikely) Windhager Campbell Sharman Connolly Highmore Van Es Peris Adams Heath Very slim pickings, especially to replace a running defender and a m...

I am a long time viewer and very occasional poster on this forum and can confirm that the reason I don't post often is because of the exact type of grievances that are being discussed in this thread. Reasonable discussion being derailed by posters who know/think they are right on some point and refu...

Nick didn’t do a shoulder He cracked his collarbone That’s only a 5-6 week injury Question Why is Max King still skinny (baby giraffe as someone said) He’s is in his 5th preseason, he’s been training at Moorabbin since 2018. His lower body is massive - Upper body is skinny as fk He's clearly too sk...

Also, I have stood next to both King boys, Max is broader across the shoulders than I thought he was from watching from afar. Ben (pre knee injury) looked more developed in the upper body and had more bulky arms and chest, which I always thought was a reflection of being able to play in his draft ye...

Nick didn’t do a shoulder He cracked his collarbone That’s only a 5-6 week injury Question Why is Max King still skinny (baby giraffe as someone said) He’s is in his 5th preseason, he’s been training at Moorabbin since 2018. His lower body is massive - Upper body is skinny as fk He's clearly too sk...

If wasn’t so tragic you’d laugh I’ve had a shoulder reco, knee and ankle. None are remotely back to what they were and never will be. But the shoulder is shot, cannot bowl fully or throw a cricket ball whatsoever anymore - I got a full reco in 2017 - by the same shoulder specialist orthopaedic surg...

Never have I seen a better mark than Goddards in the GF in the goal square in the GF in the last - right in front of me !!! At that point I thought we had it - BRING HIM DOWN💪 Were you the bloke sitting behind me in the ponsford stand in the bay next to the pies cheersquad, who hugged me when he ma...

...about future contract.... ....prior to the start of Season 22. he was played.. Tough? He* tried to push the club to give him a determination..pre-season by demanding that the club tell him mid-season..(demanding? Asking??) Bassat and co. are seasoned campaigners... They say, 'Sure Brett, whateve...

Sam Weideman or Josh Shache for FA Paddy Dow made a big play Bowes and 7 - should have been in that up to our eyeballs Plenty of Bargains there, which other clubs got And not sure why we couldn’t net a 800k player since Hannebery retired? Fkn hopeless So I presume these players wanted to come to th...