When is it the right time to rebuild?

This unofficial St Kilda Saints fan forum is for people of all ages to chat Saints Footy and all posts must be respectful.

Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators

Post Reply
End Of An Era
Club Player
Posts: 166
Joined: Wed 14 Sep 2011 11:40am

When is it the right time to rebuild?

Post: # 1137951Post End Of An Era »

I take it from most of the comments here that people do not believe we should rebuild. We peaked in 2009 and 2010 and now we are clearly on the slide. Yet people still think we should continue with this batch of players and a few trades and go again.

My question is..

WHEN SHOULD WE SAY WE GAVE IT OUR BEST SHOT AND FELL AGONIZINGLY SHORT AND UNFORTUNATELY IT IS TIME TO REBUILD THE PLAYING LIST?

Please discuss.


Thinline
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6043
Joined: Mon 21 May 2007 5:31pm
Location: Currumbin, Quoinslairnd

Post: # 1137952Post Thinline »

There's little point rebuilding now. We get nothing for bottoming out. So that means it's incumbent on us to fight like bastards next year.

And with the likes of Hayes, Goddard, Riewoldt (if fit), Dal Santo, Montagna, Milne and Fisher still well in the mix of the game's upper echelon, it seems to me there's still life in the old boy yet.

2013 and 2014 will be bottom outs for mine.


"The inches we need are everywhere around us. They're in every break in the game. Every minute, every second. On this team we fight for that inch. On this team we tear ourselves and everyone around us to pieces for that inch. We claw with our fingernails for that inch. Because we know when we add up all those inches that's gonna make the f***in' difference between winning and losing! Between living and dying!'
Sobraz
SS Life Member
Posts: 3399
Joined: Thu 29 Mar 2007 1:06pm
Has thanked: 2 times

Post: # 1137953Post Sobraz »

With all these new posters, it's going to become difficult to determine which new additions are trolls, and which are genuine..

With a name like 'end of an era', there's suspicion..

But in answering the question, never go for a full rebuild, just a constant turn over..

If we can develop 3-5 new, young faces in the side next year as regulars, along with Steven, Armo and McEvoy, that'd be a very different side to our 2009/10 GF sides..

Ledger, Sippos, Cripps and Walsh are all genuine possibilities for a consistent run next year, as well as Lynch and possibly Winmar...

Around our still young enough and strong core, the evolution can begin without too much disruption....

i.e. Geelong this year...


End Of An Era
Club Player
Posts: 166
Joined: Wed 14 Sep 2011 11:40am

Post: # 1137956Post End Of An Era »

Even the most optimistic (blind) of supporters must surely realize that we are no hope of winning the 2012 premiership. IMHO, we won't even make the top 8.

I think it is time to clear the decks and start again. The longer we put off rebuilding the longer it will be before we challenge again. Our core group of stars will never play in a premiership at St kilda. It's too late. With an ounce of luck, they should have won premierships in 2005, 2009 and 2010.


User avatar
Johnny Member
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 4157
Joined: Thu 05 Oct 2006 12:27pm
Been thanked: 1 time

Post: # 1137958Post Johnny Member »

It's all about the game plan.


Lyon needs to work out exactly what he thinks will win a flag in the next few years, then try to match a team that can carry it out successfully.

So the 'do we rebuild now?' question isn't really relevant.

It's more like 'how do we build the appropriate list to carry out the game plan that's going to win the flag for us?'.

And that should be happening right now. It should be happening all the time.


jonesy
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 4655
Joined: Sun 18 Jun 2006 2:04pm
Location: Melb
Has thanked: 5 times
Been thanked: 23 times

Post: # 1137960Post jonesy »

End Of An Era wrote:Even the most optimistic (blind) of supporters must surely realize that we are no hope of winning the 2012 premiership. IMHO, we won't even make the top 8.

I think it is time to clear the decks and start again. The longer we put off rebuilding the longer it will be before we challenge again. Our core group of stars will never play in a premiership at St kilda. It's too late. With an ounce of luck, they should have won premierships in 2005, 2009 and 2010.
Can leave luck out of the 05 premiership. Luck has nothing to do with disgraceful injury management and a half hearted effort from the playing group that partied like NYE 2000 immediatly after the siren


Bring back the Lockett era
Thinline
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6043
Joined: Mon 21 May 2007 5:31pm
Location: Currumbin, Quoinslairnd

Post: # 1137961Post Thinline »

If Geelong can bounce back from a prelim drubbing and the loss of Ablett to be a contender, I fail to see how St Kilda with it's quality core and (now) entrenched coach can't rebound after all that off-field s*** and the loss of Len Hayes and Jim Gwilt.

But then maybe I'm blind. I know positivity, however well-reasoned, really threatens some St Kilda people...


"The inches we need are everywhere around us. They're in every break in the game. Every minute, every second. On this team we fight for that inch. On this team we tear ourselves and everyone around us to pieces for that inch. We claw with our fingernails for that inch. Because we know when we add up all those inches that's gonna make the f***in' difference between winning and losing! Between living and dying!'
User avatar
PLUGGER14
Club Player
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri 16 Jul 2004 1:27pm
Location: Sydney

Post: # 1137962Post PLUGGER14 »

End Of An Era wrote:Even the most optimistic (blind) of supporters must surely realize that we are no hope of winning the 2012 premiership. IMHO, we won't even make the top 8.

I think it is time to clear the decks and start again. The longer we put off rebuilding the longer it will be before we challenge again. Our core group of stars will never play in a premiership at St kilda. It's too late. With an ounce of luck, they should have won premierships in 2005, 2009 and 2010.
sniff sniff...me smell something but I'll bite!

In the history of the draft there has never been a worse time to "clear the decks" than what we have now & for the next 2 drafts!


End Of An Era
Club Player
Posts: 166
Joined: Wed 14 Sep 2011 11:40am

Post: # 1137970Post End Of An Era »

It's amazing how people can look at the same thing yet see it totally differently. My view is that if we don't clear the decks this year it will just delay the inevitable anyway. You only need to look at other clubs that have been a top side for as long as St kilda. Since 2004 we have had a team capable of winning the flag. That's 8 years now. Have a look at the recent great teams of Brisbane and Essendon. Even they were not able to sustain it for so long. What has happened to them since?

No matter what the Saints do now, the next 4 years will be spent out of the finals. How well we bounce back depends on how low we bottom out.


User avatar
Joffa 5
Club Player
Posts: 334
Joined: Fri 10 Oct 2008 12:24pm
Location: Brisbane

Post: # 1137971Post Joffa 5 »

PLUGGER14 wrote: sniff sniff...me smell something but I'll bite!

In the history of the draft there has never been a worse time to "clear the decks" than what we have now & for the next 2 drafts!
I think the old schnoz is working just fine P14, there's no way any sane person would clear the decks now.


User avatar
borderbarry
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6676
Joined: Mon 19 Apr 2004 11:22pm
Location: Wodonga

Post: # 1137981Post borderbarry »

I would start rebuilding now, but do it over 2 or 3 years.


Thinline
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6043
Joined: Mon 21 May 2007 5:31pm
Location: Currumbin, Quoinslairnd

Post: # 1137994Post Thinline »

End Of An Era wrote:
No matter what the Saints do now, the next 4 years will be spent out of the finals. How well we bounce back depends on how low we bottom out.
You speak with such fluent authority on what the future holds I happily defer to you responsibility for my lotto numbers...


"The inches we need are everywhere around us. They're in every break in the game. Every minute, every second. On this team we fight for that inch. On this team we tear ourselves and everyone around us to pieces for that inch. We claw with our fingernails for that inch. Because we know when we add up all those inches that's gonna make the f***in' difference between winning and losing! Between living and dying!'
User avatar
stkildathunda
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2176
Joined: Mon 10 Aug 2009 11:03am
Location: Inside The Circle Of Zen
Contact:

Post: # 1138000Post stkildathunda »

borderbarry wrote:I would start rebuilding now, but do it over 2 or 3 years.
This.. Cant be bothered writing it all out again so will just copy my thoughts from TS & BF

Im not saying we dont need a rebuild but we have to be careful of how we go about it. Cant just drop all our experienced players at once. Especially given the shallow & compromised draft that confronts us this year.. Those players listed have NO value on the open market. All we'll be doing is replacing them with blokes from picks 70-120 in the draft.. and what do thsoe picks get us? Dean Polo, Ryan Gamble...

Id much rather us start at the bottom and ditch the blokes from 35-44 on our list (or whatever it is) and then bring in new batch of kids and rotate them through like we did this year. Then next year work on the next batch of players, whether thats the Polo's, Gambles. Still gotta have a eye on winning and not completely stuffing things up and becoming a rabble like Port Adelaide.


If we look at our current list we have 3 senior spots (Gardiner, Baker, McQualter) and 2 rookie spots (Eddy & Gaertner). So have to assume Tommy Walsh gets elevated which leaves 2 senior spots and 3 rookie spots.

I think Paul Cahill needs to go, been on the list for few years and not really showing anything. Nicholas Heyne has struggled but has another year left so will be rookied. Also think Archer will have to go back down to allow the Long Term Injuries to return.

DELISTED/RETIRED
Michael Gardiner
Steven Baker
Andrew McQualter
Robert Eddy (Rookie)
Paul Cahill
Steven Gaertner (not officially listed but we never replaced him)
Alistar Smith

ROOKIE LISTED
Nicholas Heyne
Daniel Archer


So basically would leave us 5 senior spots (4 if Walsh comes up) and reckon thats all the picks we will use this year. Add these 5 guys to last years kids in Cripps, Siposs, Ledger, Crocker and our bottom 10 looks bit better. That would also leave us with only like 30 senior experienced players on our list. We all sudden become a much younger list. Then next year we do the same thing.

Then if you add any trades of players, but who realistically would take some of them? The likes of Ray, Polo, Gamble, Geary are extremely good depth players if it comes to that. If you had those types guys as your 25-30 picked players we all sudden are looking as strong as Collingwood.

One thing Pelchan & Ross are is smart. They will rebuild the list smartly. They will possibly even do the "Sydney" style of rebuild where you spot target the young blokes on the fringe of top sides that cant quite get games. Eg Shane Mumford, Josh Kennedy, Ben McGlynn.. Who all had massive part in our undoing last night...

Half rebuild part of the list this year and then do the other part next year when the draft is back to normal, and as its another "superdraft" like the 2001.....


User avatar
skeptic
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 17028
Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 7:10pm
Has thanked: 3647 times
Been thanked: 2918 times

Post: # 1138004Post skeptic »

it's never abad time to cut deadwood...

just need to get rid of slow players and players with poor disposal that don't make up for it

lets slowly start weeding them out


shmic_s
Club Player
Posts: 966
Joined: Tue 03 Feb 2009 4:25pm
Has thanked: 24 times
Been thanked: 9 times

Post: # 1138016Post shmic_s »

Geelong, Sydney, Hawthorn have all shown that you can be competitive while doing a mini-rebuild. No reason why we can't do the same.


User avatar
borderbarry
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6676
Joined: Mon 19 Apr 2004 11:22pm
Location: Wodonga

Post: # 1138046Post borderbarry »

I think you will find that now the season has finished both Archer and Walsh have returned to the Rookie list.


User avatar
SaintPav
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 19099
Joined: Wed 16 Jun 2010 9:24pm
Location: Alma Road
Has thanked: 1603 times
Been thanked: 2018 times

Post: # 1138050Post SaintPav »

How many of these guys will be any good and how long will it take?

If half these guys can't play we are rooted.


Cripps
Ledger
Siposs
Crocker
Walsh
Ferguson
Curren
Winmar
Stanley
Lynch


Holder of unacceptable views and other thought crimes.
shmic_s
Club Player
Posts: 966
Joined: Tue 03 Feb 2009 4:25pm
Has thanked: 24 times
Been thanked: 9 times

Post: # 1138084Post shmic_s »

SaintPav wrote:How many of these guys will be any good and how long will it take?

If half these guys can't play we are rooted.


Cripps
Ledger
Siposs
Crocker
Walsh
Ferguson
Curren
Winmar
Stanley
Lynch
Half would be what i'd expect. If four or five of those guys can come on, then we won't suffer all this doom and gloom imo.

Problem is finding a game breaker. Finding the next Milne or Hayes. But it doesn't happen overnight.
The odds are long, but say Stanely could be mentioned in the same breath as Mitch Clarke in 2 years. Or Walsh finally getting a game and growing into Dawes type player.

If Cripps, Ledger, Siposs, Walsh and Stanely type players become AFL level, we could challenge again. Just have to get them to AFL level.
Enter Ross Lyon his team.


End Of An Era
Club Player
Posts: 166
Joined: Wed 14 Sep 2011 11:40am

Post: # 1138120Post End Of An Era »

My opinion is this.
If Goddard signs on with GWS at the end of next year then that should be the catalyst for us to go into a full on rebuild. We should get 2 top 10 picks for him. We should then trade others that have currency for more early draft picks. Reiwoldt, Dal Santo. and Montagna even.


User avatar
meher baba
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 7223
Joined: Mon 14 Aug 2006 6:49am
Location: Tasmania
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 516 times

Post: # 1138137Post meher baba »

If Lenny and Gwilt come back fit and firing, and if one or two more of the young players come on (Walsh or Siposs up forward, Cripps or Ledger in the middle) we are a reasonable show for a premiership next year.

2013 is also not totally out of the question IMO.

After that, I'd be looking to start rebuilding right away, possibly under a new coach.


"It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into."
- Jonathan Swift
User avatar
ralphsmith
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2420
Joined: Sat 25 Jul 2009 10:36pm
Has thanked: 3 times
Been thanked: 17 times

Post: # 1138148Post ralphsmith »

We're in a really difficult situation.

Our top end are still good enough to probably get us to the finals but not win a grand final.

They're not old enough to retire, not young enough (energy, drive, passion, enthusiasm, vibrance) to win a grand final.

They are past their peak but not so far past it as to justify throwing in the towel.


We will be older and slower next year.

Not sure what Ross is to do in the big scheme of things.

In the mean time it's absolutely imperative we replace the players who can't kick and/or have bad awareness/footy smarts

We all know who they are.


What is dead may never die, but rises again harder and stronger.
Image
End Of An Era
Club Player
Posts: 166
Joined: Wed 14 Sep 2011 11:40am

Post: # 1138174Post End Of An Era »

meher baba wrote:If Lenny and Gwilt come back fit and firing, and if one or two more of the young players come on (Walsh or Siposs up forward, Cripps or Ledger in the middle) we are a reasonable show for a premiership next year.

2013 is also not totally out of the question IMO
.

After that, I'd be looking to start rebuilding right away, possibly under a new coach.
I'm sorry to say meher babe but you have absolutely no idea.


User avatar
saintlee
Club Player
Posts: 1331
Joined: Mon 26 Mar 2007 12:57pm
Location: Melbourne

Post: # 1138199Post saintlee »

meher baba wrote:If Lenny and Gwilt come back fit and firing, and if one or two more of the young players come on (Walsh or Siposs up forward, Cripps or Ledger in the middle) we are a reasonable show for a premiership next year.

2013 is also not totally out of the question IMO.
Gee, I wish I was that optimistic!

I reckon we are spent as a premiership chance...at best we may crack top 4 next year if all our best players can have good years. But I can't see us threatening the best with the current group.


plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Post: # 1138203Post plugger66 »

SaintPav wrote:How many of these guys will be any good and how long will it take?

If half these guys can't play we are rooted.


Cripps
Ledger
Siposs
Crocker
Walsh
Ferguson
Curren
Winmar
Stanley
Lynch
Depends on what you call play. I would expect one 200 game player and 2 one hundred game players and the rest less than 50 based on the pick numbers. None of them will replace Hayes, Milne, Rooy, Joey, Dal, or Chips all of who will nearly bbe finished when these players start producing consistantly. Our last year with even a slight chance is next year. After that it is a complete rebuild IMO.


SainterK
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 21057
Joined: Thu 14 Aug 2008 9:53pm
Location: Melb

Post: # 1138318Post SainterK »

I'm with MB, I reckon if everything aligned next year, Saints would be a chance.


Post Reply