Votes (St Kilda vs West Coast)

[battye]

5. Montagna
4. Milne
3. Kosi
2. Goddard
1. Dal Santo

A good team-wide effort in this game though, so hard to pick just five. Third quarter aside of course

Kosi had a great first game back, his first and fourth quarters were fantastic - and he and McEvoy in the ruck really took it to Cox and Natanui.

[bigcarl]

Peake
Clarke
Milne
Dal Santo
Gilbert

[karnak]

Monty
Clarke
Peake
Goddard
Dal

[SainterK]

Surely Dempster is in there?

Kept Embley to 12, 1/2 his season average, had 17 himself and kicked a goal on him.

Joey
Clarke
Dempster
Goddard
Peake

[SunburySaint]

Yeah Dempster and Raph both deserve to be in there

Montagna
Clarke
Dempster
Dal
Goddard

Honourable mentions Peake, Big Mac, Fisher and Schneids

[The Bluff]

5. Montagna
4. Milne
3. Kosi
2. Goddard
1. Dal Santo

A good team-wide effort in this game though, so hard to pick just five. Third quarter aside of course

Kosi had a great first game back, his first and fourth quarters were fantastic - and he and McEvoy in the ruck really took it to Cox and Natanui.

dude you must be joking - ruck is the only reason we nearly lost the game - minus 36 hitouts!

[perfectionist]

5. Leigh Montagna
4. Zac Dawson
3. Brett Peake
2. Sam Fisher
1. Dean Polo

[SainterK]

5. Montagna
4. Milne
3. Kosi
2. Goddard
1. Dal Santo

A good team-wide effort in this game though, so hard to pick just five. Third quarter aside of course

Kosi had a great first game back, his first and fourth quarters were fantastic - and he and McEvoy in the ruck really took it to Cox and Natanui.

dude you must be joking - ruck is the only reason we nearly lost the game - minus 36 hitouts!

To advantage though?

What good is that if they only just beat us in the clearances, and had a lower inside 50 count?

[Old Mate]

Montagna
Clarke
Dal Danto
Fisher
Dempster

[The Bluff]

5. Montagna
4. Milne
3. Kosi
2. Goddard
1. Dal Santo

A good team-wide effort in this game though, so hard to pick just five. Third quarter aside of course

Kosi had a great first game back, his first and fourth quarters were fantastic - and he and McEvoy in the ruck really took it to Cox and Natanui.

dude you must be joking - ruck is the only reason we nearly lost the game - minus 36 hitouts!

To advantage though?

What good is that if they only just beat us in the clearances, and had a lower inside 50 count?

Got them going forward which swung the game around. easily the best two players for west coast.

[battye]

5. Montagna
4. Milne
3. Kosi
2. Goddard
1. Dal Santo

A good team-wide effort in this game though, so hard to pick just five. Third quarter aside of course

Kosi had a great first game back, his first and fourth quarters were fantastic - and he and McEvoy in the ruck really took it to Cox and Natanui.

dude you must be joking - ruck is the only reason we nearly lost the game - minus 36 hitouts!

I wasn't aware of the stats, I'm pretty surprised that the deficit was that high. Cox and Natanui took some great grabs and Natunai had some pretty impressive passages of play, but I thought Kosi had good impact around the ground himself. Bar a couple of times where the ruck contest was uncontested (not sure what happened there) and when Natanui slapped the ball about 30 metres I thought McEvoy and Kosi held their own against what is touted as the best ruck duo in the competition.

The stats don't lie though! I guess I just felt we did better in the ruck than we actually did.

[kosifantutti23]

Montagna
Clarke
Gram
Dempster
Dawson

[doggerel]

5. Montagna
4. Clarke
3. Milne
2. Dempster
1. Peake

[stkildathunda]

5. Sean Dempster
4. Leigh Montagna
3. Raph Clarke
2. Nick Dal Santo
1. Brendon Goddard

[Moods]

5. dawson
4. Raph
3. Joey
2. Dal
1. Peake/Gram

[Armoooo]

5 - Montagna
4 - Dempster
3 - Goddard
2 - Peake
1 - Koschitzke

[bigcarl]

5. dawson
4. Raph
3. Joey
2. Dal
1. Peake/Gram

actually zac was pretty good.

[gringo]

I was at ground level and haven't got to look at a stat sheet to make my list look more credible but:

5 Montagna
4 Peake
3 Raph
2 Dempster
1 Dawson

but it was impossible to say that another 15 didn't deserve a vote for that game. Dal Santo, Polo, Gamble, Gram, Schnieder, Ray, Goddard, Fisher, Big Mac, Kosi, Steven, Armo etc. all made huge contributions tonight. Can't think of a player that didn't lift, Rooey had a quiet game by his huge standards but you can't say he lay down when things went against him.

[desertsaint]

joey
goddard
jones - unbelievable tackling tonight
dempster
chips

unlucky - dawson, clarke, dal - gram also had a decent game!

[mr six o'clock]

My top five would have to be a top ten
fantastic team effort !!!!

[RW&B]

5 Joey
4 Fisher
3 Dempster
2 BJ
1 Raph

[Toy Saint]

5. Peake
4. Joey
3. Raph
2. Dempster
1. Milne

[fugazi]

5. Dal Santo
4. Joey
3. Fisher
2. Gilbert
1. Dempster

[sRaf]

Dal Santo
Montagna
Milne
Clarke
Peake

Might not have been the best, but their games stuck out the most to me. Dal's been our best player all year.

[Junction Oval]

For me :

5 - Montagna
4 - Dempster
3 - Peake
2 - Clarke
1 - Dal Santo

Apologies to Gram & Goddard.