My mate says Jack bought a house in Lorne. Which I think is odd. My mate works for a real estate group and his mate told him he sold a house to Jack last weekend. Lots of second hand info, so don't know. If what you say is true I think Geelong management will only toughen their stance in trade valu...

I think McCartin threads are a good thing..cathartic... Gives us all the opportunity to cry over spilt milk ... not to mention another way to share our outrage towards previous administrators and sink the slipper into our club. Yeah bringem on. Any shrink will tell you it's good to bring it out and...

Brayshaw and DeGoey were in the frame too. The Boyd deal spooked us and the rest is history. The thing that amazes me is that we constantly use high draft picks on talls when we are crying out for mids. Bizarre. Even the decision to pick Billings was odd - a half-forward flanker when we desperately...

Has to be cleared by the AFL and I’m hearing they are not so keen. Don’t get too excited too early.... Yes My wife has atrial fibrillation and while this isn't the same as Robertons condition irregularly heart beats can lead to various issues. They would want to be super sure of his bodies ability ...

Saintmatt wrote: ↑Mon 23 Sep 2019 2:59pm If a guy in his age bracket and with his attributes and experience is not being offered a healthy contract by GCS (who need experienced players in their mid 20's) then that should tell you everything.

Richo might suggest that Melbourne uses him?

According to SEN Dougal Howard has toured St Kilda, Essendon and North. What I have seen of him I have liked. Key defender, not bad by foot and reasonable pace. He also captained port one game this year so has strong leadership qualities. Still only 22. Media I have read indicated North was the lik...

Skeptic, if your mail is correct, then this is THE trade we need to secure over all others. Give the Suns our pick 6 and throw in a player if need be but the club desperately needs to be bold. Securing the King twins could be a true turning point in the club’s fortunes. I’m tired of our club playin...

Geelong WILL NOT give up Constable. We will get a 3rd round pic for Stevens take it or leave it. and our recruitment guys will accept. Ben King at St.Kilda all pie in the sky talk. Boom Boom. Dead right. We will take a round 3 pick and not argue. The Ben King idea is just a good idea without any re...

With Bruce on way out ..I think the best outcome is: * Bruce to Bulldogs for pick 14, maybe a 3rd rounder or player * Pick 14 to Fremantle for Hill * Pick 5 to Gold Coast for Ben King Bruce going leaves a significant gap, but if we bring in Ben King earlier it’s win:win and our forward line albeit ...

Is Pundit JR, AKA Ted, AKA Parkey? Who are these people? And no they are not. E.g. I don't agree with Pundits view on Zac Jones. He would be good for us. He played in a GF against the Dogs as a 21 year old. Has tons of pace and ability and hardness. Along with Hill on another wing they could both b...

I thought Alex Keath was off to the Dullbogs with Josh Bruce? There was a point early on when I thought that if Carlisle went - Keath was a must. Then with Carlisle staying I thought he'd be a nice to have. But now that Carlisle stays and Robbo is back in the mix - I think Keath's worth to us is mo...

Vazelos wrote: ↑Tue 01 Oct 2019 8:52pm Developments this afternoon about Chris Masten joining St Kilda as an unrestricted free agent. Lions interest understood to have cooled.

I know plenty of Eagles supporters over her in the West that are happen that Masten is no longer with them. He looks better tan he is in a good team. No.

I'm not torn over this. Bruce always found it pretty hard to get seperation on his opponent and have away his fare share of frees trying to pluck a mark. He was a good forward, but not a great one. Yeah our delivery wasn't the greatest. But having someone with presence who can demand the ball in th...

what else can we really say sk ? he certainly played hard for us whilst he was here ... and he deserves our gratitude for that he was a bit of a fave of mine ... maybe thats why it stings a bit Yes but he was still contracted, so the lure of more $$ is what has made him want to go. That's what make...

So Constance, a Seconds player at Geelong, is yet another messiah for St. Kilda No doubt those preaching “messiah” are from Scomo’s Bible bashing demographic, waving their hands around and yelling for a miracle Life does not work like that Constable might be alright. I wouldn't provide too much for...

kosifantutti wrote: ↑Mon 02 Sep 2019 9:28pm

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Mon 02 Sep 2019 8:35pm Get him in. He killed us in Adelaide.

But we might not kick it to him if he’s wearing a Saints jumper.

The trade for Hill is red hot going to happen. I think Pick 5 is ok given we are getting an AA wingman at 26. Unless we split pick 5 with 11 and 13 with GWS and give 11 to Freo for Hill. Interesting times. Splitting the pick 5 for increased trade dips is great from the Saints but the Dockers will c...

I see the logic there. We take a guy who may be as good, or better, than Grundie in the ruck and instead try and turn into being a CHF a role that I doubt he will be as good in. (Did you not see his contested ball work in the ruck contests this year?) And we make do with for our No 1 Ruck a guy pas...

Ryder is not an answer. I am hoping that the recruiting department will surprise and pull some decent rabbits out of the hat. Very few of the players being linked to the Saints so far are going to take us forward. It's early days and hopefully they can keep targets under wraps but not liking what i...

I actually rate Newnes and like him tbh. Sometimes I get pissed off at Gresh, lots of figjam and sometimes tries to do too much, but don't know if others see it that way. Meh. Gresham is frustrating at times based on his decision making. For instance his preference to kick across the body when with...

My summary is that Bruce is a required player But I am of the same view re Carlisle and Acres so what would I know? Plus I think we have just too many “small forwards” and “small defenders” who are not up to the standard Plus that we continue to play too many “inside mids” impacting on our demograp...

Difference between bruce and carlisle We are looking at what we could get for carlisle Other club are asking what we want for bruce Tell the rivals to get a three way trade deal done with Freo to enable Bruce elsewhere Hill to Saints with monetary and contractual revision and the third party to arr...

What have I missed? Since when does he want to leave? Since when would you offload a 4 x B&F winner who provides the pace and ball winning ability that we need so badly? Geez, Barry, what rock have you been hiding under? Cats want him and we still want him, simple as that. Don't get your nicker...

Can't see him forcing his way back, even if he does want to this season. Perhaps now we clearly have a good team forming he won't feel so much stress next year. I can only guess what it must have been like roving to Billy and Tom these last few years and being targeted every game. Also he would be ...

He is finally match ready. Of course, let's just blame Alan Richardson still. FMD. 🙄 Nuh, its based on a rose coloured view by our previous Pres on team list strength and the undoubted faith in the past recruitment teams. Only recently they have addressed key things like covering injured players. I...