What a joke Yep when a free a blind man would have seen is missed that costs a prelim it's a complete joke. Cant remember the decision but you could be right it was incorrect as I saw one or tow that I thought were wrong and the also saw the same with Box Hill. There are a few options here. One you...

I only saw the second half and he was ordinary. Anyway the fate of most if not all would have been decided before yesterday.

The crowd was crap. Maybe up against a league final? Probably also due to playing at Mike Fitzpatrick Oval. Has the game been played at a proper ground like the SCG there would've been 5K more easily I reckon. The Eastern suburbs lot in Sydney don't like going out West which is fair enough. Now bac...

saintspremiers wrote:

plugger66 wrote:

saintspremiers wrote:No team has come from 8th to make a prelim.

Let's all hope they beat those salary cap lovechilds. The Buddy Boys look fairly rooted.

Wrong forum and boring. Go swannies.

Why am I not surprised?

You probably love everything Sydney stands for

No but I do laugh at you.

God help the childre

saintspremiers wrote:No team has come from 8th to make a prelim.

Let's all hope they beat those salary cap lovechilds. The Buddy Boys look fairly rooted.

Wrong forum and boring. Go swannies.

Yet another thread turning to s*** due to the useful suspects. Dont you all realise you cannot be bias,passionate about the club and don't even dare to speculate or dream about players wanting to join the club or nominate us. Please only deal in facts so the miserable sacks of s*** don't get upset....

What a joke

Weird post. Bm 2 posting lately. I like bm one. And don't tell me what to do. I have a daughter to do that

No one back then said we got unders. But stick to your fantasy. Hilarious. I know plenty of supporters who thought we got unders - given he was a first round draft pick and showed good potential as a forward - and it most definitely now has been justified that we got shafted - hilarious indeed Funn...

I want to know when all these guys announce that they want to play for the Saints Don't you know how it works. If we mention a player on here or from BF it suddenly becomes fact they want to come to us. I think Kelly is a case in point. Not once have I heard these trading experts say he want to com...

Lol give it up P66. Devil head has shown you up receive Cripps.Just admit you are dead wrong on OOC. If you want to believe that then go ahead. Funny that you never seemed to say OOC players didnt go at true value previously. How did we receive unders on Cripps when devilhead said only one club was...

magnifisaint wrote:Ok what about Carlisle. Will he have to serve his 2 year suspension before he plays with us?

Whats this 2 year suspension stuff?

Looking back through the Cripps trade thread there a quite a few posters that thought we got shafted and quite a few were happy we got anything because he could have walked for nothing - as he was OCC - there were some that thought we did well cause they thought he would amount to nothing (well and...

No one back then said we got unders. But stick to your fantasy. Hilarious. I know plenty of supporters who thought we got unders - given he was a first round draft pick and showed good potential as a forward - and it most definitely now has been justified that we got shafted - hilarious indeed Funn...

No one back then said we got unders. But stick to your fantasy. Hilarious. I know plenty of supporters who thought we got unders - given he was a first round draft pick and showed good potential as a forward - and it most definitely now has been justified that we got shafted - hilarious indeed Funn...

Cripps was taken at 25 but was traded when OOC for picks in the 40's. Somehow managed to lose so much value but funnily enough is in the WCE 22 who are in a PF. God you talk BS P66 when your argument has been exposed :roll: Last year Essendon wanted Wingard and a top ten pick for a contracted Ryder...

There is no proof that OOC players have better leverage because most players are OOC and most get true value. Its a myth that I haven't really heard before but also goes with that myth of using the PSD. What did we get for an OOC Cripps? Look how he is going and tell me he was only worth two picks ...

matrix wrote:I rest my case.......

You don't have a case to rest. Why don't you come out with another surprising comment like you normally do. Has Harvey retired or something like that? Don't they have papers,TV or radio in your side of the world?

I thought we would make money What's the prob? I also think we should've stayed on at Tassie all those years ago, seeing some of our great players hhave come from there. So if we played in tassie we don't get a cent? Nothing? We get nothing from playing the dome so I don't see a prob with having a ...

Firstly how come OOC players all of a sudden mean you get them cheaper? Most players who leave are OOC and most get what you would say is true value. You don't "automatically get them cheaper", you leverage is better than if they weren't OOC. It also depends on the individual circumstance...

matrix wrote:So?
I think we should play in Tassie

Why? Anylogical reason or did you actually think we would make money. I'm going the second option based on experience from you.

What's sad is you cant string four words together and get them to make sense. So he decided to select quote and answer each point and that's no good??? Of course it isn't :roll: Confirmed. Never been. Sad. You can select quote all you like but if the answers are rubbish they are still rubbish. It w...

matrix wrote:Two games in Tassie then.

Settled.

We don't get any money for that.

I'd have to agree with many on here in that unless we can bend E'dope over to an extent we shouldn't trade for Carlisle. I'd prefer us to keep drafting like we have been. Can anyone point me towards a reference to Josh Kelly moving from GWS ? I'd prefer him to a raw deal from E'dope. He fits our re...