The last time we played WB we beat them 17.14 to 14.5 So how come all of a sudden they are a better team than us? Look at the stats from that game We add Hannebery, Hill and Ryder and lose Bruce Plus we add the unknown of King and Bytel - and anyone else we snag who is an AFL known contributor So w...

Finally... ...have no real bias either way, but with his recent injury record, and Marshall functioning well in a 1 ruck team, unless we're considering a new structure and game plan I can't see him playing much footy. Anyways, I hope goes as well for us as he usually does against us. Told you a wee...

Viscount Jeremiah wrote: ↑Wed 25 Sep 2019 7:09pm Still not sure why we want Keath.

Good player but not one we need surely?

I guess having him down back doing Battle's role might free Josh up to go forward? If we trade Bruce it might be handy to have a new forward freed up.

Was there an uproar when the Dawks got pick 18-ish for Buddy (way unders)? Or when Melbourne got pick 3 for James Frawley (way overs)? Nope ... LOL...bloody oath there was! I'm pretty sure there wasn't an uproar. It was more of a shake of the head/roll of the eyes because everyone knew/knows that i...

Finally...

...have no real bias either way, but with his recent injury record, and Marshall functioning well in a 1 ruck team, unless we're considering a new structure and game plan I can't see him playing much footy. Anyways, I hope goes as well for us as he usually does against us.

Was there an uproar when the Dawks got pick 18-ish for Buddy (way unders)? Or when Melbourne got pick 3 for James Frawley (way overs)?

Nope ...

LOL...bloody oath there was!

howlinwolf wrote: ↑Sun 22 Sep 2019 8:17pm

Ghost Like wrote: ↑Sat 21 Sep 2019 3:29pm RULE 1 - Do NOT deal with Essendon

RULE 2 - NEVER forget RULE 1

Stephen Milne says hello

Rookie selection taken from Essendon's reserves list, I don't think there was much dealing to be done.

Andrew Lovett says hi!

Back to the Rich vs Geel game. Did anyone notice how many Richmond goals were set up by Rhys Stanley mistakes! Yes, he had a shocker...that one where they were away mid last quarter, only for him to handpass into the air 5m behind the Cats player on the burst, killed the game. He's been talked up h...

I'm glad the filth are out only for the reason I don't have to look at Chris Mayne’s head again this season. Did you see the ugly headed clown at the end of the match. He has tears streaming down his face. f****** sook. Made me laugh though. Cwoar...you're a hard unit...I bet he reads this and crie...

SaintPav wrote: ↑Sun 22 Sep 2019 12:31pm I'm glad the filth are out only for the reason I don't have to look at Chris Mayne’s head again this season.

LOL! Harsh.

Geelong isn’t getting one over us, Jack Steven is. Basically reading between the lines he’s said he doesn’t want to play football unless it’s at Geelong. This gives us no bargaining power, contract or not. Geelong knows we either take what they’ve got or pay a bloke $600-800k to not play for us aga...

Geelong will not give up Constable as part of the Stevens trade Having a look at their midfield on Friday night, if he's any good they'd be mad to give him up. Of course, he's already had a reasonable run in their midfield this year before being omitted, maybe just making sure they get another pre-...

As I posted on Thursday, he has nominated St Kilda! No he hasn't. Whatever you say. Well, lets face it, whatever I say is looking a shitload more accurate than whatever you say at this point. Have there been any reports of him nominating the Saints or anyone else? This is painfully drawn out, I'd l...

Pffft...planning to do anything about any reports this time?

Healthy dose of scepticism whenever I see Lethlean quoted on something being good for the club.... but then dig deeper...... and one of his mates magically benefits from it - oooold B.Scott. Always a conspiracy theory! The journo has put it front and centre - it's clearly their opinion too. First t...

samoht wrote: ↑Sun 22 Sep 2019 9:48am The joke here is Tobey Greene himself and the way the AFL protects and tolerates him.

Absolutely...this is the only point worth considering when raising bias, GWS and the AFL.

Bernard Shakey wrote: ↑Sun 22 Sep 2019 11:41am As I posted on Thursday, he has nominated St Kilda!

No he hasn't.

Geelong will not give up Constable as part of the Stevens trade Having a look at their midfield on Friday night, if he's any good they'd be mad to give him up. Of course, he's already had a reasonable run in their midfield this year before being omitted, maybe just making sure they get another pre-...

Joffa Burns wrote: ↑Sun 22 Sep 2019 11:23am Do you believe Ryder nominated Saint with a view to playing VFL?

Has he actually nominated anyone yet? This is painful.

The MRP are just squaring up for their lack of action over the Bont incident the week before...should never have played this weekend regardless. He's a hard player to love, hope he enjoys sitting on the pine.

The trade for Hill is red hot going to happen. I think Pick 5 is ok given we are getting an AA wingman at 26. Unless we split pick 5 with 11 and 13 with GWS and give 11 to Freo for Hill. Interesting times. Remind me again when he was All Australian. That would be difficult...but I can remind you th...

I honestly don’t get why we want Ryder he’s 32, got dodgey ankles and won’t come cheap. I’d rather get Stanley back as part of the Steven deal with the cats plus Constable, we’d have to throw in a late 3rd round pick as well, and have 2 mobile rucks who can both go forward. Far out, Steven and a 3r...

I would be happy with: Hill $900,000 a season for 4 years with trigger for 5th year in exchange for Pick 5 and Acres receiving back Pick 24 along with Hill (which would give Fremantle picks 5 and 6 in the draft) We take pick 24 (probably slides to 25) either to the draft night OR use it to secure Z...

Bleeding heart it seems. Good. More power to him. Not good when it influences his decisions. Call me old-fashioned but I like a judiciary that makes decisions based on the law rather than on personal political preference. If they’re genuine refugees under the law then let them stay. But if they’re ...

saynta wrote: ↑Fri 06 Sep 2019 10:26pm Bleeding heart it seems.

Good. More power to him.