Steven Gartner played in the winning GF for Dingley yesterday and Milney and Ferg play in the GF next week for their Bendigo side.

Its all speculation, pure and simple speculation. I dont rate McCartin as highly as some do and this year has proven that there is still a bit for him to work on. He is lucky we found a few other avenues to goal this year but if McCartin doesnt play at least 10 games next year and kick at least 20 ...

One of the reasons I thought this experiment might fail was a general lack of TV coverage over there. It would be just our luck, having done all the groundwork, that some other club would come over the top in a couple of years and reap the benefits of increased television coverage of the game. We h...

As I was watching the VFL pre-lim yesterday I had a moment of clarity with regards to what has really bothered me about our club over the last few seasons, even going back to when we were genuine flag challengers in the 2008-10 era. Now bear with me because these are hardly ground breaking thoughts...

Wants a trade from the pussy cats. 192cm 93 kilos inside mid. Looks like the kind of player we need. Good hands, nice kick, good pace, very strong in the contest and rarely fumbles or wastes a possession. Also can swing forward or back as a third tall. He is not injured and has improved dramaticall...

Let's go back to one umpire and, while we're at it, how about THEY wear white and the football teams wear THEIR ACTUAL colours and jumpers and not the putrid white bulls*** away jumpers. If 4 field umpires come in that would make 10 officials on the ground during a game, FFS!!! There has been 4 ump...

Let's go back to one umpire and, while we're at it, how about THEY wear white and the football teams wear THEIR ACTUAL colours and jumpers and not the putrid white bulls*** away jumpers. If 4 field umpires come in that would make 10 officials on the ground during a game, FFS!!! There has been 4 ump...

Scollop wrote:When posters constantly quote everyone it makes the friend/foe function somewhat useless.

If the technical wizards can please also devise a function that blocks posters quoting your individual foes we can truly have a choice of who we want blocked

Agree

Let's go back to one umpire and, while we're at it, how about THEY wear white and the football teams wear THEIR ACTUAL colours and jumpers and not the putrid white bulls*** away jumpers. If 4 field umpires come in that would make 10 officials on the ground during a game, FFS!!! There has been 4 ump...

Let's go back to one umpire and, while we're at it, how about THEY wear white and the football teams wear THEIR ACTUAL colours and jumpers and not the putrid white bulls*** away jumpers. If 4 field umpires come in that would make 10 officials on the ground during a game, FFS!!! There has been 4 ump...

Age please or at least make sense and actually reply to what I said

Markworth was absolutely dreadful, played like a person who had been told he was not required next year. A real shame for the kid Oh well. Hopefully Eli and a few others go also. We need to delist around 6 senior listed players especially if we trade in 2 players. Use and abuse. I hope none go back...

CURLY wrote:Wouldn't of thought.

What part isn't true. Now this will be interesting. Anyway its obvious that you are just unlucky in the sides you follow. I must be lucky with my local side.

Siposs has had 5 years to develop, not sure another year will see much improvement. I think he's more suited to VFL Agree. We should try and keep him at Sandy next year then he can be a Saint again in our VFL reserves side in 2017 Why? Wouldn't it be better that we have different players? Because o...

Markworth was absolutely dreadful, played like a person who had been told he was not required next year. A real shame for the kid Oh well. Hopefully Eli and a few others go also. We need to delist around 6 senior listed players especially if we trade in 2 players. Use and abuse. I hope none go back...

I would certainly hope not. Cannot see one single benefit in getting him.

kosifantutti wrote:

plugger66 wrote:

saintspremiers wrote:Can someone please stop me from thinking Meatballs is another Joey.

They play a similar style and like Joey Meatballs is a slow developer but could be in the cusp

Who?

Joey is Leigh Montagna.

Thanks. Would never have known. Is meatballs a food or a player?

BS plug...Australia (cricket) over the last 20 years have had the rub of the green. Remember Warne, intimidated the umps and was rewarded most of the time. St Kilda on the other hand consistantly lose out on the rub of the green / 50 50s I was talking about his local cricket. Don't you think its st...

The crowd was crap. Maybe up against a league final? Probably also due to playing at Mike Fitzpatrick Oval. Has the game been played at a proper ground like the SCG there would've been 5K more easily I reckon. The Eastern suburbs lot in Sydney don't like going out West which is fair enough. Now bac...

So who are we actually in with a serious chance of getting? Not just name dropping. Aish is either staying in Brissie or going to the PIes. Forget about him. If Treloar goes to PIes - I think Aish stays in Brissie. Freeman I want - but is his Manager just using us as leverage to get a better deal a...

Siposs has had 5 years to develop, not sure another year will see much improvement. I think he's more suited to VFL Agree. We should try and keep him at Sandy next year then he can be a Saint again in our VFL reserves side in 2017 Why? Wouldn't it be better that we have different players? Because o...

saintspremiers wrote:Can someone please stop me from thinking Meatballs is another Joey.

They play a similar style and like Joey Meatballs is a slow developer but could be in the cusp

Who?

saintspremiers wrote:

magnifisaint wrote:Siposs has had 5 years to develop, not sure another year will see much improvement. I think he's more suited to VFL

Agree. We should try and keep him at Sandy next year then he can be a Saint again in our VFL reserves side in 2017

Why? Wouldn't it be better that we have different players?

BS plug...Australia (cricket) over the last 20 years have had the rub of the green. Remember Warne, intimidated the umps and was rewarded most of the time. St Kilda on the other hand consistantly lose out on the rub of the green / 50 50s I was talking about his local cricket. Don't you think its st...

I'll stick my next out and say... This thread is no longer about the subject matter... It's about the same posters who are changing the OP to " it's all about me" ... Seriously , this forum has been dragged to the mire for over two years, we've been dragged from pillar to post. These days...