Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Impatient Sainter wrote: ↑Fri 12 May 2023 3:41pm
Cooper's position going forward if he breaks into the side will be as a tall wingman, exactly how they have been developing him at VFL level. He is progressing well and I think we saw enough last week to see he has a future in that role.
The thing that impressed me about Sharman , aside from his tank development, was his footy smarts
He makes v good decisions with ball in hand and his field kicking is quality
I’d like to see a bit more in that role but if he keeps going I suspect Vort change his Nic ….embarrassing
Devilhead wrote: ↑Wed 10 May 2023 5:27pm
Hey Vort ... did you see the contested speccy mark Sharman took ...... you know that player that you said was devoid of contested mark skills
Yeah it was a ripper, if he keeps up his average of 3 games a season he should have quite the highlights real after he's delisted.
When are you going to put the money on the bar like you promised Vort?
I'm so sorry HF, you missed out, open bar has been and gone.
Don't worry I shout whenever we win a flag
I don’t think you would shout if a shark bit you.
If I though you were thirsty enough I'd buy you a beer, but I'm not even sure you are a drinker.
Cup of tea love?
No mate, I enjoy a beer, a good red wine and just the occasional whisky.
Rugby League would have to be the stupidest, most moronic and over rated game of all time.
I imagine a player like Sharman, who is very much a ‘Fringe player’ at this point in time, has to be very careful about where he runs and kicks in the RYB scheme of things.
No margin for error.
Ross Lyon reads the plaudits and praises a player like Cordy for a one possession game (after dragging him at 3/4 time, and dropping him) so there is no space for a loose imagination for Sharman.
Which makes it perhaps harder for him to shine and show his goods.
Someone like Pou can get away with skylarking on account of his youth. Not Sharman. Third year on the list
Devilhead wrote: ↑Wed 10 May 2023 5:27pm
Hey Vort ... did you see the contested speccy mark Sharman took ...... you know that player that you said was devoid of contested mark skills
Yeah it was a ripper, if he keeps up his average of 3 games a season he should have quite the highlights real after he's delisted.
When are you going to put the money on the bar like you promised Vort?
I'm so sorry HF, you missed out, open bar has been and gone.
Don't worry I shout whenever we win a flag
I don’t think you would shout if a shark bit you.
I think the real question should be who wants to drink at a bar that shuts down for a week if someone puts a measly $10K on the bar.
That's like 120 beers a day or 8 bottles of wine.
It must be a back yard shed in some s*** hole somewhere.
The whole week funding equates to a lunch or dinner and drinks for a group of 20, not shut down a bar for a week
There's only one rule in the jungle! When the LYON's hungry, he eats!
Devilhead wrote: ↑Wed 10 May 2023 5:27pm
Hey Vort ... did you see the contested speccy mark Sharman took ...... you know that player that you said was devoid of contested mark skills
Yeah it was a ripper, if he keeps up his average of 3 games a season he should have quite the highlights real after he's delisted.
When are you going to put the money on the bar like you promised Vort?
I'm so sorry HF, you missed out, open bar has been and gone.
Don't worry I shout whenever we win a flag
I don’t think you would shout if a shark bit you.
If I though you were thirsty enough I'd buy you a beer, but I'm not even sure you are a drinker.
Cup of tea love?
No mate, I enjoy a beer, a good red wine and just the occasional whisky.
Mate I recon as saints men we'd enjoy a drink after a great win...we all would in reality.
Devilhead wrote: ↑Wed 10 May 2023 5:27pm
Hey Vort ... did you see the contested speccy mark Sharman took ...... you know that player that you said was devoid of contested mark skills
Yeah it was a ripper, if he keeps up his average of 3 games a season he should have quite the highlights real after he's delisted.
When are you going to put the money on the bar like you promised Vort?
I'm so sorry HF, you missed out, open bar has been and gone.
Don't worry I shout whenever we win a flag
I don’t think you would shout if a shark bit you.
I think the real question should be who wants to drink at a bar that shuts down for a week if someone puts a measly $10K on the bar.
That's like 120 beers a day or 8 bottles of wine.
It must be a back yard shed in some s*** hole somewhere.
The whole week funding equates to a lunch or dinner and drinks for a group of 20, not shut down a bar for a week
Well, that’s not pub food money bags. That’s $500 per head so someone must really like their premium booze.
Holder of unacceptable views and other thought crimes.
Devilhead wrote: ↑Wed 10 May 2023 5:27pm
Hey Vort ... did you see the contested speccy mark Sharman took ...... you know that player that you said was devoid of contested mark skills
Yeah it was a ripper, if he keeps up his average of 3 games a season he should have quite the highlights real after he's delisted.
When are you going to put the money on the bar like you promised Vort?
I'm so sorry HF, you missed out, open bar has been and gone.
Don't worry I shout whenever we win a flag
I don’t think you would shout if a shark bit you.
If I though you were thirsty enough I'd buy you a beer, but I'm not even sure you are a drinker.
Cup of tea love?
No mate, I enjoy a beer, a good red wine and just the occasional whisky.
Mate I recon as saints men we'd enjoy a drink after a great win...we all would in reality.
Probably, in the event of a Premiership I’ll drink with anyone and ge pissed for a week.
Rugby League would have to be the stupidest, most moronic and over rated game of all time.
Devilhead wrote: ↑Wed 10 May 2023 5:27pm
Hey Vort ... did you see the contested speccy mark Sharman took ...... you know that player that you said was devoid of contested mark skills
Yeah it was a ripper, if he keeps up his average of 3 games a season he should have quite the highlights real after he's delisted.
When are you going to put the money on the bar like you promised Vort?
I'm so sorry HF, you missed out, open bar has been and gone.
Don't worry I shout whenever we win a flag
I don’t think you would shout if a shark bit you.
If I though you were thirsty enough I'd buy you a beer, but I'm not even sure you are a drinker.
Cup of tea love?
No mate, I enjoy a beer, a good red wine and just the occasional whisky.
Mate I recon as saints men we'd enjoy a drink after a great win...we all would in reality.
Probably, in the event of a Premiership I’ll drink with anyone and ge pissed for a week.
you absolute lightweight, I have vowed to be pissed for a year.
D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Fri 12 May 2023 7:36pm
I think the real question should be who wants to drink at a bar that shuts down for a week if someone puts a measly $10K on the bar.
That's like 120 beers a day or 8 bottles of wine.
It must be a back yard shed in some s*** hole somewhere.
The whole week funding equates to a lunch or dinner and drinks for a group of 20, not shut down a bar for a week
Can I be one of the 20 that has a dinner costing $10K??
“Youth ages, immaturity is outgrown, ignorance can be educated, and drunkenness sobered, but stupid lasts forever.”
― Aristophanes
If you have a Bee in your Bonnet - I can assist you with that - but it WILL involve some smacking upside the head!
D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Fri 12 May 2023 7:36pm
I think the real question should be who wants to drink at a bar that shuts down for a week if someone puts a measly $10K on the bar.
That's like 120 beers a day or 8 bottles of wine.
It must be a back yard shed in some s*** hole somewhere.
The whole week funding equates to a lunch or dinner and drinks for a group of 20, not shut down a bar for a week
Can I be one of the 20 that has a dinner costing $10K??
Done, I'll host the dinner for 20 saintsationalists if we win the flag this year!
Sainter Dad and Sainter Boy are on the table!
There's only one rule in the jungle! When the LYON's hungry, he eats!
D.B.Cooper wrote: ↑Fri 12 May 2023 7:36pm
I think the real question should be who wants to drink at a bar that shuts down for a week if someone puts a measly $10K on the bar.
That's like 120 beers a day or 8 bottles of wine.
It must be a back yard shed in some s*** hole somewhere.
The whole week funding equates to a lunch or dinner and drinks for a group of 20, not shut down a bar for a week
Can I be one of the 20 that has a dinner costing $10K??
Done, I'll host the dinner for 20 saintsationalists if we win the flag this year!
Sainter Dad and Sainter Boy are on the table!
We will be there - but if you think I am opinionated - well - lets just say - there are lively discussions in our house
“Youth ages, immaturity is outgrown, ignorance can be educated, and drunkenness sobered, but stupid lasts forever.”
― Aristophanes
If you have a Bee in your Bonnet - I can assist you with that - but it WILL involve some smacking upside the head!
Vortex wrote: ↑Sun 14 May 2023 6:33pm
This thread didn't age well.
Ironically Coops played North and Crows last year and was dropped.
Cordy straight back in but only becaue Sharman is way off the pace.
I don’t get you Vort
You went completely absent when he played well and wouldn’t offer so much as a compliment…
Threw up the old sample size argument and are the first to beat your chest with glee that I can feel despite it being online when the kid struggles.
My gut tells me you’re a bit on the unpleasant side.
His game still is at least on par with what Cordy produced who for some reason you heap the praise but if you make the sample size argument… it should still be too early to make a call. One good game, one poor one.
Vortex wrote: ↑Sun 14 May 2023 6:33pm
This thread didn't age well.
Ironically Coops played North and Crows last year and was dropped.
Cordy straight back in but only becaue Sharman is way off the pace.
I don’t get you Vort
You went completely absent when he played well and wouldn’t offer so much as a compliment…
Threw up the old sample size argument and are the first to beat your chest with glee that I can feel despite it being online when the kid struggles.
My gut tells me you’re a bit on the unpleasant side.
His game still is at least on par with what Cordy produced who for some reason you heap the praise but if you make the sample size argument… it should still be too early to make a call. One good game, one poor one.
Why do you keep bringing Cordy into the discussion on Sharman, has nothing to do with the fact he is just not AFL standard.
The issues with Cordy are a completely different set of problems.
And I already explained to you I didn't feel he was deserving of a compliment as he gathered some cheap stats against an ammo side, ironically he played North and Crows last year and was dropped, you may not like my belief in reference points and sample sizes but they are meaningful measurements of players ability.
Vortex wrote: ↑Sun 14 May 2023 6:33pm
This thread didn't age well.
Ironically Coops played North and Crows last year and was dropped.
Cordy straight back in but only becaue Sharman is way off the pace.
I don’t get you Vort
You went completely absent when he played well and wouldn’t offer so much as a compliment…
Threw up the old sample size argument and are the first to beat your chest with glee that I can feel despite it being online when the kid struggles.
My gut tells me you’re a bit on the unpleasant side.
His game still is at least on par with what Cordy produced who for some reason you heap the praise but if you make the sample size argument… it should still be too early to make a call. One good game, one poor one.
Why do you keep bringing Cordy into the discussion on Sharman, has nothing to do with the fact he is just not AFL standard.
The issues with Cordy are a completely different set of problems.
And I already explained to you I didn't feel he was deserving of a compliment as he gathered some cheap stats against an ammo side, ironically he played North and Crows last year and was dropped, you may not like my belief in reference points and sample sizes but they are meaningful measurements of players ability.
Sharman has something over you Vort, me, and just about everyone else on this forum.
He has played AFL football.
Maybe the rule on this forum should be something like, have you played AFL football? If not, then keep your comments to yourself.
Rugby League would have to be the stupidest, most moronic and over rated game of all time.
