hahahahahahahahahaha

Not good enough??????. Scoreboard doubters

Koby is such a good pick up. Perfect fit

hahahahaha post. Bruce you muppet

I say wait until the end of the year and see what is available. I would take the two draft picks if it s a bumber year. As it is unlikely either us or hawks will come last we wont have to #1 draft tag hanging over us like with Paddy. Take the two young guns and most likely get a gun outside mid and ...

We will get pants next weekend by the cats and it won't necessarily be a bad thing. I don't know what it will take for Richo to get all the guys to kick 50 goals a training session before leaving. Today was woeful, it really was and it isn't one person it is everyone which makes me call in question ...

saintspremiers wrote:Long sounds better than Parfit and is also part aboriginal

what does part aboriginal have to do with anything? A player is either good or bad, tough or weak, regardless of skin colour.

way to early to think about as we don't have a clue what picks we will get i.e picks 11 and 12 are a lot different to picks 8 and 6. I would be happy with getting 2 top ten players to be honest especially as all signs to this year being a great year. Obviously we want players ready out of the box. L...

From memory at the time we picked Paddy most pundits were claiming him as the #1 pick. A genuine forward with skills and a replacement for Roo. Not a new Roo but a forward for when he retires. I can't remember if we had Josh Bruce then and don't forget we got him as a back, not a forward so we got ...

From memory at the time we picked Paddy most pundits were claiming him as the #1 pick. A genuine forward with skills and a replacement for Roo. Not a new Roo but a forward for when he retires. I can't remember if we had Josh Bruce then and don't forget we got him as a back, not a forward so we got l...

Agree Brown was great tonight. Did his job and did it well. Like everyone else knows it was our terrible kicking again that let us down again. Richo get the boys in front of goals this week and practice kicking goals. We could have, no, should have won tonight and won easily

Perth doesnt get the show till later, 3 hours behind is the "news" from Purple? Should have said spoiler, sorry. If you watch you will see it pretty early when Damien Barrett comes on. Doesn't say a lot just he is seriously thinking of pulling up stumps. Dempster has been my favourite pla...

Just saw on the Footy show that Dempster is weighing up playing again. Watch this space

We were not expecting to win this game so not that important. We are honestly going to be on the end a massive hiding simply because west coast is better. A lot better, Josh Kennedy is a gun that will kick a tonne unless Carlisle gets rid of the ring rust in a hurry. Mitchell has found a new gear a...

It sounds defeatist but I don't think it is going to make a lot of difference who we play regarding the results. West coast in Perth will be a bridge too far. Players can have a bad week so I am all for second chances except for Armo, Ross & Dunstan. One of them has to go because they are too si...

We were not expecting to win this game so not that important. We are honestly going to be on the end a massive hiding simply because west coast is better. A lot better, Josh Kennedy is a gun that will kick a tonne unless Carlisle gets rid of the ring rust in a hurry. Mitchell has found a new gear an...

For me the decision to not play Demspter shocked me more than anything else. No Fish or Joey in the team so who is our most experienced back that we need up the back to settle the nerves and enforce the structure when the tide turned? Dempster by a mile. I was at the game and lost count how many tim...

No Dempster is harsh as he has done nothing wrong. Acres in understandable as he hasn't excelled in the JLT. More problems will occur next week when Joey is back. Nice problems to have for a change

If Nathan is a bust, can we merge it with a Tommy Walsh thread please? I have written him off which is a shame. He hasn't played much at VFL level and was sub par in his development league games. He has trouble finding the ball and from what I have read is scared to sprint for obvious reasons. We w...

Forget about Freeman for this season otherwise you will be continually disappointed. If he gets fit and comes back in the tail end it will be a nice surprise but its not just his running that is the problem now. He hasn't actually played a lot of footy so he will have to learn the game again.

You can't base the upcoming season on one performance but last night wasn't good. * I expected better skills and more accurate disposals. There was less handballing behind a running player which meant for quicker ball movement which was awesome but a few times we ran all the way up to the goals but ...

Goddard He's a mile off... and that was pre injury Couldn't agree more. He played one game only and was getting absolutely smashed before the injury and his VFL form was average at best. He has potential as all players do but he has to prove he can play at VFL level first. I doubt we will see him i...

I watched the game and to be honest the hard hits and huge tackles were missing so most players seemed to play better than usual knowing that they weren't going to get hit hard. a few quick points Hickey didn't have a great game but he was still good especially around the ground. Billings looked goo...

great get for 39. Genuine forward and most phantom drafts had him in the 20-30 range. Happy with this

skeptic wrote:Hmm... a lot of the phantom drafts suggest he was a mid 50s range player

I am a little confused by this pick. Some have him as a small defender, others a small forward. Plus he is 70kgs dripping wet

I would have preferred a outside mid with some wheels like Shai Bolton?

Eli has been so hard done by. He is a smaller player so needed to build his body which he has done and now is too good for VFL. We should redraft him over Fish with our third pick IMO. Chips has been great for the club but has no future and his body breaks down too often. Carlisle will be a great fo...