AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

This unofficial St Kilda Saints fan forum is for people of all ages to chat Saints Footy and all posts must be respectful.

Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators

Post Reply
CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9428
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 130 times
Been thanked: 1198 times

AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576293Post CURLY »

Sydney have made finals 15 times out of 21 seasons. In the year they one they got Tippet for free then the following year got Buddy. Now after losing a GF they get gift a top 3 player at pick 17. Imagine us in 2008 buying Jarrod Roughead then the following year after playing in the 2009 GF getting Travis Cloke and with pick 17 getting Dustin Martin the following year getting Harly Bennel. In the mean time without the Swans gifts we've had to trade off Goddard Dal McCevoy even Dawson.

What a joke this league is.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
User avatar
Sainter_Dad
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6039
Joined: Thu 05 Jun 2008 1:04pm
Has thanked: 233 times
Been thanked: 1036 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576294Post Sainter_Dad »

It will be our turn when - and only when -

We do not kick 4 - 14 in a game of AFL football

(I have a million of these!)


“Youth ages, immaturity is outgrown, ignorance can be educated, and drunkenness sobered, but stupid lasts forever.”

― Aristophanes

If you have a Bee in your Bonnet - I can assist you with that - but it WILL involve some smacking upside the head!
CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9428
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 130 times
Been thanked: 1198 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576296Post CURLY »

Sainter_Dad wrote:It will be our turn when - and only when -

We do not kick 4 - 14 in a game of AFL football

(I have a million of these!)
If we had Goddard DaL Tippet Franklin and Heeney we would have.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
Toy Saint
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2203
Joined: Wed 19 Aug 2009 10:32pm
Location: Del Mar, California
Has thanked: 34 times
Been thanked: 237 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576338Post Toy Saint »

The AFL just sold broardcasting rights for $2.5m

About half of this value is derived from ratings in NSW & Queensland.

Sydney folk like watching winners, not losers.

The AFL CEO and his team are paid bonuses based on how much money they make.

So please don't think we'll ever get a 'turn'.


saintspremiers
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 25303
Joined: Tue 01 Feb 2005 4:25pm
Location: Trump Tower
Has thanked: 142 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576344Post saintspremiers »

Toy Saint wrote:The AFL just sold broardcasting rights for $2.5m

About half of this value is derived from ratings in NSW & Queensland.

Sydney folk like watching winners, not losers.

The AFL CEO and his team are paid bonuses based on how much money they make.

So please don't think we'll ever get a 'turn'.
That's very cynical.

But very true also.


i am Melbourne Skies - sometimes Blue Skies, Grey Skies, even Partly Cloudy Skies.
mr six o'clock
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 4260
Joined: Fri 17 Nov 2006 1:05am
Has thanked: 42 times
Been thanked: 233 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576364Post mr six o'clock »

saintspremiers wrote:
Toy Saint wrote:The AFL just sold broardcasting rights for $2.5m

About half of this value is derived from ratings in NSW & Queensland.

Sydney folk like watching winners, not losers.

The AFL CEO and his team are paid bonuses based on how much money they make.

So please don't think we'll ever get a 'turn'.
That's very cynical.

But very true also.
Agree


In red white and black from 73
Bunk_Moreland
SS Life Member
Posts: 3602
Joined: Wed 14 May 2014 7:45pm
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576368Post Bunk_Moreland »

mr six o'clock wrote:
saintspremiers wrote:
Toy Saint wrote:The AFL just sold broardcasting rights for $2.5m

About half of this value is derived from ratings in NSW & Queensland.

Sydney folk like watching winners, not losers.

The AFL CEO and his team are paid bonuses based on how much money they make.

So please don't think we'll ever get a 'turn'.
That's very cynical.

But very true also.
Agree
Likemost businessmen the AFL only care how much money they can squeeze out of the game and the fans in places like Melbourne and Tasmania can get stuffed.

More money in WWE type fake football and having Sydney team get favour after favour and millions upon million poued into them.


You are garbage - Enough said
bergholt
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 7356
Joined: Wed 11 Aug 2004 9:25am

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576369Post bergholt »

Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.


CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9428
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 130 times
Been thanked: 1198 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576372Post CURLY »

bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.

Take Tippet and Franklin out and see where they are at. A lot easier to create and maintain a good list with an extra million or more plus Academy players.

I'm sure a forward line of Jessie White and Sam Reid would have them top 4. NOT!


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
saynta
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 22524
Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 3:53pm
Has thanked: 8469 times
Been thanked: 3733 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576633Post saynta »

Been going on since Adam(Goodes) was a boy.

The AFL paid to steal Plugger from us.


terry smith rules
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2495
Joined: Mon 27 Jun 2005 1:27pm
Location: Abiding
Has thanked: 168 times
Been thanked: 357 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576634Post terry smith rules »

bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Exactly, throw in the likes of Rampe (rookie listed) Pyke (rookie) etc etc they have recruited very well and wisely

Don't forget they had to trade out Mumford (arguably the number one ruck before injured) to free up some money, that was a huge out


" A few will never give up on you. When you go back out on the field, those are the people I want in your minds. Those are the people I want in your hearts."

— Coach Eric Taylor - Friday Night Lights
CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9428
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 130 times
Been thanked: 1198 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576646Post CURLY »

terry smith rules wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Exactly, throw in the likes of Rampe (rookie listed) Pyke (rookie) etc etc they have recruited very well and wisely

Don't forget they had to trade out Mumford (arguably the number one ruck before injured) to free up some money, that was a huge out
All clubs have success stories with late picks and rookie players. What they dont get is access to a top 3 draft pick at 18 and two million dollar a year key forwards.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
terry smith rules
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2495
Joined: Mon 27 Jun 2005 1:27pm
Location: Abiding
Has thanked: 168 times
Been thanked: 357 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576648Post terry smith rules »

CURLY wrote:
terry smith rules wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Exactly, throw in the likes of Rampe (rookie listed) Pyke (rookie) etc etc they have recruited very well and wisely

Don't forget they had to trade out Mumford (arguably the number one ruck before injured) to free up some money, that was a huge out
All clubs have success stories with late picks and rookie players. What they dont get is access to a top 3 draft pick at 18 and two million dollar a year key forwards.
two weeks ago most thought Tippet was gone and a waste of money and Buddy not play again this year, not much success there, you can't have it both way (eg one when their winning and one when their losing)


" A few will never give up on you. When you go back out on the field, those are the people I want in your minds. Those are the people I want in your hearts."

— Coach Eric Taylor - Friday Night Lights
CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9428
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 130 times
Been thanked: 1198 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576656Post CURLY »

terry smith rules wrote:
CURLY wrote:
terry smith rules wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Exactly, throw in the likes of Rampe (rookie listed) Pyke (rookie) etc etc they have recruited very well and wisely

Don't forget they had to trade out Mumford (arguably the number one ruck before injured) to free up some money, that was a huge out
All clubs have success stories with late picks and rookie players. What they dont get is access to a top 3 draft pick at 18 and two million dollar a year key forwards.
two weeks ago most thought Tippet was gone and a waste of money and Buddy not play again this year, not much success there, you can't have it both way (eg one when their winning and one when their losing)
Cmon they made the Grand Final on the back of these two. Lets not try and down play this.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
Stephen Theodore
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2154
Joined: Mon 06 Aug 2007 1:53pm
Location: SE Queensland
Has thanked: 30 times
Been thanked: 16 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576672Post Stephen Theodore »

bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Very well said.

Whilst there's no doubt the AFL want Sydney to succeed, the majority of recruiting and admin decisions have been very good over a long period.


spert
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 8886
Joined: Wed 29 Jun 2005 10:39pm
Location: A distant beach
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 391 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576673Post spert »

terry smith rules wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Exactly, throw in the likes of Rampe (rookie listed) Pyke (rookie) etc etc they have recruited very well and wisely

Don't forget they had to trade out Mumford (arguably the number one ruck before injured) to free up some money, that was a huge out
The Swans just did things a lot smarter than us for a number of years in most areas- smarter and stronger leadership from the top, chose better coaches, and made the tough calls in recruiting and list management.


plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576677Post plugger66 »

spert wrote:
terry smith rules wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Exactly, throw in the likes of Rampe (rookie listed) Pyke (rookie) etc etc they have recruited very well and wisely

Don't forget they had to trade out Mumford (arguably the number one ruck before injured) to free up some money, that was a huge out
The Swans just did things a lot smarter than us for a number of years in most areas- smarter and stronger leadership from the top, chose better coaches, and made the tough calls in recruiting and list management.

Totally agree but losing by 100 points fires people up.


User avatar
Grimfang
Club Player
Posts: 1431
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:30am
Location: Tecoma, Vic.
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576688Post Grimfang »

Sydney certainly haven't had the burden of a completely dud stadium deal draining the coffers.


Do not meddle in the affairs of Dragons; for you are a quick and tasty morsel.
User avatar
HitTheBoundary
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2058
Joined: Fri 27 Feb 2009 9:00am
Location: Walkabout
Has thanked: 174 times
Been thanked: 68 times
Contact:

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576692Post HitTheBoundary »

bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Good post.
Depressing to read.


CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9428
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 130 times
Been thanked: 1198 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576696Post CURLY »

Stephen Theodore wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Very well said.

Whilst there's no doubt the AFL want Sydney to succeed, the majority of recruiting and admin decisions have been very good over a long period.

Campbell Heath, Ryan Fitzgerald, Jed Lamb, and a host of other burnt first rounders but it doesnt hurt when you can cherry pick the best in the AFL.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
Stephen Theodore
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2154
Joined: Mon 06 Aug 2007 1:53pm
Location: SE Queensland
Has thanked: 30 times
Been thanked: 16 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576718Post Stephen Theodore »

CURLY wrote:
Stephen Theodore wrote:
bergholt wrote:Dan Hannebery was pretty good today. The Swans took him with pick 30 in 2008. That year we took Tom Lynch with pick 13. He's playing pretty well at the moment too, but not for us.

Josh Kennedy was also pretty good. The Swans traded for him in 2009. Kennedy + Ben McGlynn cost them pick 39 (Sam Grimley), pick 46 (Ben Stratton) and pick 70 (Matt Suckling). At that point Kennedy had played 13 games. Since then he's won their B&F and been AA twice. In 2009 we traded for Andrew Lovett and Brett Peake, and took Nick Winmar, Jesse Smith, Adam Pattison and Will Johnson in the draft.

Heath Grundy was good today and has had a very solid career at full back, just keeps on keeping on. They took him with rookie pick 42 in 2004. That year we traded in Aaron Fiora and drafted Andrew McQualter, Cain Ackland, Mark McGough and James Gwilt.

Ted Richards also really good back there. They traded for him in 2005 when he'd only played 33 games, never more than 11 in a year. He cost picks 19 (Courtenay Dempsey) and 50 (Sam Lonergan), though they also got pick 54 back. That year we traded in Fergus Watts (for pick 17) and drafted Michael Rix, Phil Raymond and Justin Sweeney. Also Sam Gilbert at pick 33, who's still going pretty well. Nice to have success in there somewhere.


My point is that they've done a lot right over the last ten years, and that's why they're still going well. And conversely we've made some terrible decisions, and that's largely why we're not going so well. Believe what you want, but plenty of non-Sydney teams have won flags in the last 15 years and plenty more will in the next 15 years. Sooking about their advantages is pretty weak.
Very well said.

Whilst there's no doubt the AFL want Sydney to succeed, the majority of recruiting and admin decisions have been very good over a long period.

Campbell Heath, Ryan Fitzgerald, Jed Lamb, and a host of other burnt first rounders but it doesnt hurt when you can cherry pick the best in the AFL.
Like I said, the majority of their decisions have been very good, the same can't be said for our club. As also mentioned above, I agree the AFL want Sydney to succeed. It's not a level playing field and hasn't been for many years.


saintspremiers
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 25303
Joined: Tue 01 Feb 2005 4:25pm
Location: Trump Tower
Has thanked: 142 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576754Post saintspremiers »

Given how good the Swines have been in drafting, why the f*** have they been given salary cap concessions as well?

Shows how corrupted the AFL really are.


i am Melbourne Skies - sometimes Blue Skies, Grey Skies, even Partly Cloudy Skies.
plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576757Post plugger66 »

saintspremiers wrote:Given how good the Swines have been in drafting, why the f*** have they been given salary cap concessions as well?

Shows how corrupted the AFL really are.

Worked well getting rid of Brisbane's. And Sydney's is also going. I reckon you would rather keep it so you could complain. I have no doubt you love complaining.


saintspremiers
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 25303
Joined: Tue 01 Feb 2005 4:25pm
Location: Trump Tower
Has thanked: 142 times
Been thanked: 284 times

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576760Post saintspremiers »

plugger66 wrote:
saintspremiers wrote:Given how good the Swines have been in drafting, why the f*** have they been given salary cap concessions as well?

Shows how corrupted the AFL really are.

Worked well getting rid of Brisbane's. And Sydney's is also going. I reckon you would rather keep it so you could complain. I have no doubt you love complaining.
You are a bigger d**khead than I ever thought plugs.


i am Melbourne Skies - sometimes Blue Skies, Grey Skies, even Partly Cloudy Skies.
plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: AFL's Gifts to Sydney when's it our turn?

Post: # 1576761Post plugger66 »

saintspremiers wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
saintspremiers wrote:Given how good the Swines have been in drafting, why the f*** have they been given salary cap concessions as well?

Shows how corrupted the AFL really are.

Worked well getting rid of Brisbane's. And Sydney's is also going. I reckon you would rather keep it so you could complain. I have no doubt you love complaining.
You are a bigger d**khead than I ever thought plugs.

You know its true. Even if things change you will complain about the past.


Post Reply