Zak Jones

[Mr Magic]

Robert Eddy played in 3 grand finals

[D.B.Cooper]

Ahh

Herald Sun - that’d be accurate!

Jones never played in the midfield

He was never going to get a look in, they had A Graders in there Kennedy, Parker, McVeigh, Jack, Hannebery

They played in a GF in 2016
Zak was in the team

Who said he played mid at Sydney?

HS is crap, but better than making up salaries

Zac is an AFL standard player, but is not a quality AFL midfielder.

You can overrate him all you wish, it appears the coach doesn't necessarily rate him as highly as you.

[SaintPav]

If his body holds up, I’d think of keeping him on for one more season for depth only.

It really depends on how many vacancies are on the list.

[B.M]

For the LAST time

Eddy did NOT play in the 2009 GF

And counting 2010 as two seperate GFs is also folly

Both games were played for 1 cup

[B.M]

I rate him as a B-C grade player

Not a quality mid

Perhaps a 5th mid

Ross doesn’t like him - that’s apparent


That doesn’t mean much - he looks for scapegoats
Luke Ball was one

[SaintPav]

1x 2010 AFL Grand Final

1x 2010 Grand Grand Final Replay

They count as two separate and distinct games, albeit playing for the same premiership, but one was clearly a GF replay and counts as such.

[Mr Magic]

For the LAST time

Eddy did NOT play in the 2009 GF

And counting 2010 as two seperate GFs is also folly

Both games were played for 1 cup

McQualter did though
And
do they count as 2 games played for the individual players’ games tally?
AFAIK every player who played in both of 2010 GF is credited with both.

[Moods]

For the LAST time

Eddy did NOT play in the 2009 GF

And counting 2010 as two seperate GFs is also folly

Both games were played for 1 cup

Tell Leon Davis that, or Ben McEvoy. Or the Collingwood bloke who kicked the first goal in the replay.

[B.M]

You said Eddy played in 3 GFs - he did not

McQualter had an excellent 2009 and was an important player

It’s more accurate to say
He played in one GF and a GF replay

[Mr Magic]

You said Eddy played in 3 GFs - he did not

McQualter had an excellent 2009 and was an important player

It’s more accurate to say
He played in one GF and a GF replay

Congratulations
I made an error in saying he played in 3 grand finals
He only played in 2 in 2010 (including the replay)
Unlike you, I’m prepared to admit to a mistake

But it doesn’t matter
You made the point that Jones played in a GF as if that bolstered your argument as to him being a better player than others have pegged him as.
I merely pointed out another player who nobody can claim as a superstar also played in a GF
But it’s ok
I realise you take offence when anybody questions your superior knowledge on football matters on here.
Feel free to have the last word on this - I’m done on this now

[B.M]

No

I don’t take offence

I just pointed out your mistake

Where did I ever say Zak was a gun midfielder

Again, I just pointed out the wrong comment that he has rarely ever go on the park or played consistently

I just stated that he did in Sydney playing in a far better team

[Yorkeys]

A point of agreement!
We all agree Zac is not a gun.
But how do we persuade the selectors, or doesn't Zac need any help with that.

[Otiman]

I think Jones will struggle to get a game again this season.

Will need to reinvent himself outside of the midfield as guys like Garcia, Dow, and Windhager will all be selected ahead of him.

[B.M]

Only playing because Dow and Crouch are out

He’ll be dropped- Ross is not a fan