GWS will probably be culling better players than those suggested in the OP's trade scenario

Good if it happened but I give it 1% chance

Missed chance this year for Matty

I was one who thought he had alot of upside.

Was hard at player and ball,frequently hurt an oppo player withfair physi al aggression.

Good luck to him

Good leap and good hands

Ming and Bing could be FF and CHF

I agree it is unlikely but I don't see Bing living in Maxs shadow...they would be a dynamic forward line.

Put Battle at CHB Clavarino at FB and you would have a total Haileybury spine.

Surely the AFL has to declare list numbers before anyone can trade with certainty?

Forget Treloar and keep the cash for Merrett as a FA...I would LOVE to rip him out of that crack house of a club.

Cool. Good insurance that we can hold our structure.

I heard BJ Goddard on trade radio today. He seems to think Seb is surplus especially with Jones, Steele, Crouch and perhaps Gresh as the starting mids. He had Hannas mainly playing wing and rotating in the middle plus with the emergence of Clark and maybe Bytel there’ll be limited spots for inside ...

He's a very good player and worthy of a FRDP
2 x BnF

Saad is a pick 8


Is he that much better than Ross?

Jy Caldwell asked to be traded to Essendope. Makes him a dope in my eyes. But two days into trade period nothing has happened. Clearly Dildo and GWS did not come to an agreement on the trade before the start of trade period. Two days and no talk of a deal. This move is not done. Caldwell does not b...

asiu wrote: ↑Wed 28 Oct 2020 5:30pm can she hit a 3 wood ?

Just want to give special kudos to this line

If we are in the hunt for Treloar then we should ask for a 3rd round pick and settle for a 4th if it came to it. We are only clearing space so offer him low. If we really aren't looking to free up space then ask for a 2nd round pick. Ask for an upgrade of pick 17 to pick 8 (equal to pick 35 on poin...

Just shows to me how one sided loyalty is. No wonder the modern player thinks of his contract first and team second. When Maguire and Bucks are hugging you and telling you that you are a Pies player thu and thru and how much we love you and you bleed black and white..... And then desperately try and...

I reckon Dunstan wpuld be great for Blues...He would give them clearances and Paddy could get outside more often.
Dunstan is a good leader and great trainer and preparer ..And they would get him for a bargain if they take his salary

On the surface getting Adam Treloar seems like a good idea but in my humble opinion, it's just too messy. Number 1, the length of his contract is a problem, 2025 is a big commitment, particularly if he continues to have hamstring problems. Secondly, we don't have a lot of currency to trade for him....

If Hannas hamstrings are definitely better since that last surgery...we all of a sudden have a beast midfield

Gotta be proud of our club

Still getting used to the idea that we are bossing it...staring down clubs...doing awesome deals...winning finals... .

What has happened to us ?!
I like it!

Hilarious effort Adelaide....

Welcome Brad

So...anything happened yet?

Don't the Crows need to match by now?

I think getting out of Adelaide which seems to have been a very depressing place recently...and into the exuberant vibe of a Ratten lead Stkilda will see Brad play his best footy.

If Lonie turns into a gun at the Dogs, I'll spew. If Lonie turns into a gun, i’ll eat your spew. He’s a muppet!!! Lonie is better than Kent & Hind with whom he competes for a spot in the team. Yes Higgins is an upgrade on Lonie but surely we can move on Kent & Hind before Lonie. I don't get...

All they need to do is simply say they are disappointed not to receive a better pick, but will move ahead with the FA take their pick and be active in the trade period.

They come off as the good guys for facilitating the deal, the AFL come across as the bad guys and we are simply the opportunists .

Ok...this is as close to ITK as I get:

I am hearing through my one contact (friend of current listed player) - that Lonie is likely gone.

No news on if we get Higgins though.

I'd love to hear from fellow saints fans how they see our best 22 looking for next season, allowing for the additions of Crouch and Higgins and Carlisle staying. Mine is: Paton Howard Wilkie Long Carlisle Coffield Hill Steele Clarke Butler Marshall Billings Gresham King Membrey Ryder Crouch Jones I...

Pretty much that

Hard to find a spot for Geary

I think the last spot on the list is between Ross, Sinclair and Bytel.