Least Caminiti took his full 30 secs 👍🤣 Even though we were 7 points down with 40 seconds to go I totally disagree with your criticism. He had to kick the goal. He took the time he needed. He kicked the goal- AND there were still 41 seconds on the clock at the next bounce . As we saw, still plenty ...

It’s just not one bad game though. It’s been a concerning trend. His first 3 games were all very good. His last 2 not so. Hardly a trend Doesn’t lead. Doesn’t work hard enough. Misses goals regularly. His game is very flawed and is what I’m talking about. I wonder if he has been instructed to stay ...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 8:56pmMarshall

I am afraid a 1 word vote cannot be counted - except for a 1

StPeter wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 7:55pm

skeptic wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 6:14pm Hope nobody minds. I fixed the thread title

Thanks, my mistake in my enthusiasm

Certainly a lot to be enthusiastic about

Add
Wilson
Phillipou
NAS
Owens
Windhager

The future feels promising

GWS player has prior run run run - Garcia tackles him - he basically just flops over the line for a throw in - no attempt to get rid of the ball.

PS This is after a very clear throw

Will be interesting to see if Matt Crouch is in trouble for head high bump on attempting to get the ball

I feel that Greene out would have changed the game. Not giving a 3 goal headstart probably would have made changed he game as well I agree - and Pou not kicking into the man on the mark and Owens not mongrel punting it OOTF but they are our issues The AFL has said it would penalize on Potential to ...

cwrcyn wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 7:04pm TheNotSoGreatZacsby, I'll have you know I once karate chopped a 1m length of balsa wood with my bare hand.

My assistant, Mr Batfink, was suitably impressed

How dare you question my mastery of martial arts!!!!

Yeah - I have a black belt of Macrame

Would you have traded McKay out if you were Carlton last year? I think King is a CHF with a tank - we just need a FF and 3 zones to target inside 50 - and the miss told to kick it there - even if no-one is in the spot - it is the forwards job to get there Watching Ade v Car at the moment - their for...

The Fireman wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 6:58pm Hard as a cats head

LOL - needs to also be as mad as a cut snake

Maybe we need a defensive forward

David Zita just reported that RTB has advised that King has been cleared of ligament damage

I feel that Greene out would have changed the game.

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 6:26pm Big fan

Said in another thread earlier this week

He will be better than Wilson and Phillipou

Very slick player, and tough


He will be the steal of the draft

If your whipping boys are Phillipou and Wilson you are probably not doing too bad

Need 3 kicking zones occupied by 3 big guys I would be happy if King did not kick another goal for the season - if Hammer, Higgins and Membrey kick 20 because he has taken the best defender and taken them to ineffective places Not sure all the blame can be laid at his feet - but FFS stop flipping th...

Showed Philippou what a real effort looks like. - had better stats than Pou in 1/2 the time on the ground. From inside sources - Phillipou has asked for more time in the midfield to learn the craft. Considerably hard position to learn. Not sure what people want from a 19 yo - they can’t all hover a...

skeptic wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 6:14pm Hope nobody minds. I fixed the thread title

I am sure nobody minds - just important to me that a player is named correctly

Aside from being a Garcia not Gacia

Does he play as a small forward? If so -
Butler may have to work really hard to get back as Hugo seems to have the tackling covered.

Abso f@rking lutely

49 AF points in his TOG

3 kicks
8 handballs
6 TACKLES

Not saying it was a great game - but if we bring Q4 on Thursday it will be fun

So time on not paid if you mark and lining up for a shot at goal anymore? Can't remember when it was - that is why the rule came in - because a player from North took literally a minute to have his sho in the dying seconds of a game (against us) That was our own Mason So time on not paid if you mar...

If a W would have been highway robbery - Call me Dick Turpin - I want more W's

So time on not paid if you mark and lining up for a shot at goal anymore? Can't remember when it was - that is why the rule came in - because a player from North took literally a minute to have his sho in the dying seconds of a game (against us) It was Mason Wood ! I know - but pled the 5th seeing ...

thecrevis wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 5:32pm It's not Caminiti's fault, he'd a kid - but why on earth were teammates not telling him to kick it quickly?

Had no right having the shot - that mark was one out of a million.

Bowey Boy wrote: ↑Sat 13 Apr 2024 5:35pm So time on not paid if you mark and lining up for a shot at goal anymore?

Can't remember when it was - that is why the rule came in - because a player from North took literally a minute to have his sho in the dying seconds of a game (against us)