Geez he gets his hands to the ball so frequently - will start clunking them.

Also - gets his bloody arms chopped so often, umps need to start paying frees.

We should have two Zac Jones But some slimy fish wanted an undersized tall forward with type 1 diabetes. We need hard at it skilled footballers, not wonderful families. PETRACCA Yep, saw a bit of him on the weekend and he looked great. If only... Apparently he is no good anyways... that’s what they...

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/teams/st-kilda/inside-story-behind-st-kilda-pulling-off-five-big-trades-last-year-including-securing-star-bradley-hill/news-story/65e8dd4cab3a5a1353fbfcf090d66531 Hi Saynta - that article is paywalled. Love to read it but unlikely to subscribe for a single art...

Didn't even know JJ was playing Sunday....

How did all those Doggies get votes?

Some ballsy selections finally. I'd still prefer Battle in over Ryder but overall I'm pretty happy with the team. It's a much more skilful side than we're used to. I'm expecting to see Clark move into the middle with Dunstan out. Geary, Paton, Coffield and Long is plenty of small defenders. Agreed....

Hunter Clark and auto selection for sure.

Dunstan has had his chance Too slow, below average footskills, struggles to mark overhead Lets face it he ain't going to improve us - we have better younger prospects Time to look and move forward Gives everything he has got but everything is not enough. Got nothing against the man but he is too sl...

Happy Coffield and Carlisle are in... very surprised Dunstan is our.

How soft are AFL players becoming ? I tend to agree on this case. Cloke had a great career but he was cooked. Even the greatest of them all - Plugger - was old and slow and useless in his final comeback year at Sydney. I don’t always buy the mental health card in every instance. Oh so only players ...

Was he that bad a president?

Better than Westaway... recruited Ross Lyon too.

Good to see that much needed move for his mental health which our club basically bent over backwards to grant for a prominent player has been worth it. :roll: I love Jack Steven and I'll always have nothing but fond memories of his time at the club but like with many things our club does this entir...

So Stuv has been stabbed. Maybe the lousy trade pick we got for him was fair value considering it appears he’s still messed up. Really sad situation for such a great player. Career over it seems. These are the types of posts I would show any player from any team when considering what the best optio...

So the VFL, sorry the pretend AFL, has reconstituted footy centred on old Melbourne town. What a joke. The only place in Australia where it’s not safe to be right now is Melbourne. Unidentified community transmission. Only place in OZ where that’s the case. We have an apartment in Melbourne that we...

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/sacked-podcast-brendon-goddard-reveals-he-pleaded-to-stay-at-st-kilda-before-sealing-essendon-switch/news-story/0aa4bf9159ac6e0d2c9af0fa73b6334c "Brendon Goddard thought the Saints had the 2010 Grand Final sewn up when put St Kilda a goal up lat...

Don’t have a lot of spare cash at the moment but pledged my membership as well as the 4 kid’s memberships, and also threw in a $200 donation to the club, would have been more but just can’t afford anymore at moment, misses wasn’t happy when she saw the bank statement (cat’s supporter) but she’ll ge...

Allowing Goddard to leave (forcing him out for a FA draft pick) is one of the worst list management decisions at the Saints over the last 20 years...

It’s a great tradition running into the ground and I hope it continues.

Blaming this on losing the game? Nah, load of crap.

People forget that we were 23 inside 50s up on Geelong at half time of the Grand Final. At the time it was a record. No team up to then had ever been +23 I50's at HT and lost. Ro$$ managed to raise the bar! Only St Kilda could do that and lose. There’s a much worse statistic that I heard and couldn...

People forget that we were 23 inside 50s up on Geelong at half time of the Grand Final. At the time it was a record. No team up to then had ever been +23 I50's at HT and lost. Ro$$ managed to raise the bar! Only St Kilda could do that and lose. There’s a much worse statistic that I heard and couldn...

People forget that we were 23 inside 50s up on Geelong at half time of the Grand Final. At the time it was a record. No team up to then had ever been +23 I50's at HT and lost. Ro$$ managed to raise the bar! This is what this thread has come to. Posters posting facts that support Lyon was a superb c...

Only 2 more visionaries required to get the percentage to shift another 0.001%. This thread could also help develop derived data from the core sample size to also compile the metrics for the "many voices" and "growing chorus", or the newly introduced, "a few people", &...

The really weak argument from those who have lauded his coaching and repeatedly claimed he was a great coach, was that some of us were dirty on Ross for the way that he left St Kilda and we changed our mind about him ‘only’ after he departed. There were quite a few voices criticising his methods an...

..with best-of-three GF. Please, please, pretty please, do not let this circus be an official AFL season with a real flag winner.. I am all for the fun and entertainment and re-couping some desperately needed cash - sounds great, but if they try to make it a legit season with a legit premiership it...

Should have been played by that useless tosser instead of his toyboy FFS in the 2009 grammie. I saw himthe following Sunday morning at Etihad . He was a shattered man. Disagree. Max was too much of a injury risk for 2009. Missed games through injury, lost his spot in a team that won 19 straight. Bi...