realdeal wrote:longtimesaint wrote:J-Boy061979 wrote:How about this:
Pick 5 and 23 to Crows for 9,13 & 28.
9 goes to Bombers for Carlisle.
29 goes to Collingwood for Freeman
Adelaide rumoured to be keen on Francis who wouldn't be available at 9 but would at 5.
Bombers get pick 9
Pies get pick 28
Saints end up with Carlisle, Freeman and pick 13
It's great but how do we sell it to the crows?
If crows are really keen for Francis then they need a higher pick than they currently have.. After the Dangerfield trade they have a fair few draft picks. This way I guess they can consolidate those picks to ensure they get the player they want, whilst upgrading their 2nd round pick.
I like the scenario, although, the way Essendon have behaved I don't even want them getting pick 9.,
Adelaide would want pick 4 from Essendon as part of any arrangement with Essendon getting pick 5.
They would also want to come out of the deal ahead not way behind as above.
Adelaide would accept pick 4 and pick 24 (2,819 points) in exchange for pick 9 and pick 13 (2681 points).
St Kilda would give up pick 5 and 24 = (2,663 points) in exchange for pick 13 (1,212 points) and Carlilse
Carlisle costs St Kilda 1,415 points (pick 9 = 1,469 points & pick 10 = 1,395 points)
Essendon would get pick 5 and pick 9 (3,347 points) by giving up pick 4 (2,034 points) and Carlisle.
Essendon sells Carlilse for 1,313 points roughly pick 11 = 1,329 points.
Adelaide wins by making the trade possible
Essendon gets a decent price for Carlisle roughly pick 11
St Kilda make the deal happen by rewarding Adelaide with a bonus of 138 points.
StKilda gives up pick 5 and 24 to get Carlisle and pick 13.
St Kilda then needs to split pick 13 (1,212 points) in two, so they can trade for Freeman.
Or give Collingwood pick 13 in return for Freeman and a second round pick.
e.g St Kilda gives up pick 13 and pick 63 (112 points to Collingwood) and receives pick 26 (729 points)
Values Freeman at 595 points between picks 31 & 32 (pick 31 606 points & pick 32 = 584 points)
We get Carlise, Freeman and pick 26 for pick 5, 24, 63.
Essendon get pick 5 and 9 for pick 4 and Carlisle
Adelaide get pick 4 and 24 for picks 9 and 13
We then have picks 26 and 45 to secure Bailey Rice
If we don't use pick 26 for Rice we would risk him being taken between picks 27 and 33 and not having enough points.
Trading pick 26 down to 30 in return for raising pick 44 would solve this dilemna.
BUT nothing will happen so long as Dildo keeps playing with himself over the value of Carlisle.
The more you know, the more you know you don't know.
When I was a young child, I knew that I knew so much about so much.
Now that I am old and know so much more, I know that I know so much about so little, and so little about so much.
