Fancy trying to play Hunter in Marshall’s role as a fwd/ruck He is probably a nice fellow, and an honest state league crash and bash ruck battler But to get drafted at 28 into an elite system is bizarre To play as a tall forward even more bizarre Why didn’t he just come off the bench and Steele res...

Just as many righties who cant kick on their left I am leftie and kick perfectly well on my right - its just practice Not sure I've seen many righties fluff it as badly as Kent did. Agree it is just practice, for a professional player it should not even be much practice for a basic level of putting...

more chance Kent will be dropped than Butler IMO Kent should be left out. Terrible game can’t remember a positive from him. That and injuries the only reason Butler says As Cornes just said on FC ....Butlers playing like a millionaire and his inability to do the team thing when needed is deplorable...

Isn’t it interesting Players seem to perform well in the HB line Hill, Sinclair, Webster this year Coffield, Paton, Clark last year Yet on the HF line the goings a bit tougher StK careers have ended from that position Acres, Newnes, Weller and now Billings I think when we judge a player, we need to...

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Sun 18 Jul 2021 12:14am Kent got caught at least once because he couldn't use his right foot

Kent’s inability to not even attempt on his right was under12s level laughable.

If we lose to Port and Dunny doesn't play well for 4 quarters he will be right back in the sights of most supporters who don't trust him to sustain this current level of form. I really want him to succeed but it's a trust issue for me, similarly for this whole team. Dunny transcends the fragility o...

Those have obviously ended up being good decisions I don’t think I’m an expert, I’m not employed in the AFL, as you are not. We are just fans with an opinion. I’d like to know any one post where I have claimed expertise?! There’s just a few posters on here who don’t like the way I post- which is fi...

It’s funny McKenzie was apparently - ridiculously - given a contract extension If the experts on SS were in charge He wouldn’t even be on the list! As ridiculous as recruiting Ryder or letting Steele play as an out and out midfielder rather than a tagger? You were against both- how are those calls ...

Pretty simple I was just pointing out a few things about our backline performance under Hamill Even though it has been suggested on here we have rubbish assistants and they need to go - including Hamill Me personally, I don’t believe it makes that much difference. 2 years ago Adam Kingsley needed t...

Definitely overrated Players make coaches either look great or not… How’s the development of Sinclair been under Hamill? How’s the continued performance of Wilkie been? Highmore? Webster 2 years out of the game IMO is one of best defenders in the game atm Hill’s move to HB has transformed him Howar...

Ghost Like wrote: ↑Sat 10 Jul 2021 11:09pm

perfectionist wrote: ↑Sat 10 Jul 2021 11:04pm Luke Darcy is the most moronic commentator of all time.

Only if Matthew Richardson is removed from the voting.

Love Richo even though he is not the best commentator

Maligned assistant coach When we were looking for scapegoats, and we couldn’t bag Ratts It was the assistants fault And Hamill was no good and needed to go!!! Backline coach The backline (in many was no-name) has been the best in the league over the last 6 weeks But your theory is that coaches shou...

I’ll keep up the tone as long as you attempt to shoot down every second post I make. I could say the sky is blue, and you’d say otherwise Bias does effect people’s thinking doesn’t it?? You don’t like it when somebody treats you the way you treat everybody else. You try to shoot down and put down e...

I guess your right Your subjective judgment would be way more accurate Having said that Coaches use data to make informed decisions So I’ll go with what they do Coaches use mor than just data in their decision making process. That’s how they get to the top of their profession. So I’ll stick with wh...

Teflon, where would you play him? Well...,tonight ...no Membrey....I’d have given him a go up forward left Coffield where he knows how to play down back ... I wouldn’t have picked Lonie at all although at least he touched the ball....Butler to busy playing with his hair... Hunter is a clear liabili...

Not really a new low but let's be melodramatic and pretend it is. What will fix it? A healthy list plus three or an over the top list cull? I thought it was a new low when there was no response from any of our players after Hunter got a broken jaw, yeah. I totally agree on that samuraisaint, I said...

Thinks he’s fkn David Dench! Any danger of him ever being on his opponents shoulder, especially when he’s playing deep on the last line. He seriously overrates himself, the fact he runs to take the kick ins when he’s a s*** kick! Young Thilthorpe is a ripper, you see, young key forwards can be matc...

Teflon, where would you play him?

Teflon, where would you play him?

Was going to start a similar post. Confusing and feel for him. Showed most as a backman but drafted as a forward?

Dunstan has his limitations, we know that Both skill and fitness He’s a C Grader with the ability to play the odd very good game Smashes it at VFL level as an inside mid. Just doesn’t have the running power or foot skills at league level. Very good depth player. Saintmatt - not sure if you’ve ever ...

Such a lack of composure coming out of our backline. Hacked kicks when not heaps of pressure and those kick ins in the last were so woefully predictable. I think we lack leadership on the ground. Steele leads by example but can’t be everywhere. Who is our defensive general who takes the heat off. Wh...

Always liked Sinclair. A smart and skillful footballer- not the out and out match winner but the sort of player who can elevate and play at a higher standard as the team improves.

Unsurprising yet awesome news. Will tear games apart (almost did it on the weekend) and I can't wait to see it.

How the hell does Ross keep getting votes??? He’s a depth player at best, and is getting judged in the best players on the ground?! That makes no fkn sense?!?! You really do have a weird obsession with Seb Ross. Why is that? Its not like he is an elite player. Gotta admit I don't always watch games...