plugger66 wrote:

st_Trav_ofWA wrote:

plugger66 wrote: Having said that Brooks will have to go this year. Not rated in RL opinion obviously.

nor GTs as he never got a game then either
me thinks hes just not good not that hes out of favour

Bingo.

double-bingo

JB, that whole rant of yours had alot of good points, and alot of terrible ones

legalising illicit drugs?!?!

how bout ACTUALLY punishing drug makers/dealers/users

they should give that a try

IMO, and it appears others aswell, disregarding all sentiment, Thommo and Voss should be picked ahead of CJ, Gwilt, Birss and Ferguson on form alone

i don't go to training, but my opinion would be ruck skills - Clarke > Rix > Brooks disposal - Brooks > Rix > Clarke effort - Rix >Clarke > Brooks overall - Rix >Clarke > Brooks haven't seen rix get a mention in the local rag or be in the best for scorps... clarke? may have been good once. effort? ...

just saw the full interview on the footy show (NRL) and the bloke looked like he was gonna throw up or pass out in his seat appears to be doing it tough, tho he's brought it all upon himself, and probably deserves it i also think that it highlighted the fact that most of us are probably ignorant to ...

i haven't been to the MCG in years

but i'm taking it that the Ponsford stand is the way to go

with general admission tickets, which level in the Ponsford stand can i sit on, and which is the best?

thanks

Kosi is a marvellous player, but - if (as has been rumoured) he is holding out for a longer contract and can get it from one of the more desperate clubs then St Kilda would be right to let him go IMO. His career could be over in the twinkling of an eye: can anyone imagine that he would be able/allo...

how old is he?

cos he already seems passed his best

I am an enormous fan of V2, but it has to be said that he was given a golden opportunity to prove himself again at the AFL level, and he squibbed it completely. I'm afraid I can't see any viable future for him. I'd rather see guys like Gwilt, Ferguson, Raph Clarke and Allen given a go. spot on... h...

i don't go to training, but my opinion would be

ruck skills - Clarke > Rix > Brooks

disposal - Brooks > Rix > Clarke

effort - Rix >Clarke > Brooks

overall - Rix >Clarke > Brooks

this would be the equivilent of Hirdy coming out and saying he's been on the drugs fro 10 years

NRL will be shattered

SaintBot wrote:
someone on the melbourne board...cant identify him or anything otherwise i could get him (or myself) in some strife as melbourne dont intend to make an announcement untill next week

on another note, they'd be fools not to pick Sheedy

i think Thommo deserves a spot regardless of whether it was his last game or not IMO, all things considered, Thommo is a better choice than CJ he is not as slow as people say, and CJ isn't as quick whats the point of being the fastest player in the league if u can't find the ball, and when u do ur d...

i haven't been to a game at the MCG in years, and i have no idea about where to sit and buy tickets where do you get to sit with General Admission tickets, and where is the best place? and i usually buy General Admission tickets on the net (for the Dome) but i can't seem to do that for this game, so...

Are you on DRUGS? Yes, I regularly take cocaine, and don't mind escstacy at the odd party ... Hate smoking weed though ... don't understand people who do that. I don't believe Gehrig will be part of our next premiership team. I believe we are too predictable with him in the side, and that a forward...

wow, if only he was a drug addict, then u'd class him as a champion........


(look, i can do it too!)

if we do make the finals, i honestly think we have a real chance of beating all three of those teams, aslong as we show up to play

on another note, did anyone catch the Bulldogs/Hawks game today?

geez Hawthorn looked alot better after the half-time break, Clarkson's speach must have been a real pick-me-up

interesting to note, on the coverage tonight they said that (before this game) since the mid season break, if you started a whole new ladder, we'd be 3rd behind Geelong and Port thats why i think if we scrape into the finals, and bring our game from the first quarter tonight, we'd be a chance to bea...

Raph Clarke showed us again why he still demands 'dud' status, he moves like a battleship, and up stairs he's even slower 20 possessions only 2 were ineffective played on a guys much taller and absolutely belted them and he is a dud. You are a d**khead!!!! Get off his back he has had no pre-season ...

if Fiora could get his kicking right, he would be a gun

Ferguson didn't have a great game, but was far from our worst

just thought he deserved his own thread, for heaping praise on this champ who is our best player by a MILE again best on ground for us tonight, stepped up in the last when we needed him was EXTREMELY impressed with his kicking tonight, if only we could get him to be more selfish kept us in it tonigh...

lol, lets not open up this can of worms again....

i disagree

if our defence could have put in even a tiny wimper tonight, we would have won

we did have a few costly turnovers (mostly from the usual suspects) but so did WCE

Maguire Clarke R Clarke M Blake Fisher S Ball all had there pants ABSOLUTELY pulled down tonight ...and add Gehrig. What a frustrating player! 2 goals, had the opportunity to kick a few more, did some good things without the ball in the forward 50 didn't have a great game, but was far from our wors...