I said last week he has to be traded out whilst he has currency.
Dal Santo said the same this week.
Match winner- no
Consistent 4 quarter player- no
Influential player in key moments- no
Big Match player- no
Leader- no
Will play 200 games best to go now he isn’t what we need.

Same old Dunstan No class poor disposals and can’t run out games. Will be delisted end of year amongst another 8+. Got 100 games in seasons of Mediocrity. The one season we played finals he didn’t play, says it all. Simply not true. What part isn’t true? Last part is a fact the rest is an opinion. ...

Same old Dunstan
No class poor disposals and can’t run out games.
Will be delisted end of year amongst another 8+.
Got 100 games in seasons of Mediocrity.
The one season we played finals he didn’t play, says it all.

It’s funny... I had this gripe in the latter part of the Richo regimen. Unfortunately it extends to a large portion of the supporter base too. Don’t criticise Richo McCartin must be persevered with Hannebery and Kent were great trades Newnes is a future captain Joyce “I can’t spoil from behind” is ...

Great OP, Vazelos ( yes, I did read it...), and I agree with cwrcyn's assessment of the list. I think the 2024 timeline is unrealistic as we are essentially rebuilding (again) and are behind others like NM and even the Hawks, particularly given our position going into this draft and the lack of tra...

How come Webster gets a pass. Just as undisciplined as Long at times but just doesn't look as manic. Kicking is no better than Higgins in terms of quality. And Butler, how is he still picked - because we have no reinforcements. Billings and Ross are so far above those two but is the suggestion get ...

Agree with several points Vaz (although stopped reading half way) Paton a huge underrated loss. ...excellent speed , skills and discipline and courage. Marshall and Jones make this side look much better Gresh also, losing both Jones and Gresh hurts us very badly If we kick straight vs Cats and Swan...

Agree with several points Vaz (although stopped reading half way) I didn't read any of it but it was really well spaced! Apologies for the manifesto and too much for some people’s attention span... Next time I’ll shorten it. Hope one day I can become a Saintsational legend . You forgot a meme or an...

Let's have a look at what the holes are. Who are the players who are of the right standard? The following players will not take us where we want to go Carlisle (finished) Hannebery (finished) Geary (finished at year's end) Mckenzie (poor skills) Dunstan (poor skills) Frawley (finished) Mckernan (fi...

Agree with several points Vaz (although stopped reading half way) I didn't read any of it but it was really well spaced! Apologies for the manifesto and too much for some people’s attention span... Next time I’ll shorten it. Hope one day I can become a Saintsational legend . I too read it all great...

My apologies Frawley out as well I forgot to list him as a delist.

Enrico_Misso wrote: ↑Sun 06 Jun 2021 12:29am

Banger9798 wrote: ↑Sun 06 Jun 2021 12:08am Agree with several points Vaz (although stopped reading half way)

I didn't read any of it but it was really well spaced!

Apologies for the manifesto and too much for some people’s attention span...
Next time I’ll shorten it.
Hope one day I can become a Saintsational legend .

The Recruit wrote: ↑Sat 05 Jun 2021 10:42pm Lag

Most of us took the 1110 point loss as finals dashed.

No Nostradamus in that just official today.
Riewoldt and Steele said we would still make finals before today’s game so go figure.

Season done and the lofted expectations culminating from 2020 now well and truly behind us. I have sat back posted very little and watched the roller coaster rides of emotions week to week from people on this forum and on social media. “ Sack the Coach”.... “ We are a top 4 team”... “ Get rid of the...

I think you have to ask the question why did we entice 2 players out of retirement and 2 others that were delisted. What does that say about the current list. To me that smells of list mismanagement. Well it was a top up wasn’t it. Recruit some ready made to cover a Carlisle or a Ryder to prevent w...

The curse of the CHB position continues at the Saints.... We have never been blessed in this position over the last 40 years and when we do find a ripper in Matt Maguire he Breaks his leg never to be the same again... Now Big Jake who I recall when we signed him I was very excited as a top line defe...

Play them both they are our future both good prospects.

I’ve had coffee a couple of times with Chris Pelchen and he told me the following. Pelchen remember was moved on before the draft but shortly before he left the decision was to take Petracca. When it was announced on Radio they had taken Mc Cartin, Pelchen moved to the side of the road and called El...

Trading a two times best and fairest winner for a pig in a poke? Thanks, but no thanks. He won the B&F in our poorer years. The same player who goes missing everytime the heat is on and still cant hit a target going forward. Would much rather off load him while he still has some value, take a s...

What I hate more about this year, is not us losing. It is Melbourne having such a successful start to the season with Petracca starring. I hope Elshaugh rots in hell with his Paddy love, he has cobbled us to years of watching Petracca tear oppositions apart. Has to be the worst recruiting call of a...

I always thought that his disposal was the thing that made him unplayable McKenzie in term of endeavour, fitness and work rate has been close to elite from the start. He had his pants pulled down a few times by faster opponents but for developing players that happens and they learn from it He was a...

I seem to recall a lot of games where Hind went missing and provided zero impact. You do realise Hind was being played out of position at St Kilda he is not a small forward he is a half back...A quality player!!! Seeing Mc Kenzie playing for us and Hind for the Injectors was icing on the cake on Sa...

Fantastic positive post i am sure any leader would like to read that as a settling stabilising statement to everyone connected to the club. It is just that the loss was so bad, the performance so insipid that it shook us and the football club to the core and made the experts severely doubt our crede...

An incredible difficult piece to read mirrors the feeling I had reading Robbie Muirs article we have had 2 high profile articles in 6 months. I don’t believe any club was well equipped to deal with such things back then... football clubs treated their players like pieces of meat... commodities to be...

Yes I rate Battle as well just hasn't had a settled position.