I guess he’ll be Mason Wood’s temporary replacement. My guess is no. Does not yet have the tank, and to play wing these days you need a huge tank. If King gets suspended. Caminiti to come in. Wing will be Byrnes and or Jones. Jones was the sub and will come into the 22. Wilson to also rotate throug...

Otiman wrote: ↑Wed 20 Mar 2024 9:00pm Seen a few posts on bigfooty but probably before Feb.

I wouldn't want to be seen on this place after some of the meltdowns last week.

3 posts in the last two days on BF.

I suspect he was tired of the constant attacks on this forum by several posters.

I must have missed the bit where Collard suddenly became a mid capable of playing at stoppages. I think it was more that one of Crouch or Ross had to make way for Jones who can midfield pace. All of Steele, Crouch and Ross make for a slow midfield group. Henry made a difference when injected there ...

Nas is wonderfully balanced smart player - can lose 1v1 contests Wow, it is almost like he has played less than 50 games, is only in his third season, and is still building his body.... If there is one young player on our list who I am confident will have a long and glorious career, it is Nas.

Personally I think King, Coops and Members can all work together up forward… most likely one pushing up. Owens found his way down forward for stints tonight and Coops is a waaaaay better set shot. Got to figure out Owens’ best role too Sharman should be one of our three marking forwards. King, Memb...

bigcarl wrote: ↑Sat 16 Mar 2024 12:21am Collingwood, lol.

The only premiers who has been ZIP-2 after ROUND 1.

So you missed the Cats losing their first three games last season?

Higgins is - lead up and play for free kicks. Butler is being played as a pressure forward with the odd opportunistic 'over the back'. Collard is a high flying, mosquito crumber. This is the true small forward we need. Based upon what Membrey said when he announced Collard's selection his role when...

Lovett Bennell Lyon loves a failed experiment Michael Gardiner Failed experiment? Michael Gardiner. While he had a poor injury run in his latter years and then also had some offield problems I do not think you could really say he was a failed experiment at the Eagles where he played 129 games and m...

emmdee wrote: ↑Mon 11 Mar 2024 4:06pm I may be wrong, but thought RTB had a couple of wins in Geelong with the Dockers, all about game plan for the ground dimensions.

Yes RTB has had some good wins at KP.

RTB is not phased by coaching teams to win at KP. So he probably will have a few ideas on how to help us win.

Arie will be in the running. The downside though is that Hawkins and Cameron are both quality key forwards who are very experienced. Plus the Cats team as a whole is very experienced. So I think the selectors will opt for Cordy's experience and more mature body. So assuming Battle is fit and he see...

Injured I think BBMD Yes injured. As of 5 March. Dan Butler Ankle 2-3 weeks Hunter Clark Calf 3-5 weeks Paddy Dow Knee 3-5 weeks Jack Hayes Knee 4-5 weeks Dougal Howard Hamstring 4-5 weeks Ben Paton Pectoral 12-16 weeks Mattaes Phillipou Hip Test Jack Sinclair Calf 1-2 weeks James Van Es Ankle 4-5 ...

Well if a poster's info here is correct, that Clarkson called Jimmy (and was it Dougal?) c*cks*ckers. Whilst vulgar and inappropriate, not homophobic. Not only gay gentleman indulge in such. This was not a AFLW Game though. And how often anyway do you hear it directed at women? If as in this case, ...

chook23 wrote: ↑Sun 03 Mar 2024 8:14pm

Howard and trainer....Not the look of concern

If injured appears too happy

Surely this is prior to injury

Howard played in the RED Stickman today, not the BLUE training top.

cwrcyn wrote: ↑Tue 27 Feb 2024 3:37pm from that dim sim munching drunk

Dim Sim munching, and drinking? Is that Plugger 66?

Pretty big call BM. He’s been on the list for 3 months Some of our new kids have come from very professional set ups and so have been in good systems for a while. Arie is not one of the them. This is probably Arie's first year in a truly well supported and professional environment. He may knuckle d...

Elwood Peckett and Boston Everitt at training this week Hope I am 100% wrong, but I don't see either of them making it. Big hopes on the Reiwoldt & Hayes boys 8-) Barry Hall has 3 boys but played what 90 games with us? Hope Josh Bruce's son isn't a gun with his 99 matches. I wanted us to list D...

Can St Kilda still get him back? I don’t think so. I’m under the impression we have a full list and the reason he was cut in the first place was that Schonmaker (spelling) fell into our lap with the last pick. Happy to be corrected Yes that plus Port delisting Riley Bonner. Two unexpected recruits ...

I am the most bullish I have been about our future since 2010! When do you see us being in premiership contention? I can see us getting better each year for the next 4 years. Longer if we keep drafting /trading like we have done in recent year. This year would probably be too early and would requir...

Still don’t know why we paid for him to fly to Germany and see a specialist For his own or another team’s benefit Is it really that hard to understand? Because when he went, he was still a chance to be a St Kilda player in 2024. So it was for St Kilda's benefit. Then : 1/ The club I am pretty sure ...

Their sneaky old bastards will play their tricks. Expect Tuohy to try and provoke Caminiti to throwing a punch. Might be hard as I suspect he may not make our starting 22. But agree on your point that the Cats are a very experienced unit. But also time is starting to catch up on a few who might be ...

Otiman wrote: ↑Mon 08 Jan 2024 8:59pm This is worth a look. Saints Key Forwards 23 and under.

Thanks. So if we use that data and then apply the Vortex Rating System (Patent Pending) to them Sharman, Caminiti and Owens are all duds who should be delisted.

If he can deliver a performance like that ......, instead of every 30 games then he should go a long way to gaining respect. LOL. He has only played 31 games. And he has had a lot more than 2 decent games. In his first season his 4 games were all ok to excellent. His second season he struggled some...

Please discuss.... GOAT = Oh so you mean, Good to Ordinary Attacking Teamplayer? I am a Sharman fan, but lets discuss him in the right context. He had a very good development season last and went well in the different roles that Lyon had him play, and demonstrated that he can be a good team role pl...

2 - We did not take a ruckman in the draft, so RTB must have considerable faith in Max Heath I disagree with this. Ruckman often take a while to become good if drafted. However it is very common for clubs when in the the Premiership Window to trade in a ready yo go ruckman. Look through the Premier...