No too big of a risk. Should never of been no#1 pick. Bloody WB paid too much for Boyd which forced our hand.
I wanted the tractor back when we were discussing this at draft time.

How to beat GWS?

Hard relentless football.

If they get it on the outside, they have faster more skilful players than what we do and we will lose.

We can't take a contested mark

We can't do anything right. We have stopped and looks like a 5+ goal defeat coming

Best small forward that I have ever seen. Miss him.

The club had a crack at Lycett, Am I on the only one that thinks this shows that the club is pretty clueless about rating ruckman? Lycett simply put is a pretty average ruckman. A long term deal on good money made no sense. I do understand the Saints had to lose Hickey as he was the only player tha...

Best available regardless of position. If its King then so be it. Its not like our other key forwards are setting the world on fire.

Hi risk hi reward. Take pick 4 to the draft and hope both kings go 2 and 3.
Then watch the fireworks from both adelaide and port.
Hope we are getting in both of their ears now.

The afl will always underwrite Stkilda and prop them up. They need us because of the tv rights deal. They also need a vic club to travel to all the interstate clubs every year. They also know that we wont bite the hand that feeds them so we just cop it. As a business we will always be the minnow clu...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Thu 04 Oct 2018 3:04pm Seems like a massive flog...

If a flog can play good footy anf make us better then why not.

Rankine a must if available at our pick. Will be interesting to see what GC do with Lynch and May leaving. May is the interesting one. If the AFL allow GC to terminate his contract to give them 2,3 & 4 then the AFL is corrupt. Another power house in Collingwood get another very good player for ...

Straight swap for Elliot. He idolized Milne when he was a kid

No one is untouchable for the right price.
Yes we all hope that they are one club players but i would just be happy winning a premiership with 22 rejects from other clubs.

The biggest dud of all lethlean will waste the clubs money....nothing surer. We have failed for over hundred years and now we are the most unsuccessful club in the AFL. We need to do something different. Yeah Lethlean may or may not be the answer but we have to try something. I dont know what it wi...

He is our best but he is getting on. This and next years first round picks would be tempting So if Steven at his age is worth 2 first rounders what would you value Martin or Kelly at? To me atm Steven is contracted so that means 2 first. If out of contract then 1 first. Being contracted means we ha...

Lets say he does request a trade to go back home.
What realistically could they offer us in a fair trade.
For me minimum would be 2 first rounds and one of them around 10.

I hope Richo moves on and Ratts get a chance.
5 years with lil to no improvement and a less than 35% win record is clear enough data to move him on.

Happy that Lycett is gone, but can Preuss take a contested mark. We need this skill more than anything as we only have Carlisle and members this year that can do it.
If he can take contested Mark's then how much for Preuss?

What would a coaching strongly KPI look like.
How is it a measurable?

The interest in Seeders is very real and he is very gettable. Is he a Vic fella or not? If you actually knew enough to state the first sentence with any true conviction, you would know the answer to your own question. Not even relevant actually. Yes vic boy. Have friends that went to school with hi...

The interest in Seeders is very real and he is very gettable. Is he a Vic fella or not? If you actually knew enough to state the first sentence with any true conviction, you would know the answer to your own question. Not even relevant actually. Yes vic boy. Have friends that went to school with hi...

Was the touched goal in the third quarter a touch. At the game it seemed to be a goal but no review Saints fans behind the goals were adamant, but no review I was in the pocket and it looked like it went through. Just a quick review would have been nice. Let the play go on as they kicked out quick ...

Coach lost the players after the carltank game last year due to the Murphy incident. No other coach would have made them apologize.

Was the touched goal in the third quarter a touch. At the game it seemed to be a goal but no review

We need to trade in more players that are very good at contested marking. This is the area we lack the most