Very similar player to Seb Ross. I wouldn't say no but not the type we put too much effort into getting

I hope they play him more in the middle. He's a beast

I think it's a bit concerning that the recruiter (not sure who) said as a side note to taking McCartin was that there wasn't a good KPF in this years draft. What about Shaky (I know that's spelt wrong but that's how its pronounced)? I know we won't be able to get him as he is expected to go number ...

Have you been talking to Phil Kelly?

AFL as in the sport or the organisation? If the former then it sounds like James Aish.

I'd trade this year and next years 2nd rounders for Aish and the Lions 2016 3rd rounder. If both teams have a similar year next year to this year it'll be Aish and about 40 for 25 and 25. With academy players required this year and next it's an appealing trade for the Lions however they would push t...

Simpkin there's a blast from the past

He couldn't manage people. Staff, players, they all hated him.

plugger66 wrote:

#gosaintas wrote:It's certainly surprising they have dropped Schneider...

Not really. He should never have been given a rookie spot IMO. Am allowed to say that or should we do a poll to see if I can say it?

I don't believe the club expected Sinclair and Lonie to be as advanced.

Great read.

I cannot believe Carlisle gets a game after what he said last week If any Saints player came off the ground like that I would want them out for a time (which could be an everlasting time) What did he actually say? I heard it mentioned on the radio the other day but didn't hear what was said.... &qu...

gringo wrote:I have heard a rumour Cloke is going and they have a first rounder in mind for him which will go to picking up Aish or perhaps a direct swap. Seriously think they are probably paying something outside the cap though too.

Cloke?

Speaking of recruitment can someone help me out. The media seem to be reporting that both Treloar and Aish are going to Collingwood. According to a poster on here, Crozier is also keen on the Pies. Now firstly this proves the Pies have a competitive advantage in recruitment - mainly because they ar...

Every time I think about this bloke getting a gig at our footy club I shake my head. He's the worst recruiter in the business. No doubt he would love to trade pick 6 for Carlisle.

Pretty much your standard amateur level footy player

Billings and Lonie add some foot skills and they replace two with below average foot skills. Dunstan isnt too bad either.

Yes please

Parish is a combo mid. Does his best work as an outside mid however very capable of winning clearances. His playing style is a little bit like Marc Murphy. Less productive but more damaging. Parish is always heading towards goals and can break the lines. Will be a star IMO. Likely out of our reach ...

Parish is a combo mid. Does his best work as an outside mid however very capable of winning clearances. His playing style is a little bit like Marc Murphy. Less productive but more damaging. Parish is always heading towards goals and can break the lines. Will be a star IMO. Likely out of our reach n...

Any comparisons with Hogan at this stage are seriously unjust. Technically this is Hogans 3rd season in the AFL given he spent a year 2013 in the VFL and then had an injury interrupted 2014 (lower back injury) which would have been used predominantly to build up body strength. On VFL form, Hogan ki...

Pick 5 or 6

Between 07-10 Geelong were a team of bodybuilders. They were that much bigger than any other team. It was like West Coast circa 92-94.

MadSaintFan wrote:Not sure that you understand the deal - yes pick 6 goes to Ess, but pick 20 odd and Carlisle come the other way. We obtain Carlisle and move forward with 2 picks in the top 25.

Do we also give our 2nd rounder?

matrix wrote:looks youd consider it depending on the essendope saga
but id try to give them F*** all to get him
i mean if he is no good to play for over a year is that what we really want?

who is the sauce of this trade rumor ?

Finey

plugger66 wrote:

Old Mate wrote:

mambo2706 wrote:Is Dunstan injured, being rested or dropped?

'Sore'

Is that in between rested and dropped?

In between tanking and torn