Carlisle is better than hunter and mckernan in any position on the field including ruck.

No matter how fast the game.

It is concerning that there are members of the football department that do not realise that

Ross was very good against the kangaroos especially early . As well, he finished 2020 strongly. Cant see him missing the 22.

The ump was too busy watching the guy on the mark rather calling play on when the guy with the ball moved sideways off his line ...... and of course the player on the mark moving 2 steps sideways did not effect the play at all given the player with the ball was 8m back Just an absolute horrific rul...

No he wont just be paid out. He cannot fulfill his contract. His payment would a negotiated amount at best. Does anyone know the rule about this? If he retires due to a health issue, will he get paid out in full? In part? negotiate a new role at the club? If he retires for health issues, will his 2...

Out Jonathan Marsh In Mason Wood Slight upgrade but purely a ready made depth option I suspect. If Ryder goes down and Marshall plays full time ruck, Wood may come into the mix as a replacement forward depending on how King , Membrey & Battle are travelling Yes.. was thinking the same... Both h...

According to ace's list we have 2 x primary list spots, 3 x Rookie A spots and 1 Rookie B spot available. We do have 2 primary list places but it is only by not filling those that we have 3 rookie A spots free. So we can add 3 primary/rookie A players of whom only 2 can be primary. Then we can fill...

the Everitt trade was not so bad.. got pick 6 and 22. Using 6 on Brooks was aweful and a disaster. Port used 6 on Salopek and then Mackie went at 7. Considering how poor our bottom couple of players were, if we get either of them in our 2009/2010 team and we win at least one flag. Salopek or Mackie ...

You would think both will be offered new contracts on less money than their current deals but both seem committed to the saints... Billings was good in 2019 but not great in the latter part of 2020.. Ross started 2020 slow but actually finished well. Let's see how they go in 2021..doubt the club wil...

The NAB league will become u19 next year. A bunch of kids will play who have been unsighted for a year and who can be taken midseason. Who knows how many will come out and be good? Presumably they can also play some VFL games if they are already in that age range, so they can be assessed further. Th...

cwrcyn wrote: ↑Mon 16 Nov 2020 7:57pm Of course, Demetriou has been embarrassed by a recent investigation intoCrown Casino money laundering,where he was exposed for lying to the investigation.....surprise, surprise

Demetriou also involved in an education scam company. The guy is as dodgy as they come and should be in prison IMHO.

Presumably we can move a couple players to the rookie list?

We should use at least two draft picks. Pick in the 60s may actually m over up quite a bit with many earlier picks used as points for academy players.

Huge Free Kick against numbers vs Freee Kick for.

That is bad and needs to be addressed. There is clearly an issue, it is year after year.

Will get a pick I the 50s of say

Don't understand the fuss. There was nan open market for crouch. We paid the most. That salary we offered was within the range of a band 3 pick. A band 3 pick is the second round which is the range of picks 19-38, but slides after other comp to 23-42. So the open market valued Crouch at pick 23-41. ...

Looks very much like the Ryder deal. Former AA who looks cooked at present club but age wise could have two years left in him.

Would not think our offer to Hind would be large.. If bombers offered him more money and an extra year.. Such as two years assuming we are offering one... I don't think we will match them. Decent depth player but that will be weighed against salary cap and future list management. Also may see more o...

Very strange to not have Steele as A grade. Must be stuck in 2019.

third year players who are not best 22 do not cost much. Even fringe players in a premiership team.
Getting him at the right moment IMO. Clearly will cost more than Butler but cant see us paying too much.
Classic St. Kilda future 2nd perhaps?

If he has agreed to come, there is no need for either side to "announce" it prior to the trade period.
Maybe saints are just better at keeping secrets than some other teams?

We must have a ruck lined up. We certainly will not go into next season with just Ryder and Marshall and I doubt we would delist Abbott until we were sure of a replacement, ie. if we did not have someone, we surely would have at least waited until after trade period to get someone before we delist him

matched them in many ways .. they were kicking them out of their asses early, we were missing easy ones.. things fell their way including a bad call on the goal to Sinclair which was not touched, early injuries to Paton and Battle, the huge loss of Ryder and Carlisle in particular in the context of ...

For the forced changes:

Webster for Long... would not lose anything there at all if Webster were at his best but it has been some time
Battle for Ryder... Marshall to ruck... sweating on Battles fitness
Roberton or Austin for Carlisle--- I really have no idea which one.

Hopefully Battle in for Paddy

The fade out in the last quarter has proven costly.. I recon if we maintained our lead, Hannas and Paddy would have been on the bench during the final minutes rather than Paddy being out on the ground

was it high?

looked shoulder to shoulder to me

The Dogs were playing for frees. They were pulling the defenders arms down when they Saint defenders were spoiling drawing the too high free. It worked 3 times. They also pin the arm of the tackler drawing the holding the man. They sucked umps in time after time. The umps need to be better...someth...