As much as I enjoy most of Milneys exploits and with all due respect to his goalkicking tally, I would find it extremely difficult to put him in a TOTC ahead of all the great resting rovers over the years or indeed ahead of Billy Young(given that FF is already spoken for).

Don't want to open old wounds but if you apply that theory to selections/moves in 09 Granny there may be 2 flags worth of regret!

Only one thing I don't get:How can a bloke be bad enough to delist when 3 weeks earlier he was good enough to play in GF2 whilst significantly injured?

Was 12 when Keddie fixed us up in 71 I think I cried a bit and its all downhill since. My kids tell me that post 97 is the only time they have seen me really drunk!

You forget to say that Banger makes a comeback in prelim final,and Armo runs through Luke Ball on the way to ironing out D.Thomas causing Sh..house and Eddie to weep in each others arms!

Ever wonder what a Hawthorn supporter in his/her fifties feels like compared to us. I remember 71 both sides going for their second flag, how many now, how time flies?

Heart still misses a beat every time Dawson is isolated ono on one, just wonder if we got another big defender if he may be better suited further up the ground?

Interested to know how/why/when people first became or realised they had become Saints Supporters.

Condom fitting on the syllabus ?

General consensus seems to be that all the whipping boys lifted tonight.Is that not what saints footy was supposed to be about?

Are we soft supporters , or are the commentators right about the negative game plan driving crowds away?

Don't see the level of enthusiasm on SS after such a great win that I would have expected.Did everybody turn off the radio @3q time (considered it myself as I live in the country and reception was about as good as our play in the 3rd). Anyway all is good for another week!

Great effort young man, Iwill be donating via your fundraising page and hope other Saints fans follow suit.I am sure your dad would be proud!

Why can't we make it easier on the umps? just about every other game in the world gives the ball to the opposite side of the player that touched it last.Throw ins could be retained for situations where it is unclear who touched the ball last.

Need a sense of humour right now, brother is a filth supporter.I told him during 09 prelim that all they needed was a good inside midfielder and a key forward to challenge, look on the bright side they didn't take Kozi as well as Ball

Toolamba indeed!

after 45 years following Saints you get a fairly thick hide, not much can penetrate the scar tissue!

From the little I saw of Dawson in Geelong game he seems to focus more on his man than the ball, and does not seem to have enough footy smarts to carry it off.[/quote]

coz I shave as often as Ablett gets pinged for holding the ball

Thank you,ggod to be unmuted?been watching board for long time but was unable to participate,probably a good thing the way we have been going recently.

After 16 months I finally emailed organisers and managed to activate account (thanks N1ck).Just in time jump on the bandwagon ,hope there's room.