The_Dud wrote: ↑Sat 16 Mar 2024 9:56pm

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 16 Mar 2024 9:55pm Sharman should NEVER play again

Piss weak

He’s shown over and over again he’s a forward, what do you expect?

He's a dud - just like Higgins.

We have some skill-less triers.

Moods wrote: ↑Sat 16 Mar 2024 9:01pm Pou’s not ready to play midfield...

He's never going to be ready. Too slow. A total dud of high pick - again.

Our last win at KP was in 1999 with Tim Watson as coach to take us to 3rd on the ladder after Round 10.

I think 16th will be a little on the high side by the end of the year. But we will know more in 5 hours.

I think 4 weeks would have been reasonable. That's how many weeks he would have got under a previous "points" system. But concussion is now viewed more seriously so 7 weeks is now the base for this action. The perversion remains Maynard's outcome - an obvious case of bias. He did everythin...

Family matter now resolved - or should I say - is "in remission". Move on.

The only Premiership team full back captain that I can recall is David Dench. This year will see another one as both teams have fullback captains. Verdun Howell was VC in 1966 but, by then, he was on the half back flank.

If the umpires are broccoli they would be my three favourite vegetables - and very good for the bowels.

He's 5 cm taller.

He played well. His pace in foot races to get to contests was especially noteworthy. But he wasn't the player who cost GWS the game. That was Lachie Ash (no.7). Last week, I can remember thinking that you can't have someone like him on the backline - he gives the ball away with poor disposal or poor...

Who is tipping what? I don't know.

If only we had bought Steven May and not Dougal Howard. Melbourne seemed to be robbed of one goal and possibly two. I couldn't see any bent fingers in the one that was declared touched and Max Gawn hit to ball onto the post but could have been behind the line when he did it. It shows how teams must ...

... Well a precedent has now been set that you can run directly at player front on who is carrying the ball and launch yourself at him or her as he or she disposes the ball without actually effecting the smother and cannon into their head without fear of retribution. ... That would seem to be the c...

... Jimmy is our Stevie Baker without the Jeff Fenech. Steven Baker was an exceptionally skilled player. He could kick either foot, handball both hands, take a contested mark and most importantly, pick up the ball cleanly when it was in front of him. For his size, he was as good as anyone and he wa...

I hope his eye is OK after someone stuck a thumb in it. He had to play with his eye closed for most of the second half. He has had his best year in my opinion - certainly his most consistent. Despite that, I think he can get fitter and stronger. Or should I say, he needs to get fitter and stronger. ...

The black dog is sometimes hard to spot but can have a big bite.

Peanut Farm wrote: ↑Sat 09 Sep 2023 8:34pm Marshall
Steele
Hill

...

agree

Ground dud

On a positive, how good has Sharman been. Surely it’s time to give him a good run next season. Sharman probably our best but we went out with a whimper ... He wasn't in the top ten of the ground and is a dud once the ball hits the ground. He is as slow as wet week. RoMa was BOG by a mile.

Max King needs to be off loaded whilst he still has AFL currency. Dropped marks are one thing, but you can't have a player who just stands there and watches his opponent run down the ground. If he's not fit - get him off. Been held in contests. Should have had 4 frees. One free, but that doesn't st...

meher baba wrote: ↑Sat 09 Sep 2023 4:58pm

Bruce G McAbee wrote: ↑Sat 09 Sep 2023 4:57pm Where's the match thread?

Well, this will do, won't it? I imagine most posters are at the ground.

No, just edit the thread name to The Match Thread.

Pathetic effort with his last shot. Once the ball hits the ground, he's useless - so he has to mark the ball.

Max King needs to be off loaded whilst he still has AFL currency. Dropped marks are one thing, but you can't have a player who just stands there and watches his opponent run down the ground. If he's not fit - get him off.

Not being an emergency, I hope Anthony wasn't out on the beers last night. Then again, he's only 19, an age where the body is still very forgiving. It seems the AFL have given permission for him to play.

The media debate on this sort of incident continues to alienate me, as does some of the commentary on here. All I can hear is the same old crap that was thrown around when Giascura jumped up and elbowed Kosi in the head back in 2006: after which Kosi was never the same player again. You know what I...