whats the Pies record against Crows like?

surely they now have th incentive of playing for a top 4 spot?????

geez solar ....Im prayin ure right....

GO PIES!

GO EAGLES...

Just to be sure,...

so.....assuming we win.......

SHOULD Collingwood/West Coast win....we are in? yeah?

Geelong 21 18 3 0 2411 1540 72 156.5 2 West Coast 21 14 7 0 2030 1811 56 112.1 4 Hawthorn 21 13 8 0 1992 1732 52 115.0 3 Port Adel 21 13 8 0 2175 1967 52 110.5 5 Kangaroos 21 13 8 0 2005 1886 52 106.3 6 Collingwood 21 13 8 0 1950 1907 52 102.2 7 Sydney 21 11 9 1 1899 1643 46 115.5 10 Adelaide 21 11...

I like this sort of discussion cause it focuses on where we are going BUT.......you end up reading through peoples lists and realise if we took that path we'd have 15 players left... Facts are we aint gonna get 4 Judds and a partridge in a pear tree at draft time....so I spose while its tempting aft...

hmm still need a bit to go our way.

Are Eagles next week effectively playing for a home final????

u have any good news?

yep thats how I see it....although I heasr Rocca may be in trouble for an indiscriminate smack in the mouth to Goodes....

The reality is that who else could have played on Cousins? No one at St Kilda is fit enough to keep up with him. That is the sad reality. Blake is our fittest player, and he was stuffed. Blake is fit...but he also didnt have the burst speed off the mark to stay with Cousins...or give him 5 meters h...

Yeah I feel the same way..........and should the Pies lose tonight...they simply HAVE to beat Adelaide next week...

Im leaning more towards...lets just knock Brisbane out of the equation soon as...

Obviously involves beating Richmond but looking at the different senerios I believe we should barrack for Adelaide to -night and hope like Hell that Collingwood beat them at Telstra next week...wouldn't be confident that Geelong will have an incentive to beat Brisbane at the Gabba in the last round...

does it matter? I can see Collingwood rolling Adelaide - Geelong in Brsibane...hmm..the Lions are a different side..and with Browne and their backs to the wall..(and would Geelong maybe give the likes of a sorfe Bartel the extra week off before finals?????...be temtping...) Collingwood have more to ...

Lorsi analysis is dribble and shows all the signs of someone who watched the game on TV.......you just dont see enough Loris Im afraid... 2nd half Blake simply didnt - for ALL his vaunted engine - have capacity to go with Cousins...he was stuffed and it showed when he started to allow Cousins 5/10 m...

Sorry Barks - midfield match ups in the 3rd didnt cost us the game - players who by foot could not hit the side of a barn ALL over the ground cost us. We had plenty of chances going fwd in the 3rd and stuffed it with pathetic skill errors and dumb decision making. I agree I wouldve moved (with hinds...

Our recruiting at St Kilda has been pretty average I think. To me it appears that we have been picking players for a hard, contested, old Brisbane of 2003 style game. Winning the contested ball being all important. The theory being it doesn't matter how fast the opposition is if they don't have the...

I do like him and for me he is a goer, but my problem is that he does stand up and no one sees him... I feel he is just a bit too small and still needs to gain those extra kilos IMO Agree. Nup sorry for mine hes to small, slow AND has absolutely no penetration in his kicking. Ask yourself - Does St...

Dan Warna wrote:
poor disposal is poor discipline.

your clucthing at straws.

poor disposal = poor disposals and a basic lack of skill.

Fact is that the 50m penalty was there! Stupid play by Vossy then. Absolutely no need to drag the player to the ground. Gifted them a goal. Not that it would have mattered...we have to be THE worst side I've seen at killing the ball on the last line of defence. WCE got too many goals tonight becaus...

No we want him sacked because he's more supportive of the AFL than he is his players and club. Eddie Maguire was horrified when they played a grab of his speech. Something along the lines of "anyone would think he agreed with the decision to suspend him". Of course Rod would defend his in...

bit nervous bout this...

good enough talent not good enough between the ears. IMO we choked under pressure and made mistakes. we have enough talent. getting more players or different players wont help unless we can maintain discipline. we played exciting footy for 1/2 a game, and let ourselves down but muffing the ball. ad...

I agree with much of what you wrote that's most unlike you. sense has a way of bringing that out in me...and I note a hint of you finally coming to some realisation in your opening post that we have some LIST work to do finally...rather than it all being "we are now sydney game plan...the skys...

SORRY GUYS THREAD LOCKED DUE TO STUPIDITY OF BARRY "STINGER" DAWSON. \END RANT....CLOSEFILE. f-wit.......... you naughty little monkey.....re-opening my locked thread like that..... back in ure cage..... oh...btw......Pluggers not "lost" you....you did that all by your lonesome....

In Rod's speech tonight I can't remember the exacts words (I'm more than a little tired) but he strongly defended our representation at the hearing and intimated Baker had incriminated himself under heavy cross examination from the AFL prosecutor or whatever his term is. Also got legal advice from ...

SORRY GUYS THREAD LOCKED DUE TO STUPIDITY OF BARRY "STINGER" DAWSON.
\END RANT....CLOSEFILE.