Really disappointing ..again!

I just wish he would start just doing some simple things well, and stop trying to do the incredible things every time

I thought Webster was superb

And if you didn’t put him in your votes please reconsider

Kept Charlie completely ineffectual

Forget the last goal to him (not sure Jimmy was even on the ground)

So my votes

5 Jimmy
4 Battle
3 Sinclair
2 NWM
1 Steele

How I wanted us to win and spoil the Cotchin party, was looking forward to this game all week Oh well! Yes there were some problems, but I think there were some great positives We played a team missing 3 of their best 18 (Lynch, Hopper and Pickett) who were playing for a club legend and apart from t...

SydneySainter wrote: ↑Sat 17 Jun 2023 11:35pm I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, St Kilda are just a sh**ty football club.

Why bother then?

Simply a disgraceful decision Smashed front on in a marking contest it is a free all day every day Exactly what I was going to post and yet horseface was whinging about our free kicks in his ungracious presser TY and some here have missed the point, yes there are 50/50 decisions that can go either ...

Otiman wrote: ↑Thu 08 Jun 2023 11:55pm`Which one?

The one when he was injured

Simply a disgraceful decision

Smashed front on in a marking contest it is a free all day every day

My understanding is that a few Saints had Sicily as captain in their fantasy team

That is a disgraceful non free for the push in the back to Mathias.

Alan Killigrew (the hot gospeller) played for St K and then coached St K and later NM

older saint wrote: ↑Thu 25 May 2023 10:50am and pushing the Woke aspect of the AFL agenda.

Love to know what your definition of woke is because I have heard some pretty stupid definitions from Trump supporters

Anyway if you don’t support the indigenous round, or gay pride games or AFLW just have the guts to say it and why

Wow just goes to show that there is no accounting for “insert your own word” Just above me is one poster claiming that Robbo keeps going after Essendon and then another saying all he does is protect Hird et al How about you agreeing that both of you are wrong Then we get the standard “Robbo is alway...

I didn't realise SODs dad played for the Saints. I got the impression that O'Donnell didn't care much for the Saints. Maybe he does given his old man SOD is a Saint through and through and had all the makings of an outstanding player for the Saints. Unfortunately he had all the makings of a champio...

FYI
This year (in AFL total)
19th for disposal
15th for contested possessions
17th for tackles
24th for total clearances

Above average (for the AFL) in nearly all key indices for midfields (check it out on the AFL website)

I love how he plays and we need him in the team

FQF

Thought he was average until the last qtr. Made Hogan look like the hogan when he was at Melb. Sure it wont happen but temptation should exist to replace him with Highmore - Kosi and Lewis are not monsters we are up against this week. Hopefully last qtr was the turning point. Are you kidding Howard...

Brad Johnson today “Crouch is one of the most underrated top end midfielders”

his game today not stellar, but still most pressure acts and second most tackles

He will not be dropped

I thought after half time we saw the old Howard

He imposed himself physically and that allowed Wilkie a better opportunity to intercept and play his game

Yes he mucked up a handball near the end and Cadman kicked an assy goal on him but generally

I thought his second half was good

FQF

I don’t really care about the result now

Just hope Mitchito is going to be ok

I’m not sure if he was conscious going off the ground

I don’t really care about the result now

Just hope Mitchito is going to be ok

I’m not sure if he was conscious going off the ground

Frankly I am staggered and a little angry that at least 1 of Marcus or Jack B could not get a look in No doubt Matthias is going to be a jet, but he needed a rest 3 weeks ago, surely a road trip was the perfect time My fear is that Jack B not getting a game means his time at the Saints is done I hop...

Crouch - would have least meters gained of all AFL mids He is not in the side for metres gained (which actually is at 301 per game, rated average on the AFL site) He is in the side for his clearance work which is elite on year to date averages His year stacks up really well against Lachie Neale (go...

Out

Membrey

Fitness ?s on
Steele and Roma

Form
Sharman (just not hard enough)
Paton (showed up today)

In
Marcus
Billings (if he doesn’t get picked then surely he is not a Saint next year)
Max (who knows)
Webster (obviously)

Teflon wrote: ↑Sun 14 May 2023 4:07pm Is Dougald Howard the master at turning a certain easy clearance into a calamitous **** up and opposition scoring opportunity??

Correct, had 3 running inside him but turned to the outside

5 Marshall
4 Sinclair
3 Ross
2 Clark
1 Owens

JHF deserves to be booed IMO. Sorry, but I find the idea that these strong, muscly, macho young men are "homesick" to be quite ridiculous. And I don't think the booing had any effect on his performance. You might not have noticed, but he is rather good. So if Ben King said he was homesick...