B.M wrote: ↑Wed 20 Mar 2024 10:34am Personally - I’d take a great around the ground ruckman - every day of the week!

Remember Tom Hickey (although I thought he was unfairly maligned at times).

You can disagree with me and I hope to be proven wrong.

Come on. Surely I’m the most negative on this forum. All fun and games aside, while we had injuries, the Cats (despite painted opinions) are nothing more than an okay side. They will not play finals this year and at full strength, were a 6 to 7 goal better team. To blow a golden opportunity to final...

Remember Roma & Paddy - so good!

Geelong are not a top 8 team and what’s the average age of their star players - 32? Injuries not withstanding, they were ripe for the picking and we have every chance to finally break this 24 year Cattery jinx and the season with a statement. Now, we face a 5 day turnaround against the Pies, a team ...

shrodes wrote: ↑Sat 16 Mar 2024 10:26pm

The_Dud wrote: ↑Sat 16 Mar 2024 10:19pm Collingwood have started the season poorly, maybe we’ll be a chance?

This worries me, can’t see them dropping three in a row even if we’re in red hot form but grand final hangover seems to be a thing so who knows

We’ll play them back into form. Just watch…

There is nothing honourable about that loss. We are a s**t team.

Let’s enjoy an honourable loss against a team of old men who never moved out of third gear. Very St Kilda to celebrate that.

Enjoy!

Hey, at least we have RTB to add polish.

Typical f**king St Kilda.

Just another season being a sh**ty football club.

Season over.

Hey, at least the team is made up of nice men

Beaten by a team of tired, old men. Enjoy!!!

It was theirs to win and they f**ked it.

Enjoying waiting till 2030 to finally win at the Cattery. Maybe they’ll finally get a win against Port before then…

Seriously, all of this 3rd quarter domination but they’re still leading marks inside 50. WTF???

Getting thumped by a team of 35 year olds. Very St. Kilda.

Getting flogged by a team of 35 year olds. Great team, great dignity, very St Kilda!!!

Bask upon your legacy Finnis. This is the team that “good men” built.

Have we had a mark inside 50 yet?

Seven weeks - next game for Jimmy if picked will be Nth Melb Was always going to be heavy - trial by the media. Could have been better, but could have been worse. Considering that last season we actually copped a bit of a rare reprieve from the appeals panel, plus what a careless and stupid act it ...

I think Lethers so called brilliance was well overstated by some of the fans.

His first master stroke move was bring in a busted Hannebery on a godfather contract.

Then, being party to that debacle of Ratts re-signing, only to be shown the door 6 months later.

His reward, the CEO role???

skeptic wrote: ↑Sun 07 Jan 2024 12:34am

SydneySainter wrote: ↑Sun 07 Jan 2024 12:30am What on earth does GOAT mean?

Greatest of all time

Thank you, it must be my Sydney ignorance.

What on earth does GOAT mean?

Our opinion of his value in the end means nothing. It's the assessment by the current coaching group that determines what happens, and it looks like their assessment is that Billings is not part of their best 23. Now, if Billings was considered of real value, clubs like North Melbourne would have b...

While I’m not hysterical enough to say this is one of worst ever trades, we are the losers in this trade, make no mistake. We traded Billings for chump change and we’re still paying a portion of his salary. He was contracted, we didn’t have to do squat, but we’re now paying him to play for the compe...

Loserville style of trade.

Anyone who labours this as a good outcome is kidding themselves.

We might as well reminisce as to what great trades the Cripps or Hickey deals were, or what a stellar recruit Hannebery was.