13 disposals, 5 marks, 10 hit outs, .5 goals is a healthy return from a 201cm 90kg rookie in his first 13 games. His move to the Ruck certainly proved he can ruck but it detracted nothing from his ability to play CHF. Yep, I maintain that to win a premiership you need players that can mark the foot...

Quite a few reasons right there to choose Harvey ahead of Ratten.

Tough crowd when you're rated on your performance in half a dozen games as a fill in coach of someone elses team.

Then, of course, there's his reasonably successful coaching record...

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 05 Sep 2019 5:27pm At cricket training last night, we were talking a bit of finals footy and trades when a mate who barracks for North ask me WTF we were actually doing...

LOL...a North supporter can poke fun at St Kilda? And you didn't hold a mirror up to him and say f@rk off?

The Barometer wrote: ↑Thu 05 Sep 2019 9:38pm Bruce definitely traceable.

Yep...big guy, usually seen in the St Kilda F50 when not at training, 27 on his back...

Quite comfy with him not getting the job to be honest...in a period of record senior coach turnover in the AFL, Harvs has remained solidly as an assistant in (up until the last few seasons) a middle rung team. Who else has he ever been tied to? Personally, I reckon the very definition of small-minde...

Watch this space. So Scoop posts at 1.43PM Whereas September 4, 2019 at 1:37pm TOM MORRIS https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trade-news-blog-with-tom-morris-verdict-on-exchange-periods-biggest-names/news-story/c8a6b31675fc84bb658710ae97382480 What trades could St Kilda make? You can lock Bradley ...

What do they have to offer in return? Pick in the mid teens maybe. Do they have a suitable player we might want whom they’ll trade? What would be a good value deal for Josh? I hope he stays, but we have to give to get. A 50 goal a year forward? Dogs first pick or tell your story walking, surely? I ...

I want B King at the club badly, but we would be so royally bent over if we attempt to pick him up before his contract is out, I just can't see it happening. We've got nothing that would satisfy them regardless. I'd rather we wait 'til the getting's good.

Waltzing St Kilda wrote: ↑Mon 02 Sep 2019 10:00pm Smells of Michael Frost.

Hey, this guy tore us apart in one game last year. He must be a superstar!

Let's take him with our first round pick.

Delisted after one year.

LOL, my thoughts exactly. Dean Kent used to go pretty well against us too, from memory.

Senior bodies made all the difference to Brisbane, as it will the Suns...but sadly we don't have a Lyon, Cameron or Neale to offer them. As for The Suns, they need to grow a pair and do some deals to get established stars onboard.

We were right into him last year, possibly the year before, yet everyone else seems to be in the box seat according to the media. Says something IMO...Ah Chee could be worth a look though, I agree.

If he goes he will become a gun. He has something. 23yo 194cm midfield beast anout to hit 100 games. I hope we dont get rid of him.Will regret. Sorry, when did he become a midfield beast? I must have missed that game. Acres out, Hill in...whether you like Blacres or not, you have to admit we'd be i...

I like reminding my Brissy supporting mate about their heartfelt bid for a desperately needed compo pick last year, and how much it has helped them in 2019. Hey, wait a minute...

Well, they did say some of the changes wouldn't necessarily be popular...so this is a solid start.

Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Sat 24 Aug 2019 11:35am One from left field - Tom Papley. Wants to come back to Victoria; a gun.

All but signed and sealed Hawks, isn't he?

bigcarl wrote: ↑Tue 27 Aug 2019 11:06am Ratten. He’ll get the best out of what he’s got. Good solid bloke and a people person.

Sounds like someone's resume we've read already...bring on Rattcho then?

I don't think they will, and I don't think they have. How much longer will the AFL continue to take a handful of picks off their existing 'successful' franchises (i.e. clubs that can pull 30,000-50,000 members no problem) to prop up a team that continually gets top draft picks and soft draws, and do...

spert wrote: ↑Tue 27 Aug 2019 1:41pm I heard that there could be a much bigger cleanout than anticipated

The only problem with reported big cleanouts, is they need to be followed by big intakes...and I can't see we're in a position to much with our trades and picks, no matter how hard I squint.

Tend to agree with the sentiment on here that more than the coach and playing list needs to change for 2020...so does it matter? Anyone but Brad Scott.

I get the feeling every other club in the league will join you...I really can't see everyone putting up with another year of compromised draft positions, just to prop up a team full of high draft picks.

Anyone see the article on the AFL website about his alarming drop in disposal efficiency this year? LOL. Hopefully he's just having an average year and not just warming up for next season at the Saints. Still better than most of our centre.

Hmmm...better late than never. I did wonder why Rattcho came out and announced he had 'licence to roam' against the Blues, given he is obviously not in the best shape, but hard not to put him in the forward pocket after the previous weeks' performance. After most of the season out, consistency was n...

What happened to Ted? Ted's dead, baby, Ted's dead. :lol: This thread is great :) I’m sure we’ll be seeing Ted again soon, he won’t be able to help himself! #backfromtheted Hearing whispers we will see him on the forum next week, 90-95% chance I'm right .😁 That's appropriate - about the same % as T...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Wed 14 Aug 2019 10:56am

degruch wrote: ↑Wed 14 Aug 2019 10:09am

SaintPav wrote: ↑Wed 14 Aug 2019 12:32am What happened to Ted?

Ted's dead, baby, Ted's dead.

This thread is great

I’m sure we’ll be seeing Ted again soon, he won’t be able to help himself!

#backfromtheted

Hearing whispers we will see him on the forum next week, 90-95% chance I'm right.

SaintPav wrote: ↑Wed 14 Aug 2019 12:32am What happened to Ted?

Ted's dead, baby, Ted's dead.